Lots of bound recipe pages
If you want to scan lots of pages without pressing the binding against a glass surface, key things to consider include book mode, the capture area and how well the pages are flattened.
For many bound recipe pages, an overhead book scanner with page flattening and a sufficiently large capture area is a good option if you don’t want to press the book against a glass surface. A flatbed scanner may be enough for a few pages that lie flat, while a library scanner you can access is another option for a one-off school project. Check the binding, handwriting and images in a sample scan rather than assuming that an OCR specification guarantees error-free text.
If you want to scan lots of pages without pressing the binding against a glass surface, key things to consider include book mode, the capture area and how well the pages are flattened.
If ingredients, margin notes or photos matter, check that they’re legible in the saved file. Correct any recognised text before using it elsewhere.
If you only need a few scans, compare buying your own device with using a library scanner that you can access.
First, work out whether you need to scan lots of bound pages or just a few. That will help you decide between an overhead scanner, a flatbed scanner or an accessible library scanner.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Binding and book gutter | Check that the capture area can fit the open book, and test book mode and legibility near the gutter using a sample page. | If I’m scanning lots of bound pages, I want to leave the book open and capture entries near the gutter clearly. Around 28 % of consumers put the binding and gutter first. |
| Handwriting and images | Check small print, contrast, page edges and, where relevant, glossy photos in the saved file. | If handwritten ingredients or images are important for my school project, I need a clear scan. Around 22 % of consumers prioritise handwriting and illustrations. |
| Searchable recipe text | Check the required output formats and test text recognition on one of your own sample pages. Proofread recognised ingredients and quantities. | If I want to search recipes or edit the text, I need recognised text as well as the scanned image. Around 17 % of consumers prioritise searchable and editable text. |
| One-off use | Think about how many pages and scanning sessions you’ll need, and check the availability and terms of use of a library scanner. | If I’m only scanning for a school project, I’ll compare buying a device with using a scanner I can access locally. Around 22 % of consumers put the cost of buying a device first when they only need it once. |
| Workspace and software | Measure the space needed for the device and the open book, and check that the software and export formats work with the specific model and your computer. | If I’m short on desk space, I need room for both the device and the open book. The workflow on my computer needs to suit me too. Around 11 % of consumers prioritise space and setup. |
VIISAN says that text recognition depends on the source material and layout. Ingredients, quantities and handwritten additions may therefore need to be checked.
Keep the scanned image and compare the recognised text with the original before handing in your work.
Allow time to correct ingredients, quantities and handwritten additions.
Avision describes the FB10 as having a lift-up lid for thicker documents, but doesn’t specify a feature for scanning along a book gutter. A tight binding may therefore make it harder to capture text near the gutter.
Check the stated scanner type and test a page with text close to the binding.
A fast scan doesn’t eliminate the time needed to turn pages, name files and check the results.
Plan your workflow around several typical pages and check the finished files.
You may need extra time to turn pages, name files and check them.
Legal exceptions have different requirements and don’t give blanket permission to share or publish anything.
Distinguish your own notes from other people’s published works, and check who will receive the material and how much you plan to use before sharing it.
The Aura Pro is classed as a portable overhead scanner, while the ET series is a separate range of book scanners.
The VK16 is described as an overhead book scanner with a document camera, designed for bound books and searchable files.
The IRIScan Desk 7 Pro is a compact overhead scanner with a short camera arm.
The FB10 is an A4 flatbed scanner for documents that can be positioned flat on the glass.
The OpticBook 3800L is a flatbed scanner designed for bound documents.
Not necessarily. For example, Reutlingen City Library offers a book scanner that you can use for free without a library card. For a location you can get to, check the opening hours, terms of use and whether it’s suitable for your material.
Measure the open book, position a typical double-page spread in the capture area and check the saved file for the gutter, page edges and legible quantities. VIISAN describes the VK16 as having a book mode with page flattening and page splitting; this is a manufacturer feature specific to that model.
Before buying, check that the software for the specific model works with your computer and supports the export formats you need. For the IRIScan Desk 6, 6 Pro and 6 Business, the IRIS Help Centre describes an online installer and the camera permissions required; other models have their own instructions. If you only scan occasionally, you could also compare the time involved in visiting a library with the cost of buying a device.
That depends on the source material and how you use it. Under the conditions set out in § 60a UrhG, up to 15 per cent of a published work may generally be used to illustrate non-commercial teaching for the specified groups of people. § 53 UrhG distinguishes private copies from redistribution and restricts, in particular, copying books that are substantially complete. The Federal Ministry of Justice’s Laws on the Internet therefore don’t provide blanket permission to scan an entire recipe book belonging to someone else or upload it publicly.