Anyone with a growing photo archive
If you want to keep lots of originals and additional backup copies, make sure you allow for future files. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends considering backups for important files.
For a large photo archive that stays at home most of the time, an HDD could be a good fit if capacity matters more to you than short copying times. If you regularly transport large folders, consider a portable SSD. Also decide whether you need shared file storage or a Time Machine backup: Apple recommends different file systems for each. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends planning for recovery too – a single drive is no substitute for keeping another copy separately.
If you want to keep lots of originals and additional backup copies, make sure you allow for future files. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends considering backups for important files.
If you want to open backed-up files on both systems, you’ll need a compatible file system. Shared file storage is different from a Mac system backup using Time Machine.
If you regularly transport large image folders, check the ports, cables and copying speed of the specific drive. If you make an additional copy, it’s important to keep that copy separately too.
A good fit if: you mostly back up at home and capacity matters more to you than short copying times.
Bear in mind: a desktop HDD may need a separate power supply; it depends on the specific model.
A good fit if: you regularly move photo and project folders between work locations.
Bear in mind: an SSD or an advertised maximum speed is no substitute for a second backup, or for the right host port and cable.
| Priority | What to check before buying | Who should consider this? |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity for a growing archive | Compare the size of all the folders you want to back up with the capacity of the specific model. For Time Machine, Apple recommends at least twice the storage capacity of your Mac; this isn’t a general requirement for simple photo file copies. | As my archive grows, I want room for originals and future backups. Around 33 % of consumers put capacity first. |
| File system and devices | Check which devices you use and whether you want to share files or use Time Machine. Apple recommends exFAT for shared storage and prefers APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for Time Machine volumes. Reformatting can erase existing files. | If I want to open the same files on Windows and macOS, the storage needs to work with both. Around 25 % of consumers prioritise device compatibility. |
| Recoverability | Plan to keep another copy separately and test whether you can restore a file you need. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security points out that restoring files isn’t always straightforward. | I want to be able to get my photos back after a fault or accidental deletion. Around 25 % of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Mobile transfers and ports | Check the interface and compare the cable and port on your computer with the specific drive model. Advertised maximum speeds aren’t guaranteed for every connection or mix of files. | If I regularly move large image folders between work locations, the right ports and easy portability matter. Around 17 % of consumers prioritise mobile transfers. |
If the drive fails or is damaged where it’s stored, you could lose the only remaining copy too.
Keep the originals or another copy separately, and test whether you can restore files from it.
An additional copy needs storage space too.
Storage for sharing files between Windows and Mac won’t necessarily work for Time Machine. Reformatting can erase existing data.
First decide which devices and backup method you’ll use, and make another copy of any existing files before changing the format.
Neither a protective casing nor an advertised interface speed proves that a backup is complete or can be restored later. Samsung notes that liquid and dust damage aren’t covered by the warranty for the T7 Shield tested.
Check the warranty terms, host port and cable for the specific model, and keep another copy regardless.
The Canvio range includes portable HDDs. Toshiba says Canvio Flex is designed for use with compatible Windows, Mac and mobile devices.
My Passport is a portable HDD range. The black 4-TB model considered here has the model number WDBPKJ0040BBK-WESN.
Expansion Desktop is a desktop HDD range for large files and archives.
The German product page for the portable T7 Shield describes the black 2-TB SSD MU-PE2T0S/EU.
Kingston’s external SSD ranges, XS1000 and XS2000, differ in a number of ways, including their interfaces.
This Joybuy selection includes portable HDDs for photo archives, a desktop drive and a portable SSD for transferring files.
No image available
For a growing photo archive if you’re looking for a portable HDD with a generous stated capacity.
5 TB; portable 2.5-inch format; USB-C port and USB-powered, according to the product description.
No image available
A portable HDD for photo and file backups, if the stated capacity suits your archive.
4 TB; portable 2.5-inch format; USB-C port and USB-powered, according to the product description.
No image available
For shared file storage on Windows and macOS, if exFAT suits your workflow.
2 TB; exFAT; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; portable 2.5-inch format and USB-powered, according to the product details.
No image available
For a portable file archive, if the stated 256 GB capacity is enough for your needs.
M.2 SATA SSD; USB 3.1 Type-C; up to 500 MB/s, according to the product details. The description lists compatibility with PC, Mac and Android.
No image available
For a large photo archive that’s mainly used in one place.
8 TB; 3.5-inch format; USB 3.0; external power supply. According to the product description, the drive is formatted as NTFS and needs reformatting for macOS.
Add up the storage needed for all the original, catalogue and project folders you want to back up, and allow for future files and your backup method. For a Time Machine volume, Apple recommends at least twice the storage capacity of your Mac; this isn’t a blanket requirement for a simple file copy.
Shared file storage and a Time Machine backup need different planning. Apple recommends exFAT for sharing larger drives between Windows and Mac, but prefers APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for Time Machine volumes. Make another copy of your files before setting up or reformatting the drive, as they could be erased in the process.
Check that the folders you intended to back up are there, then try restoring a file you need. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security points out that restoring files isn’t always straightforward; keeping another copy separately can reduce the risks of damage where your drive is stored.
Check whether the specific model includes the cables and adapters you need, and whether a desktop HDD requires a separate power supply. Also compare the warranty terms and the stated backup software with your actual workflow: software alone doesn’t guarantee that you’ll be able to restore your files.