Who is a photo catalogue backup for?

Backing up a photo collection

If you want to copy your original photos as well as your catalogue without using the cloud, take the space required for both into account. Adobe describes the Lightroom Classic catalogue as a database containing entries for your photos.

Making regular offline backups

If you update an offline copy regularly, check that you can restore the files you need. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup media from your computer when you’re not making a backup.

Backing up to a portable drive

If you’ll be carrying the copy with you or storing it away from home, check that the connectors are compatible and consider protection in case it’s lost. The German Federal Office for Information Security warns that data on portable storage media could fall into the wrong hands.

What should you look for when choosing one?

Adobe distinguishes between the catalogue and original photos in Lightroom Classic. The German Federal Office for Information Security also recommends checking that backups can be restored and keeping the backup medium separate.

What matters when buying What to check Who is this particularly important for?
Enough space for your backup Check the size of your catalogue and, if applicable, your photo folders, then compare it with the usable capacity. If I want to back up my original photos as well as my catalogue, everything needs to fit on the stick. Around 33% of consumers say having enough space for their backup is their most important buying consideration.
Recoverability Check which files are included, whether they can be read and restored, and keep the stick separate. If I need to restore my copy, I want to know in advance that it’s readable and kept away from my computer. For around 25% of consumers, recoverability is the most important buying consideration.
Write speed Check the write-speed specifications and conditions for the exact model; don’t confuse read speed with write speed. If I regularly back up large amounts of photos, how long the transfer takes matters to me. Around 17% of consumers put write speed first.
Access protection If you’ll be carrying a copy with you, check how the stick is unlocked and whether a security update is needed. If I keep my stick away from home, I want to protect my personal photos from unauthorised access if it’s lost. For around 17% of consumers, access protection is the most important buying consideration.
Connector and file system Check that the connectors and file systems are supported by the devices you use. Back up your files elsewhere before formatting. If I use the stick with devices that have different connectors, it needs to fit my workflow. Around 8% of consumers name connector compatibility as their most important buying consideration.

Common backup mistakes

  • Copying only the catalogue and assuming the original photos are included

    In Lightroom Classic, the catalogue points to photo files but doesn’t automatically contain the original files. A copy of the catalogue alone therefore won’t protect those photos.

    Before you buy, decide whether you also want to copy your original photo folders to the stick, and factor both sets of files into your storage requirements.

  • Confusing read speed with write speed

    When you back up, data is written to the stick. A high read speed alone doesn’t tell you how long writing will take. Maximum speeds quoted by manufacturers can also depend on the hardware, software and usage.

    Check the write-speed specification for the exact model and the conditions under which it applies.

  • Leaving your only backup stick connected to your computer

    A stick that’s always connected could be affected along with your computer if it breaks down or is infected with malware. Damage at the place where you store it could also affect both the original and the copy.

    Disconnect the stick after backing up, store it separately and check that your files can be restored. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup media from the device when you’re not making a backup.

  • Using a USB stick with a numeric keypad without a plan for unlocking it

    Verbatim says that the Keypad Secure is reformatted after 20 incorrect code entries and recommends a security update. Reformatting could put access to your saved files at risk.

    Check for the update and read the instructions before using the stick. Keep the access code in a safe place, separate from the stick.

Brands and product ranges at a glance

SanDisk

The Extreme PRO range may be worth considering if you’re looking for a USB-A stick for transferring larger files.

  • SanDisk lists 256 GB and USB 3.2 Gen 1 for the SDCZ880-256G-G46 version.
  • Manufacturer transfer-speed claims aren’t the same as independent, sustained write-speed test results. Check that the usable capacity is sufficient for your backup.

Samsung

The BAR Plus range includes USB-A options for a catalogue or photo export that you can store separately.

  • Samsung lists sequential read speeds of up to 400 MB/s for the silver 256-GB version, MUF-256BE3/APC.
  • The read speed doesn’t confirm a similar write speed. Before buying, check the full model number of the version you want.

