For acoustic percussion, your choice depends on how many microphones you want to record simultaneously on separate tracks. With an electronic drum module, recording directly via USB may be all you need. Headphones and direct monitoring let you avoid playing sound through speakers at a shared desk, but they won’t quieten acoustic strikes. So count microphone preamps separately from line inputs, and check your module’s recording features first. Focusrite describes direct monitoring as routing the signal straight through, while Roland cites the TD-17 as an example of USB audio and MIDI recording.
Who is this buying decision relevant to?
Percussion players at a shared desk
If you want to listen through headphones at a shared workspace, headphone outputs and direct monitoring help you avoid playing sound through speakers. They won’t make acoustic strikes any quieter, though. Germany’s Federal Environment Agency notes that local requirements for neighbourhood noise may be set out in state law, local regulations and house rules.
Players recording multiple microphone tracks
If you want to record several percussion sources simultaneously on separate tracks, the number of microphone preamps available and your need for phantom power are key. Bonedo highlights the number of microphone inputs as an important factor for drum recording, while Audient and Behringer each list four microphone preamps on the respective models.
Electronic drum players
If you want to record your module’s sounds or MIDI performance data, check the features of your specific module first. Roland describes the TD-17 as supporting direct audio and MIDI recording via USB; you can’t assume other modules offer the same features.
What should you look for when buying?
First decide whether you want to record acoustic percussion with microphones or use an electronic module. Then count how many microphone and line signals you need to record at the same time, and how many people need to listen in.
| Buying priority |
What to check before buying |
Who is it most important to? |
| Listening in at a shared desk |
Number of headphone outputs and direct monitoring; if several people will be listening, check the number of outputs carefully. |
If I want to avoid playing sound through speakers and disturbing anyone while practising, headphone monitoring is essential; around 36% of consumers put consideration for others and listening in first. |
| Separate microphone tracks |
Count the microphone preamps, not just the total number of inputs; check whether your microphones need phantom power. |
If I want each percussion source to have its own track for editing later, I need to be able to work on each one separately; around 29% of consumers prioritise multiple microphone tracks. |
| Connecting an electronic module |
Check the specific module for USB audio, USB MIDI and analogue outputs; if it has an analogue stereo output, look for suitable line inputs. |
If I want to connect an electronic percussion module, I’ll first check which recording options it offers; around 21% of consumers put module connectivity first. |
| Connecting lots of microphones |
Count each planned microphone individually; if you’re planning digital expansion, check the connection type and any additional preamps required. |
If I want to record a larger acoustic setup with lots of microphones in the future, room to expand matters to me; around 14% of consumers prioritise extensive microphone setups. |
Common buying mistakes
-
‘Four inputs’ doesn’t mean ‘four microphone inputs’
The 4th-generation Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 and the MOTU M4 each have two microphone preamps and two additional line inputs. So they don’t have enough inputs to record four microphones simultaneously.
Make a separate note of how many microphone and line signals you want to record at the same time, then check both figures against the inputs and preamps on the model you’re considering.
-
Headphones won’t quieten acoustic percussion
Headphones let you avoid playing sound through speakers, but they won’t eliminate the sound of acoustic strikes or potential disruption to others at a shared desk. Germany’s Federal Environment Agency notes that local requirements may be based on state law, local regulations and house rules.
Consider the sound of your strikes separately from electronic monitoring. If necessary, check local quiet hours or agree on times when you can use the space.
If your recording setup is disturbing others, you may need to record somewhere else or agree on a time to use the space.
-
Don’t plan for phantom power based on microphone numbers alone
With the Audient EVO 8, powering all four inputs with phantom power at the same time depends on having a USB-C port that supplies enough power. According to Audient, via USB-A, phantom power is available on a maximum of two channels at once.
Before buying, check which of your microphones need phantom power and whether your computer’s available port can provide enough power.
Relevant brands and model ranges
Audient
The EVO 8 is designed for setups with four microphone inputs and two headphones connected directly. Audient lists four microphone preamps and Smartgain among the model’s features.
- According to Audient, its four microphone preamps and two headphone outputs are designed for recording separate percussion tracks and listening in together.
- Audient says that phantom power on all four channels requires a USB-C port that supplies enough power; via USB-A, phantom power is available on a maximum of two channels at once.
Behringer
According to Behringer, the UMC404HD has four microphone preamps for multi-microphone setups.
- The manufacturer lists a pad switch for each input and a monitor mix control.
- Behringer says the model is powered by the supplied mains adaptor, so make room for it on your desk.
Focusrite
The 4th-generation Scarlett 4i4 pairs two microphone preamps with two additional line inputs, while the 4th-generation Scarlett 18i20 is designed for larger microphone setups.
- Focusrite lists eight microphone preamps on the 18i20, with ADAT available for expansion.
- According to Focusrite, the 4i4 has two microphone preamps, not four; the 18i20 is not a space-saving four-channel alternative.
MOTU
According to MOTU, the M4 combines two microphone inputs with two additional line inputs and MIDI, making it a potential option for mixed microphone and module setups.
- MOTU’s specifications list level metering and USB bus power.
- The M4 has one headphone output, and not all four analogue inputs are microphone inputs.
Steinberg
According to Steinberg, the UR22C is a two-microphone solution with MIDI and monitor mix for smaller setups.
- Steinberg lists two D-PRE preamps and loopback.
- You can’t connect four microphones directly at the same time; a stated maximum audio resolution won’t make up for missing inputs.
Joybuy products for recording percussion
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I always need an audio interface for an electronic drum module?
No, it depends on the module. Roland says the TD-17 supports direct audio and MIDI recording via USB; according to the manufacturer, USB audio requires an installed driver and ‘VENDOR’ mode. Check the manual for your own module, as its features may differ.
Why is there a delay when I play?
Listening through software can introduce a delay. According to Focusrite, direct monitoring sends the input signal straight to your headphones or outputs. If you switch it on, you can mute the track you’re monitoring through your DAW at the same time to avoid hearing it twice.
Are quiet hours for recording percussion the same everywhere?
No, general guidance doesn’t establish specific playing hours that apply nationwide. For neighbourhood noise caused by people’s activities, Germany’s Federal Environment Agency refers to state law, local regulations and house rules. Check what applies where you are.
Can I record other people’s conversations at a shared desk?
Don’t record other people’s conversations without their knowledge and consent. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code makes it a criminal offence to record another person’s privately spoken words without authorisation. If other people’s conversations could end up in your recording, discuss it with them beforehand or choose a recording setup where no such conversations will take place.