Which option is right for you?

Local game with a character for everyone

If several people are solving puzzles at the same time and want to control their own characters, what matters is the number of local player slots and the inputs accepted by the specific game – not just the number of connections supported by the console. Nintendo explains that Joy-Con can be used individually in games that support this style of play; PICO PARK 2 supports two to eight local players.

Group with an existing console or PC

If you’re adding controllers to a system you already own, check that the game supports your specific platform and console generation. Nintendo notes that Switch and Switch 2 accessories differ, while Sony says that up to four controllers can be used at once with PS5.

Puzzle night without a gamepad for everyone

In Jackbox, smartphones act as controllers. In Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes, one person operates the bomb while everyone else helps using the manual. These styles of play don’t require a separate gamepad for each person.

What should you check before buying?

What you need What to check before buying Most important for
Compatibility Check the console generation or PC operating system, as well as the input requirements of the specific game. If I’m adding controllers to a system I already own, I want to avoid buying the wrong one for my console, generation or game. Compatibility is the top priority for around 36% of consumers.
Inputs at the same time Check the number of local player slots and supported controller types, and count any controllers you already own. If everyone wants to control their own character, I need enough usable inputs – not just a high connection limit. Around 29% of consumers are most concerned about having enough individual inputs.
Extra gamepads Check first whether the game uses smartphones, shared character controls or a separate controller for each person. If smartphones or shared puzzle roles are enough, I don’t want to buy gamepads for inputs the game doesn’t require. Avoiding unnecessary gamepads is the main concern for around 21% of consumers.
Connections and power For wired models, check the connection and cable length; for wireless models, check the power supply and charging options. If several people are sitting close together, I want to plan for cables and power that suit the playing area. Practicality is the top concern for around 14% of consumers.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Confusing the maximum number of connections with the number of players

    The console and the specific game can impose different limits on your group. Being able to connect several controllers doesn’t guarantee that the game supports the same number of local players.

    Before you buy, check the local player limit for the game you want and which types of input it supports. Sony says that up to four controllers can be used at once with PS5.

  • Assuming a Joy-Con 2 wheel includes an extra controller

    Nintendo lists the two-wheel set as an accessory; Joy-Con 2 are not included. The accessory alone therefore doesn’t add another controller.

    Check what’s included and make sure you already have the Joy-Con 2 you need, or plan to buy them separately.

  • Buying a gamepad for everyone solving puzzles

    In Jackbox, smartphones can act as controllers. In Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes, one person at a time defuses the bomb while everyone else helps using the manual.

    First decide which game your group wants to play, then check the roles and inputs it requires.

  • Overlooking platform and charging requirements

    Nintendo says that older Joy-Con can’t be attached to or charged on Switch 2. PowerA states that the Advantage Wired only works when Switch 2 is docked.

    Check your console generation, play mode and charging options before ordering. For wired models, make sure the connection also suits your playing area.

Brands at a glance

Nintendo

Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 are worth considering for local games with the corresponding Switch generation.

  • Nintendo explains that Joy-Con can be used individually in games that support this style of play. For the original Switch, Nintendo says up to eight controllers can be synchronised wirelessly, depending on the controller type and features used.
  • Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 are for Switch 2 only. Being able to connect a controller doesn’t guarantee that every game supports the same number of players.

Microsoft Xbox

A full-size option for Xbox and compatible Windows PC games.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, a hybrid D-pad and customisable button mapping for the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • These details don’t confirm Switch compatibility or a specific number of people who can play a PC game at once.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is a relevant choice for an existing PS5 and supported PC games.

  • Sony says up to four controllers can be used at once with PS5, and that supported devices can connect to a PC via Bluetooth or USB.
  • Some features depend on the device and game. Adding more DualSense controllers won’t lift Sony’s stated limit of four controllers on PS5.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wired is a wired option for compatible Windows PCs.

  • 8BitDo lists USB wired connectivity and Windows 10 or later as requirements.
  • Switch compatibility isn’t specified for this model. Manufacturer claims about precision and durability aren’t evidence of an advantage for puzzle games.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired is a wired option for a docked Switch 2.

  • PowerA lists a 3 m USB-C cable and Nintendo licensing.
  • PowerA says the controller only works with Switch 2 docked and doesn’t support motion controls or Joy-Con games.

Controllers for local puzzle nights

This Joybuy selection includes controllers for compatible local multiplayer games on Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, as well as suitable Xbox, PC and PS5 games. Before you buy, check the specific game and the inputs you’ll need.

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair in blue and light yellow

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 Pair (Blue/Light Yellow)

For compatible local multiplayer games on Nintendo Switch 2 when your group needs extra Joy-Con inputs.

Pair; listed as designed for Nintendo Switch 2 only.

View at Joybuy
Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller in Deep Pink

Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller – Deep Pink

For compatible Xbox or PC games when you need a full-size controller.

Listed as a wireless controller for Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S and PC.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair in Neon Blue and Neon Yellow

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Pair (Neon Blue/Neon Yellow)

For compatible local Switch games that support using the Joy-Con separately as controllers.

Joy-Con pair; separate controls depend on the game.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 HE Wired Controller with Hall Effect sticks in black

GameSir G7 HE Wired Controller with Hall Effect Sticks (Black)

For compatible Xbox or Windows PC games when a wired full-size controller suits your playing area.

Wired; listed as compatible with Xbox and Windows PC.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller in white

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller (White)

For supported PS5 and PC games when the title accepts DualSense inputs.

Listed as compatible with PS5, PC, Mac and Android. Sony says up to four controllers can be used at once with PS5.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do eight connected controllers automatically mean eight people can play the same puzzle game?

No. Nintendo says the original Switch can have up to eight controllers synchronised wirelessly, depending on the controller type and features used; the game itself also determines how many people can play locally. The PC version of PICO PARK 2 supports two to eight local players.

Can older Switch Joy-Con be used and charged with Switch 2?

Nintendo says they can be used wirelessly, but not attached directly to or charged on Switch 2. Nintendo lists an original Switch or suitable charging accessories as charging options.

When can a big puzzle group get by without an extra controller?

In Jackbox, smartphones act as controllers. In Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes, one person operates the bomb while the others help using the manual. Check that the specific game supports this way of playing.

How many controllers can be used at once with PS5?

Sony says up to four controllers can be used at once with PS5. So buying more DualSense controllers won’t automatically add extra controller slots for a larger local group; check the player limit for the game too.

What rights do you have if an online-purchased controller is faulty in Germany?

For a consumer purchase from a retailer, Your Europe says you’re generally entitled to a legal guarantee of at least two years from receipt; this is separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. Many online purchases also come with a 14-day right to cancel, starting from delivery, although exceptions and the terms of the specific purchase apply.