Which controller is right for you?

Players practising quarter-circle motions

If you want to practise the sequence of down, down-forward, forward, first decide whether you want to use an arcade stick, individual directional buttons or a D-pad. Hit Box Arcade describes the directional input, while the input history in Street Fighter 6's training mode can help you check your sequence.

Players in a dark room

If you want to find the controls when the room is dimly lit, check whether the specific model has illuminated buttons or labels, or simply an RGB light ring or another lighting feature. 8BitDo, Razer and Qanba describe different types of lighting.

Players with a set platform

If you're looking for a controller for a particular console or PC, check the full model number and any adapter or firmware requirements. HORI and MAYFLASH list differences depending on the platform or model.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide which input motion you want to practise, then check the platform and model version. For playing in the dark, what matters is which control is illuminated – not simply whether the model has RGB lighting.

Consideration What to check Who is it important to?
Movement sequence Arcade stick, individual directional buttons or D-pad; input history in-game, if available. If I want to practise the exact motion I'll use later, I choose the right input type first. Around 33% of consumers put this movement sequence first.
Visibility in low light Check whether the buttons, labels or just a light ring or another RGB accent is illuminated. If I want to find the controls I need quickly in a dark room, it matters which part of the controller is lit. Visibility is the main priority for around 25% of consumers.
Platform compatibility Full model number; where specified, check the firmware and required adapter too. If I'm buying for a particular console or PC, I want to avoid choosing an incompatible model version. Around 25% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility.
Space and maintenance Case dimensions and cable routing; check the exact pinout before replacing any parts. If desk space, storage or replacing parts later matters to me, I check the case and connections in advance. Around 17% of consumers prioritise these practical considerations for use and maintenance.

Buying decisions worth checking

  • Assuming RGB means the input buttons will be visible

    A light ring, illuminated labels and illuminated buttons are different features. An RGB effect alone doesn't tell you whether you'll be able to see the directional buttons clearly in the dark.

    Check which buttons or labels actually light up on the exact model.

  • Assuming similarly named console versions are the same

    The HORI SPF-013U and AB11-001U models are designed for different platforms. For PS5 use with the F300 Elite, MAYFLASH specifies firmware V1.15 and the MagicBoots-S5 adapter.

    Before buying, check the full model number, your platform and any required accessories. Using an adapter may mean extra setup and accessories.

  • Assuming ‘Silent’ or replaceable parts mean the whole device is silent

    Qanba's claims apply to specific components of the Q8. The manufacturer also notes that certain joystick types have different pinouts on the HORI SPF-013U.

    Assess the stick and buttons separately, and check that the specific parts are compatible before making any modifications.

    Finding the right replacement parts may involve extra time for checking compatibility and fitting them.

Relevant brands to consider

HORI

The Fighting Stick α range includes arcade sticks for different platforms, while the Fighting Commander OCTA is a fightpad with a D-pad.

  • According to HORI, the case of the PlayStation SPF-013U model can be opened for maintenance. The D-pad sensitivity on the SPF-023U fightpad is adjustable.
  • The SPF-013U and AB11-001U are different platform versions. This doesn't amount to a general claim that the action buttons are illuminated.

MAYFLASH

The range includes arcade sticks such as the F300 Elite and F500 Elite, as well as the all-button F500 FLAT Elite controller.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components for the F300 Elite and F500 Elite.
  • For PS5 use with the F300 Elite, MAYFLASH specifies firmware V1.15 and the MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Certain console connections for the F500 FLAT Elite are also subject to additional requirements.

8BitDo

The range includes arcade controllers with a stick, as well as button-only models.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller Pro has illuminated button labels. For the Arcade Controller for Xbox, the manufacturer lists an RGB light ring.
  • A light ring isn't the same as illuminated button labels. The Arcade Stick models for Switch/PC and Xbox are platform-specific versions.

Razer

The Kitsune is a slim all-button controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists optical switches, a detachable USB-C cable and Chroma RGB lighting.
  • The RGB specification doesn't confirm that every directional button is illuminated, or that it has been shown to make quarter-circle motions easier to learn.

Qanba

According to the manufacturer, the Q8 is a PC-focused arcade stick for players interested in components described as quiet and illuminated buttons.

  • Qanba describes the Q8's stick as ‘Silent’ and its buttons as RGB LED ‘Silent’ buttons.
  • These are manufacturer-specific claims, not independent measurements of noise or visibility. The product information consulted doesn't specify console compatibility.

Related products at Joybuy

This selection includes a leverless all-button controller for practising quarter-circle motions using individual directional buttons.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android

The all-button layout is a good fit if you want to practise quarter-circle motions using individual directional buttons.

Listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired connectivity.

Listed in the product title: hot-swappable Fast-Trigger mechanical switches and RGB.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I check whether my quarter-circle input registers in-game?

Start by practising the sequence down, down-forward, forward on both sides of the screen. If you play Street Fighter 6, the input history in training mode can help you check it; whether an input registers depends on the game and its controls.

Are RGB lighting and illuminated buttons the same thing?

No. Qanba describes the Q8's buttons as RGB LED buttons; 8BitDo lists illuminated labels on the Arcade Controller Pro and an RGB light ring on the Arcade Controller for Xbox. Check which part is illuminated on the specific model.

What do I need to use a MAYFLASH F300 Elite with a PS5?

MAYFLASH documents PS5 use with the MagicBoots-S5 adapter and firmware V1.15. The instructions specify a Windows PC for the firmware update, so check the adapter, device and setup requirements together before buying.

What are my rights in Germany if a product is faulty or I want to cancel an online purchase?

According to Verbraucherzentrale, if a newly purchased item is faulty, you can generally exercise your statutory warranty rights against the seller within two years of receiving it; this is separate from any voluntary guarantee. For online purchases, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel from the day you receive the goods, subject to the specific conditions set out by law.

Can I put an old arcade controller in the household rubbish in Germany?

No. The German Environment Agency advises against disposing of old electrical equipment with household waste; local collection points accept it free of charge. You may also be able to return it to a retailer if the applicable take-back conditions are met.