For individual old, bound or delicate recipe pages, a flatbed scanner is usually the better option; a suitable document feeder can process many sturdy, loose sheets more quickly. Check the condition of the originals before placing them on the glass or feeding them through, and choose an ink cartridge or tank model based on how much you’ll print beyond the school project. Scan resolution, file formats and the rights to text and images are separate points to check.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Families with delicate originals
If you want to digitise old recipe pages that may be fragile or bound for a school project, think about how to handle the originals safely. The Library of Congress recommends taking their condition into account throughout the whole process.
Families with lots of loose recipe sheets
If you have lots of sturdy, individual sheets, consider whether a feeder is suitable or whether you should place each sheet on the flatbed glass separately. Canon lists a single-sided automatic document feeder for the PIXMA TS7750i.
Households that print for school regularly
If you also print regularly beyond the project, consider your print volume and the consumables required for the specific model. Manufacturers’ information about cartridges or ink tanks applies to particular models and usage conditions.
What should you look for when buying?
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| Capture old originals gently |
Check the flatbed glass and supported size. For damaged or bound pages, make sure they can be placed on the glass without pressure. |
If my recipe pages are fragile or bound, I want to scan them individually without forcing them flat. Around 36% of consumers prioritise protecting delicate originals. |
| Clear, legible recipe scans |
Compare the scan resolution, colour scanning and file formats supported by the specific model. |
If small print, handwriting or illustrations need to remain clear in my project file, I check the scan specifications rather than the print resolution. Around 29% of consumers prioritise easily legible recipe scans. |
| Further printing needs |
Consider how many black-and-white and colour pages you expect to print, as well as the compatible cartridges or ink bottles. |
If I’ll still be printing worksheets or recipe copies after the project, I want to understand the running costs of the specific model. Around 21% of consumers prioritise the cost of consumables for further printing. |
| Scan lots of loose pages quickly |
Check the ADF capacity and whether it scans single- or double-sided against the full model name. |
If I have lots of sturdy, loose sheets, I want to avoid placing them on the glass one by one, without feeding unsuitable old pages through the machine. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the speed of scanning suitable loose sheets. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming the document feeder is suitable for every old recipe page
A feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets; it isn’t automatically the gentlest option for fragile, damaged or bound originals.
Check the condition and size first. Use the ADF only for sheets that are suitable for it, and handle delicate originals individually.
-
Confusing print resolution with scan resolution
Print resolution doesn’t tell you how much detail a recipe scan will capture.
Look specifically for the scan resolution and supported file formats in the technical specifications.
-
Judging by an advertised ink yield alone
How much ink you use depends on how much you print. Manufacturers’ claims about yields or potential savings are based on their own usage assumptions.
Factor in any further printing you expect to do and the consumables compatible with the model.
-
Assuming an earlier place on a list proves a model is still available
An entry in a review list doesn’t confirm that the model is still on sale. Epson Germany lists the EcoTank ET-4850 as no longer available.
Check the model identity and current availability separately; don’t assume a successor is the same as the model on the list.
Printer brands to consider
Canon
The PIXMA TS7750i combines colour printing with scanning via the flatbed glass. Canon lists a single-sided automatic document feeder with a capacity of up to 35 sheets for this model.
- For suitable loose sheets, the ADF can save you from placing each one on the glass individually.
- Automatic duplex printing doesn’t necessarily mean double-sided scanning: Canon describes the feeder as single-sided.
Epson
EcoTank models differ in how they scan. The ET-2950 is a tank printer with scanning, while Epson lists a double-sided automatic document feeder for the ET-4950.
- For suitable loose sheets with content on both sides, the ET-4950 may offer a suitable feeder.
- Epson Germany currently lists the ET-2950 as unavailable and the ET-4850 as no longer available. The manufacturer’s claims about yields or savings aren’t an individual estimate of your usage.
Brother
Brother describes the DCP-J1260W as a compact colour all-in-one printer with USB, Wi-Fi and individually replaceable LC521 cartridges.
- You can check the connectivity and cartridge type against the needs of your household.
- Brother’s claim that the supplied ink can print up to 200 pages in black and colour isn’t a forecast for individually designed recipe pages. Check how scanning works against the full model specifications.
HP
HP lists a flatbed scanner for the Smart Tank 7000 series. Double-sided scanning is listed as a model feature for the OfficeJet Pro 9120e.
- The two models offer different options: a flatbed scanner on the Smart Tank 7005 and double-sided scanning on the OfficeJet Pro 9120e.
- These features apply to the models named or the specified series, not to all HP printers. For the OfficeJet Pro 9120e, check the terms relating to dynamic security and optional services.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy products offer scanning and printing for individual recipe pages. If you have delicate or bound originals, check whether you can place them on the scanner without applying damaging pressure.
No image available
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 mono laser all-in-one printer
The flatbed glass lets you place recipe pages on the scanner individually. With delicate originals, make sure they can be scanned without applying damaging pressure.
Optical scan resolution: 1200 × 1200 dpi. Colour scanning and flatbed scanner; A4 mono laser printer with 22 ppm. Dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet.
Joybuy
No image available
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg
The flatbed scanner lets you place individual recipe pages on the glass. With old or delicate originals, make sure you can do this without applying damaging pressure.
Colour laser all-in-one printer with flatbed scanner. Automatic double-sided printing; this print feature doesn’t confirm double-sided scanning. Touchscreen, Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to feed old recipe pages through the feeder to get a clear scan?
No. You can use the flatbed glass for suitable individual pages. Check the condition of the original first, and avoid using a feeder or pressing hard on fragile or tightly bound pages if this could damage them.
How should I prepare the flatbed glass and scan file?
The Library of Congress recommends cleaning the glass with a slightly damp, lint-free cloth and not spraying liquid directly onto the scanner. Choose a scan resolution, colour setting and file format to suit how you’ll use the scan, then check that the saved file is easy to read.
Can I show scanned pages from an old cookbook in a school project or publish them online?
Not simply because the book is old or its pages have been scanned. Whether the recipe text, design or images are protected depends on the specific material. Subject to certain conditions, § 60a UrhG permits certain uses of published works to illustrate teaching at educational institutions for non-commercial purposes, generally up to 15 per cent. This doesn’t give you general permission to publish an entire book online for anyone to access.