Which archive solution is right for you?

Podcasters with a growing episode archive

If you keep raw recordings and project files as well as finished episodes, plan for the size of your entire collection and how quickly it will grow. A separate backup is part of the plan for irreplaceable files. The Federal Office for Information Security explains why it can be important to keep a backup away from your usual storage location.

Podcasters with a mobile editing workflow

If you regularly move projects between devices, the right connection and cable matter, as does the time needed to copy large files. A portable SSD may be a good option if you take your drive with you regularly. However, speed and protection claims apply to specific models and conditions.

Podcasters using different computers and file types

If you want to use recordings and project folders on both Mac and Windows, check the drive's file system and the connections on both computers. Whether you can open individual audio or project files also depends on the file format and the software you need.

What should you look for when buying?

If the drive will mostly stay in one place and mainly store complete episode and project folders, an HDD could be a good fit. An SSD is usually the better choice for frequent transfers or regular travel. CHIP describes SSDs as faster and less susceptible to knocks than HDDs, although the results depend on the model and how you use it.

External HDD for archiving

A good fit if: you keep lots of finished episodes, raw recordings and project files in one place and copying time is less important.

The trade-off: CHIP notes that HDDs transfer files more slowly and are more susceptible to knocks than SSDs. A single drive is not a substitute for a separate backup, either.

Portable SSD for frequent transfers

A good fit if: you regularly move large project folders between computers or often take the drive with you.

The trade-off: Manufacturers' peak-speed figures are not a guarantee of the performance you'll get with your computer or when copying a complete folder. An SSD also needs a separate backup.

The table shows which consideration is most important for each option. The percentages refer to consumers choosing an external HDD or SSD for a podcast archive.

Consideration What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Space for projects Check the size of your complete folder collection and allow for planned growth. If I'm archiving raw recordings and project files too, I need enough room for complete folders. Around 33% of consumers say archive storage is their top buying priority.
Recoverability Allow space for an additional copy and test restoring a project folder. If recordings can't simply be made again, I don't want to rely on a single drive. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability first.
Access to files Check the file system works with both computers, and test the audio and project files you need with the appropriate software. If I want to open my files on different computers, the drive and file formats need to work with my workflow. For around 20% of consumers, access across devices is their main consideration.
Mobile transfers Check the connection and cable against your devices. Don't judge speed by a peak figure alone. If I often take projects with me and move large folders, a mobile workflow is essential. Around 14% of consumers put mobile transfers first.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming one drive is a complete backup

    A fault, loss or damage to the place where it's stored could make your only copy unusable. Keep a second copy separately, and make sure you can actually restore it.

    A separate backup requires an additional storage device and time to test that you can restore your files.

    Plan for a second copy and check that you can restore and open a complete episode along with its project files. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping backups somewhere they won't be affected by the same risks as the originals.

  • Confusing audio format with a drive's file system

    The file system determines how you access the drive; the audio or project format applies to the files stored on it. Reformatting can delete existing files, as Apple warns in its Disk Utility guidance.

    First, check access on both computers using a copy of a real project. Back up all your files somewhere else before reformatting a drive.

  • Choosing an SSD based only on its stated top speed

    A peak-speed figure doesn't automatically tell you how quickly a complete project folder will copy on your computer. The connection, cable and test conditions also make a difference.

    Before making a speed claim your main buying criterion, compare your actual transfer needs with the connection options on your devices.

Key brands at a glance

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics range includes portable HDDs for archives that will mostly stay in one place or only be moved occasionally. Toshiba lists the HDTB520EK3AA variant with 2 TB of storage.

  • Toshiba says Canvio Basics can be used with Windows without any additional installation.
  • Check the file system and backup arrangements for your computers. The Windows compatibility information doesn't tell you how every Mac setup will work, and it won't protect you against drive failure.

Seagate

Seagate's range of portable external HDDs is available in 1 TB, 2 TB, 4 TB and 5 TB versions.

  • Seagate describes the drive as connecting via USB 3.0 without a separate power supply.
  • Matching storage capacities alone don't tell you whether a particular version will work with your connections and cables or meet your backup needs.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield is an SSD range for frequent transfers and travel. Samsung lists the black 2-TB version as MU-PE2T0S/EU.

  • Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and IP65 protection for this model.
  • These are manufacturer claims for the specific model, not a guarantee against data loss or a promise of transfer performance in your workflow.

Crucial

The X9 is a range of portable SSDs with a USB-C connection, and an option for frequent copying and travel.

  • Crucial gives the X9 a read speed of up to 1,050 MB/s.
  • According to Crucial, the maximum sequential performance was measured on a high-performance desktop PC, so results may vary on other devices.

Joybuy products for HDD archiving

The WD Elements models below are external HDDs for podcast and project archives. The selection includes portable versions as well as a desktop model for use mostly in one place.

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

For an archive you mostly take with you, if 5 TB is enough for your current collection and planned growth.

5 TB storage capacity; USB-C. The product description warns against exposing the drive to knocks.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

For a portable archive, if your complete episode and project folders make good use of 6 TB.

6 TB storage capacity; USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

For a portable archive, if 4 TB is enough for your current project collection and planned growth.

4 TB storage capacity; USB-C.

Joybuy
WD Elements 2 TB Portable, USB-C, exFAT

WD Elements 2 TB Portable, USB-C, exFAT

For a smaller archive or selected project folders, if 2 TB is enough for your planned collection.

2 TB storage capacity; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; 2.5 inches; exFAT.

Joybuy
WD Elements 8 TB desktop hard drive

WD Elements 8 TB desktop hard drive

For a large archive that will mostly stay in one place.

8 TB storage capacity; USB 3.0; 3.5 inches. Requires an external power supply to operate.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a different hard drive for MP3, WAV or FLAC files?

No. Choose a drive based on the storage space, connection and access you need. Whether you can edit a saved audio or project file later also depends on having the right software. FLAC is a lossless audio coding format, not a drive file system, as explained by the Library of Congress.

Can I use the same drive with Mac and Windows?

It may be possible with a compatible file system. You should also check the connections and cables for both computers beforehand. Apple warns that formatting can delete existing files, so save them somewhere else first.

Is one external hard drive enough as the only copy of my episodes?

No, not if you need to recover episodes after a fault, loss or damage to the place where they're stored. Keep an additional copy separately, and test that you can actually restore and open a project. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends storing backups separately from the originals.

What else should I plan for when setting up an archive?

If needed, allow for a second backup device and any cables or adapters you require. For the specific model, check what's included, the warranty terms and how to make a claim.

Can I keep podcast recordings featuring identifiable guests indefinitely?

There is no blanket permission or retention period that applies in every case. If an organisation processes recordings containing personal data, it must follow the applicable legal basis and principles such as purpose limitation, storage limitation, and integrity and confidentiality. What retention period is permitted in a particular case depends on the purpose and applicable legal framework. The European Data Protection Board explains these principles.