Verbatim

The Keypad Secure 128 GB is aimed at buyers who want to unlock a portable stick directly on the device.

  • According to the manufacturer, the model offers AES-256 hardware encryption and a keypad.
  • The manufacturer requires a security update and says the stick is reformatted after 20 incorrect code entries. 128 GB may not be enough for a large collection of original photos.

Kingston

DataTraveler Max and DataTraveler Duo offer different connector and capacity options across these product ranges.

  • Kingston lists DataTraveler Max versions up to 1 TB, with write speeds of up to 900 MB/s depending on hardware, software and usage. DataTraveler Duo has USB-A and USB-C connectors.
  • The documented DataTraveler Duo versions are listed as 128 GB and 256 GB. These specifications apply to the relevant ranges and conditions, not to all Kingston sticks.

Joybuy products for local photo backups

These USB sticks could suit local catalogue or photo backups. Depending on the model, you may want to prioritise capacity, connector options or access protection. Match your choice to the size of your actual backup and the connectors on your devices.

Kingston DataTraveler Kyson 256GB USB stick

Kingston DataTraveler Kyson 256GB USB stick

For backing up a catalogue and photo folders, as long as everything fits within the capacity.

Capacity: 256 GB.

View on Joybuy
Kingston DataTraveler 64GB 220MB/s Metal USB 3.2 Gen 1 SE9 G3

Kingston DataTraveler 64GB 220MB/s Metal USB 3.2 Gen 1 SE9 G3

Could suit a catalogue backup or a limited amount of data. Check that your files will fit within the capacity.

Capacity: 64 GB. Interface listed in the product name: USB 3.2 Gen 1.

View on Joybuy
MOVESPEED YSUSP05-128GSR 128GB USB stick

MOVESPEED YSUSP05-128GSR 128GB USB stick

The dual interface listed may be useful if you switch between USB-A and USB-C devices. Check the connectors on your devices.

Capacity: 128 GB. The product name lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and Type-C.

View on Joybuy
MOVESPEED YSUYC-256GSN 256GB USB stick with fingerprint access

MOVESPEED YSUYC-256GSN 256GB USB stick

For a copy you’ll carry with you or store away from home if access protection matters to you. The product description lists fingerprint access and encryption.

Capacity: 256 GB. The product name lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and Type-C.

According to the product information, encrypted data can’t be recovered if both the administrator password and fingerprint access fail; the system partition must not be formatted.

View on Joybuy
Lexar D40E 128GB Dual USB 3.2 Gen 1 Type-C, LJDD40E128G-BNSNG

Lexar D40E 128GB Dual USB 3.2 Gen 1 Type-C (LJDD40E128G-BNSNG)

For a portable catalogue backup. Check that the stick’s connector matches the connectors on the devices you use.

Capacity: 128 GB. The product name lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and Type-C.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does backing up my Lightroom Classic catalogue also back up my original photos?

No, not automatically. Adobe describes the catalogue as a database containing references to where your photos are stored. If you also want to back up the original files, you’ll need to make a separate copy of them.

What should I do after copying files to the stick?

Check that the files you need are readable and can be restored. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup media from your computer when you’re not making a backup. Storing it separately can also help prevent the original and the copy from being damaged at the same location.

Which format should I use with both a Mac and a Windows PC?

Apple lists ExFAT as an option for a suitably formatted volume over 32 GB that you want to use with both Mac and Windows. Back up any files you need elsewhere before formatting, as the process deletes existing files.

What are my rights if a USB stick is faulty, and is the manufacturer’s warranty the same thing?

When you buy from a business seller in the EU, you generally have a statutory right to a minimum two-year guarantee from the date you receive the goods. This is separate from any additional manufacturer’s warranty; check the terms of each separately.

How should I dispose of an old USB stick in Germany?

According to information from the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, waste electrical and electronic equipment is collected separately. You may be able to return it to a local collection point or, subject to the legal requirements, to a retailer. Remove your personal data before handing in the stick.