Electronic percussion players in flats with thin walls
If you mainly record through headphones, first check whether your module provides the USB audio or MIDI you need. Even an electronic kit can make mechanical noise.
With electronic percussion, you don’t need a separate interface if your specific module sends the audio or MIDI you need to your recording software over USB. Roland documents this option for the TD-07, although USB audio requires the right driver and the VENDOR setting. With acoustic percussion, your choice depends on how many microphones you want to record simultaneously on separate tracks. Headphones and placing the microphone closer can make recording more practical, but they won’t block out the sound of hits or vibrations travelling through the floor to your neighbours.
If you mainly record through headphones, first check whether your module provides the USB audio or MIDI you need. Even an electronic kit can make mechanical noise.
For individual instruments recorded with one or two microphones, microphone distance and room noise are separate factors to consider. Assess them independently of how many inputs your interface has.
If you want to record several microphones simultaneously on separate tracks, the number of built-in microphone preamps or the right external expansion is what matters.
First check your module’s USB recording options, then count how many microphones you need to use at the same time and decide how you want to monitor while playing.
| What you need | What to check before buying | Who is this most important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Recording without an unnecessary interface | USB audio or USB MIDI only; drivers and settings for your specific module | If you want your electronic percussion module to communicate directly with your recording software, the right signal path is your priority. Around 33 % of consumers have this as their main concern. |
| One or two acoustic microphones | Number of microphone inputs that can be used simultaneously; whether phantom power is needed | For a single instrument or a pair of microphones, you want a compact setup without paying for more microphone inputs than you need. Around 27 % of consumers have this as their main priority. |
| Several separate microphone tracks | Built-in microphone preamps; suitable external preamps for ADAT | If you want to record several percussion sources simultaneously on their own tracks, the number of microphone preamps actually available is crucial. This is the main requirement for around 20 % of consumers. |
| Headphone monitoring while playing | Direct monitoring and mixing with playback; signal routing when using live software effects | When playing in time, you want to monitor your signal without distracting delay and avoid playback through speakers. Around 20 % of consumers consider this their main concern. |
According to Shure, placing a microphone closer can make the sound source stand out more against room reverberation and background noise, but it won’t remove existing noise. Headphones avoid playback through speakers, but they don’t make acoustic hits or mechanical vibrations inaudible.
According to MOTU, two of the MOTU M4’s four analogue inputs are additional line inputs. So four inputs don’t automatically mean you can connect four microphones directly.
Before buying, count the microphone inputs you need to use simultaneously and check which ones actually have microphone preamps.
An interface routes and digitises signals. Headphones replace speakers, but they don’t prevent acoustic hits or mechanical noise from travelling through the building.
Consider recording noise, disturbance to your neighbours and the rules that apply where you live separately from your choice of equipment.
An ADAT connection doesn’t provide additional built-in microphone preamps. For the Studio 1824c, PreSonus specifies eight ADAT channels, or four at 96 kHz.
Plan for suitable external preamps, the optical connection and your preferred sample rate together.
The examples below relate to the documented inputs and connections of the product ranges mentioned; they are not a general assessment of quality.
The Scarlett 2i2 4th Gen is suitable for up to two microphones; the Scarlett 18i20 4th Gen is designed for more extensive simultaneous microphone setups.
The UR22C is a compact two-input option with MIDI In/Out and a monitor mix for small recording setups.
The Studio 1824c is designed for multitrack recording, with up to eight built-in microphone preamps.
The M4 is an option for a small microphone setup that also needs to connect line-level signals and MIDI.
No, not if your specific module sends the audio or MIDI you need to your computer over USB. Roland documents this option for the TD-07; USB audio requires the right driver and the VENDOR setting. Check which formats your own module supports.
Placing the microphone closer can make the sound source stand out more against background noise and room reverberation. According to Shure, the result depends on the microphone’s position, so place it only as close as makes sense for the sound you want. This approach won’t remove existing noise completely.
When you monitor the input through software, your computer has to process the signal, which can cause noticeable latency. The Audacity manual highlights this delay. Check whether your interface offers direct monitoring and whether you need to hear effects from your recording software live while playing.
An ADAT input doesn’t provide additional built-in microphone preamps. To add more microphones, you’ll need suitable external preamp hardware and the right connection. The number of ADAT channels documented by PreSonus for the Studio 1824c also depends on the sample rate.
No, using headphones doesn’t give you blanket permission. For neighbour noise caused by people’s behaviour, the German Environment Agency refers to rules set by the federal states, local authorities and housing regulations. Under the conditions set out in § 117 OWiG, unreasonable noise is an offence. So check the rules that apply where you live and in your building.