A protein shake can be convenient after a workout, while a meal replacement shake can stand in for a complete meal. However, both product categories are often marketed in similar ways. If you only look for terms such as “high protein”, “reduced sugar” or “ready to drink”, you may overlook important differences.
Typical purchasing mistakes arise from three points:
The following selection categorises different protein shakes and meal replacement drinks according to specific everyday situations. This makes it easier to see whether vegan protein powder, a post-workout shake or a ready-to-drink meal is right for your needs.
For powdered products, the recommended amount should be taken into account. According to the product information, the Nutri+ Starter Sets Box Vegan 8x30g 6K I provides 25 g of protein per 30-g serving. 300 ml of liquid is recommended for preparation. This represents a clearly defined serving, although milk or plant-based drinks may further alter the nutritional values.
The Optimum Nutrition High Protein Shake contains 25 g of protein per 330-ml bottle. This figure can be compared directly with other bottled products. The bottle also contains 185 kcal, 1.0 g of fat and 13 g of sugar. “No added sugar” should therefore not be confused with “low in sugar”.
If you follow a vegan diet, you should read the full ingredients list. The Nutri+ 6K Protein Powder combines, among other ingredients, soya, wheat, rice, pea, sunflower and almond protein. This makes the product plant-based, but it also contains several potential allergens. According to the product information, the 3K variants are based on soya, pea and sunflower protein; certain flavours are listed as wheat-free.
Dairy-based products, on the other hand, are not suitable for a vegan diet. The Optimum Nutrition Shake contains milk ingredients. The yfood drinks are also made with milk protein and, according to the information available, are not vegan. Labels such as “lactose-free” or “gluten-free” do not change this.
A powder containing around 23 to 25 g of protein per serving is primarily a high-protein supplement. It does not automatically replace a complete meal. Products with a higher energy content and additional micronutrients should be assessed differently if you will be without a regular meal for a longer period.
The yfood products are sold as drinkable meals. A 500-ml bottle in the Classic Choco, Happy Banana, Heavenly Hazelnut, Cold Brew, Fresh Berry or Smooth Vanilla flavours provides approximately 500 kcal, depending on the variant. For the flavours mentioned, the nutritional values are around 30 to 33 g of protein per bottle, supplemented with fibre, vitamins and minerals. Before buying, check the flavour, calorie requirements, allergens and the specific nutritional table for the variant in question.
Why this product suits this profile: Eight flavours, each with 30 g of powder, let you try different options before buying a larger pack. Prepare it with 300 ml of liquid in a shaker.
The sample sizes reduce the risk of buying a large tub in a flavour you do not enjoy. The protein content is stated per serving.
Plant-based multi-component blend, 25 g of protein per serving and eight flavours.
Why this product suits this profile: This ready-to-drink protein shake is portioned and requires neither a shaker nor refrigeration before opening. It is ideal for training days, the office and commuting.
The nutritional values per 330-ml bottle make comparison transparent. Despite having no added sugar, the product contains 13 g of sugar per bottle.
25 g of protein per bottle, 185 kcal and 1.0 g of fat; ready to drink chilled.
Why this product suits this profile: The 1-kg pack is aimed at people who use vegan protein powder regularly and want to adjust their servings themselves with water or a plant-based drink.
The 30-g serving and recommended 300 ml of liquid are clearly stated. Ingredients and allergens can be checked before purchase.
Plant-based protein blend with 23 g of protein per serving and a large pack for regular use.
Why this product suits this profile: The 500-ml bottles are ready to drink and designed as meal replacements. They are suitable for the office, travelling or days when mealtimes are difficult to plan.
The bottle size and energy content of 500 kcal per 500 ml help distinguish a drinkable meal from a small protein snack.
According to the product information, around 32.5 g of protein per bottle, along with fibre, vitamins and minerals; milk-based and not vegan.
We have put together a complete, regularly updated list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the safety regulations applicable in the EU.
This depends on its intended use and the rest of your diet. For a post-workout shake or a high-protein snack, the products mentioned, with around 23 to 25 g of protein per serving or bottle, are comparable. What matters is your total daily intake, not just the individual shake.
Ordinary protein powder is not automatically suitable for this purpose. It mainly provides protein and must be assessed in terms of energy, fat, carbohydrates, fibre, vitamins and minerals. A shake specifically labelled as a meal replacement has a different formulation for this purpose. Even so, the nutritional information should be checked before buying.
This depends on the product. For the yfood shakes mentioned, the recommendation is to refrigerate the opened bottle and consume it within 24 hours. For the Optimum Nutrition Shake, refrigeration after opening and consumption within three days are specified. The packaging takes precedence.