Which drive is right for you?

Collectors with large photo archives

If you want to back up lots of original files at home without using the cloud, allow enough space for your entire collection as well as additional backup copies.

Photographers who import files frequently

If you regularly add new photos or take the drive between work locations, consider the connection on your computer and the transfer speeds you can actually achieve.

Users of photo catalogues

If you manage your images in catalogue software, make sure you can restore both the catalogue information and the associated image files.

What should you consider when buying?

External HDD

A better fit if: Your photo archive stays at home most of the time and you mainly need enough capacity for your original files and additional backup copies.

The trade-off: In its German comparison from July 2026, COMPUTER BILD described HDDs as a capacity-focused option, offering more storage for your money but lower speeds than SSDs. A single drive is no substitute for a backup stored separately and tested.

External SSD

A better fit if: You regularly copy new photos or take your backup drive with you, and its capacity is right for your collection.

The trade-off: Manufacturers’ high speed ratings only apply when the required connection conditions are met. For the Samsung T9, Samsung specifies a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 port, a suitable cable and UASP.

For a local photo backup without the cloud, first decide which files you need to back up and how you’ll use the drive.

What you need What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Space for your photo archive Work out the size of your original files, edited images and planned backup copies, then compare it with the drive’s capacity. If I want to store my collection alongside additional backup copies, I need space for all the files; around 36% of consumers prioritise capacity for their complete photo archive.
Completeness and recovery Make a note of where your photos, exports and catalogue are stored, then test restoring a file. If I want to recover both my images and catalogue after a fault, I check each separately; around 29% of consumers prioritise completeness and recovery.
Transfer speed and portability Check how often and how much you transfer, as well as the USB port and cable. Don’t assume maximum speeds are guaranteed in practice. If I often transfer new photos between work locations, I need a drive that suits my computer and how I’ll carry it; around 21% of consumers prioritise transfer speed and portability.
Local privacy Depending on how you’ll use the drive, consider encryption and make sure you can access the recovery key securely. If I take my drive with me or store it separately, I want to control access to my images and keep the key safe; around 14% of consumers prioritise privacy.

According to Adobe, Lightroom Classic’s built-in backup only includes the catalogue file. You’ll need to save edited photos and exports separately.

Common photo backup mistakes

  • Backing up only the catalogue file

    In Lightroom Classic, photos and exports aren’t automatically included in the catalogue backup. So the catalogue file alone won’t be enough if you want to recover your images too.

    Make a note of where your original files, edited images, exports and catalogue are stored, then check that your backup includes everything you need.

  • Relying on a single drive as your only backup

    The Federal Office for Information Security points out that it’s impossible to predict exactly how long storage media will last, and recommends keeping backups in a separate location.

    Set a practical backup schedule, keep your copy separately and regularly check that you can restore your files.

  • Assuming you’ll get the advertised maximum SSD speed

    Advertised maximum speeds aren’t guaranteed on every computer. For the T9, Samsung specifies a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host, a suitable cable and UASP as requirements for sequential read and write speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s.

    Check the whole connection and decide whether capacity or transfer speed matters more for your backup.

  • Encrypting your drive without planning how you’ll access it later

    Depending on the method, you’ll need a key or password to access an encrypted backup. Without these recovery details, you may not be able to get to your files.

    Keep a record of the method you use and store your recovery details securely, where you can access them in an emergency.

Key brands at a glance

Toshiba

Canvio Advance is a range of external, USB-powered HDDs for portable or home backups.

  • Toshiba lists models with up to 4 TB of storage, along with backup and security software.
  • The software details come from the manufacturer and don’t independently guarantee the reliability of every backup.

Western Digital

My Passport is a range of external HDDs. A black 6 TB model was included in the German HDD test.

  • The 6 TB model offers a specific capacity option for larger photo archives.
  • Check the connection and software requirements for the exact model before adding it to your backup routine.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T9 is a range of external SSDs. Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 for the 1 TB model.

