Joybuy Insights

Permanent Hair Colour: How to Avoid 3 Common Buying Mistakes

A new hair colour can refresh your look and boost your confidence. Reaching for a permanent hair colour for at-home use is a popular and convenient solution. However, the market is crowded, and many products overpromise and underdeliver. Anyone planning an at-home colour treatment often faces the challenge of choosing the right option from a vast array of choices. Misleading claims not only lead to unsatisfying results but can also cause unnecessary damage to your hair. This guide will help you identify common purchasing traps and make an informed decision.

The Hidden Pitfalls of Buying Hair Colour

Many users invest money in products that ultimately disappoint. Certain marketing promises should be viewed with a critical eye to avoid a poor investment.

  1. The patchy grey coverage trap: Many boxes advertise "up to 100% grey coverage," but the reality is often different. Especially with a high percentage of grey or resistant hair, the colour can appear uneven or fail to adequately conceal grey strands. The result is a blotchy colour that requires another treatment.
  2. The myth of pure "nourishing oils": Formulas enriched with precious oils sound appealing. A nourishing hair colour is what many people want. However, the concentration of these oils is often too low to provide any significant conditioning effect during the chemical process. If the base formula also contains aggressive substances like ammonia, the hair can become dry and brittle despite the advertised oils.
  3. The unpredictable colour result: The picture on the box serves as a guide, but it's no guarantee of the final outcome. Your initial hair colour, hair texture, and any previous treatments have a significant impact on the final shade. Ignoring this can lead to unwanted undertones or a result that is much darker or lighter than expected.

What Really Matters: The Key Product Parameters

To find the right permanent hair colour, you should focus on objective criteria. The following three parameters are crucial for achieving a successful colour result and healthy-looking hair.

Parameter 1: The Formula – With or Without Ammonia?

Choosing the right formula is one of the most important decisions when you buy hair colour. Traditionally, ammonia is used to open the hair's cuticle layer, allowing colour pigments to penetrate deeply. This ensures an intense and long-lasting colour. The downside is the pungent smell and the potential to irritate the hair and scalp.

An alternative is an ammonia-free hair colour. These products often use substitutes like ethanolamine (MEA). A modern technology, used for example in Garnier Olia, utilises a high concentration of oils to transport the colour pigments into the hair. Such formulas are often odourless and can feel gentler on the hair.

Parameter 2: Coverage and Longevity

For many, reliable 100% grey coverage is the main criterion. Products specifically designed to cover grey hair, such as the L'Oréal Excellence line, often contain a higher pigment concentration or special pre-treatments to ensure an even result. According to manufacturers, a permanent colour should typically last up to eight weeks before roots become visible and require a touch-up. Look for product descriptions that explicitly mention complete grey coverage.

Parameter 3: Nourishing Ingredients and Aftercare

A high-quality colour is distinguished not just by the colour cream itself, but also by the included conditioning treatment. This aftercare seals the hair's surface after colouring, locks in the colour pigments, and provides shine and smoothness. Product lines like Garnier Nutrisse promote their rich conditioning treatments, which contain a blend of several fruit oils (e.g., avocado, olive, shea, argan, and cranberry oil). This after-colour treatment is crucial for smoothing the hair structure and protecting it from drying out.

Top Picks for Every Need

Instead of a one-size-fits-all recommendation, we present products tailored to specific profiles and requirements.

SUITABLE FOR: BUDGET-CONSCIOUS BEGINNERS
GARNIER Nutrisse Creme Care Hair Color 5.35 Golden Fawn Brown

GARNIER Nutrisse Creme Care Hair Color 5.35 Golden Fawn Brown

Why this product is a match: Ideal for users looking for a reliable and straightforward at-home colour. The creamy, non-drip texture makes application easy, while the formula promises a rich colour result and good grey coverage.

How it avoids the trap

The included conditioning treatment with five fruit oils counteracts the "empty conditioning promises" trap by noticeably nourishing the hair after colouring. The proven cream formula ensures an even result and minimises the risk of unpredictable colour outcomes.

Key Advantage & Plus Points

Offers a combination of easy application thanks to its non-drip texture and a rich aftercare treatment for conditioned hair.

SUITABLE FOR: FOCUS ON GENTLE FORMULAS
Garnier Olia Hair Color 4.0 Medium Brown

Garnier Olia Hair Color 4.0 Medium Brown

Why this product is a match: For anyone who wants to avoid ammonia and values a pleasant application experience. This brown hair colour is ideal for a gentler colouring process with a subtle fragrance.

How it avoids the trap

The ammonia-free formula directly addresses concerns about harsh chemicals. The 60% oil-based technology isn't just marketing; it's the core mechanism that propels colour into the hair while simultaneously conditioning it.

Key Advantage & Plus Points

Ammonia-free, oil-powered colour. According to the manufacturer, it delivers a visible improvement in hair quality and a pleasant floral scent during application.

SUITABLE FOR: MAXIMUM GREY COVERAGE
L'Oréal Excellence Creme Nr. 7 Mittelblond

L'Oréal Excellence Creme No. 7 Medium Blonde

Why this product is a match: For users whose top priority is complete and long-lasting coverage of grey hair. This blonde hair colour is known for its reliable coverage.

How it avoids the trap

This product tackles the patchy grey coverage trap with a triple-care system that protects the hair before, during, and after colouring. The formula with Pro-Keratin and Ceramide is designed to colour even resistant hair evenly.

Key Advantage & Plus Points

A systematic triple-care routine (protective serum, colour cream, conditioning balm) and a formula designed for 100% grey coverage, according to the manufacturer.

Permanent hair colours offer long-lasting results. However, if you prefer to experiment with colours first or want a less-committal option, a different type of hair colour might be more suitable for you.

Looking for more options?

We have compiled a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and UK safety regulations.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often can you apply permanent hair colour?

Generally, it is recommended to touch up your roots every four to six weeks, depending on your hair growth rate. A full-length colour application should be done less frequently to avoid over-processing the hair. Many instructions recommend applying the colour to the roots first and only distributing it through the lengths and ends for the last few minutes of the processing time.

What do the numbers on the hair colour box mean?

The numbers on the packaging follow an international code that provides information about the colour. The number before the dot describes the colour level on a scale from 1 (Black) to 10 (Extra Light Blonde). The numbers after the dot represent the colour reflects or tones. For example, .1 indicates an ash (cool) tone, .3 a gold (warm) tone, and .4 a copper tone. Understanding this system helps you find the right shade for your desired look.

Do I need one or two boxes of at-home hair colour?

As a rule of thumb, one box is usually sufficient for hair that is shorter than shoulder-length. For shoulder-length or longer hair, as well as for very thick hair, it is advisable to buy two boxes. This ensures you have enough product to apply the colour evenly from roots to ends and avoid a patchy result.