  • Samsung rates the T9 for sequential read and write speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s.
  • Samsung says these maximum speeds require a compatible host, a suitable cable and UASP. They aren’t a guarantee of the speed you’ll get on every computer.

Kingston

XS2000 is a compact USB-C SSD range available in several capacities, including 2 TB and 4 TB.

  • Kingston lists speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s over USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and a removable protective sleeve.
  • The stated speed is a manufacturer rating and doesn’t tell you on its own what speeds your backup routine will achieve.

Seagate

The 4 TB Game Drive for Xbox is an HDD that you could also consider for storing photos locally.

  • Seagate lists the model number STKX4000402 for a 4 TB model.
  • This model number doesn’t correspond to the version named in the test. Check the exact model and how to set it up on your computer before using it for photos.

Joybuy products for local photo backups

This selection includes external HDDs for capacity-focused backups and SSDs for compact or portable photo backups. Check that each drive’s capacity and connection requirements suit your collection and computer.

WD Elements 2 TB Portable External Hard Drive

WD Elements 2 TB Portable External Hard Drive

This external HDD is a good fit for a local photo backup if 2 TB is enough for your collection and you’re looking for a portable drive.

2 TB; 2.5-inch; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; exFAT. The product description lists Windows and macOS compatibility and a weight of 131 g.

The drive contains sensitive mechanical components, so avoid knocks and vibration.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 8 TB Desktop External Hard Drive

WD Elements 8 TB Desktop External Hard Drive

This desktop HDD is an option if you have a larger photo archive that you mainly back up in one place.

8 TB; 3.5-inch; USB 3.0; NTFS; power supply included.

The power supply is required to use the drive. According to the product description, you’ll need to reformat it to use it with macOS. Avoid knocks and vibration.

View at Joybuy
Kexin M.2 SATA Portable External SSD 256 GB

Kexin M.2 SATA Portable External SSD 256 GB

This portable SSD could suit you if 256 GB is enough for the files you want to back up and you’re looking for a compact drive to take with you.

256 GB; M.2 SATA; USB 3.1; up to 500 MB/s according to the product name.

View at Joybuy
KEXIN External SSD 512 GB

KEXIN External SSD 512 GB

This portable SSD could be a good choice for frequent transfers if its 512 GB capacity is enough for the photos and other files you’ve selected.

512 GB; USB 3.1 Type-C; up to 500 MB/s according to the product name. The description mentions a lightweight, portable casing.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport External Hard Drive 2 TB

WD My Passport External Hard Drive 2 TB

This portable HDD is an option if you want to back up 2 TB locally and take the drive with you.

2 TB; USB 3.0. The product description lists password protection, 256-bit AES encryption and automatic backup schedules.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is the Lightroom Classic catalogue backup enough to protect my photos?

No. According to Adobe, the backup created by Lightroom Classic contains the catalogue file. You’ll need to save edited photos and exports separately. Check where your images are stored.

How do I set up a local backup on a Mac or Windows PC?

On a Mac, you can use an external drive with Time Machine. In Windows, File History can also back up to an external drive. Check whether photo folders outside the libraries it covers are included, then test restoring a file.

Does my backup drive need to stay connected all the time?

No. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping a backup in a separate location from your PC. Schedule regular backups so that your separately stored copy stays up to date.

Will I have ongoing storage costs if I don’t use the cloud?

You don’t need a cloud subscription for a local backup. Work out how much storage you need and, if necessary, allow for another drive to keep additional copies separately. The total cost depends on the solution you choose.

Do I have to use a particular encrypted drive for personal photos in Germany?

No. There’s no general requirement to use a particular drive. According to the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information, the GDPR doesn’t apply to personal data processed by individuals solely for personal or family activities. The legal position is different if you use the data professionally or outside this context. Either way, encryption can help protect a drive you take with you.