A NAS is a good choice if you want several devices on your home network to access the same recipes, or you’d like to manage your files in one place. For occasional copies from a single computer, an external hard drive may be simpler. Whichever option you choose, set up a separate backup and test restoring a file from it: mirrored NAS drives alone are no substitute for a separate backup.
Who is a NAS archive for?
Home cooks using several devices
If you want to access recipe files from different devices on your home network, a central folder can be useful. Synology describes file access via common network protocols, while QNAP lists Gigabit Ethernet for the TS-233.
Home cooks with important recipe archives
For recipes you’ve created or collected, it’s important to make sure an additional copy can actually be restored. The Federal Office for Information Security lists removable hard drives as a storage medium for personal backups.
People who back up one device occasionally
If you only copy recipes from a computer now and again, you can weigh up the time and effort involved in setting up and maintaining a NAS against using a removable hard drive. The Federal Office for Information Security also lists removable hard drives as a possible storage medium for personal backups.
What should you look for when choosing one?
NAS as a local recipe archive
A good fit if: you want several devices on your home network to access the same recipe files.
Bear in mind: setup and maintenance are part of the package. Cloud syncing and remote access over the internet aren’t needed for local storage.
External hard drive
A good fit if: you occasionally copy files from a computer and don’t need shared network storage.
Bear in mind: copying and restoring files depend on you following the process reliably.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| Local storage without cloud storage |
Set up local file access and check whether cloud syncing is enabled as a storage destination. |
If you deliberately want to store recipe files on your home network rather than in public cloud storage, make sure the local option works for everyday use. Around 36% of consumers prioritise local storage without a public cloud destination. |
| An archive you can restore |
Set up a separate backup destination and plan a restoration test. |
If you have recipes of your own that you don’t want to lose, it’s important to have an extra copy you can restore. Around 29% of consumers prioritise an archive they can restore. |
| Access from several devices |
Check which local access methods are supported and whether they’re compatible with the devices you use. |
If you want your recipes to be available on several devices on your home network, look for a suitable shared access option. Around 21% of consumers put access from multiple devices first. |
| Simple setup |
Think about how often you’ll copy files, who’ll manage updates and how you’d restore a file. |
If you only occasionally back up recipes from one computer, a network storage device that runs all the time may require more maintenance than you need. Around 14% of consumers prioritise simple setup. |
Common mistakes
-
Assuming a ‘private cloud’ means storage without the cloud
The NAS models described may also offer features for public cloud syncing or remote access over the internet. The product name alone doesn’t tell you where files will be synced.
Set up local file access and check every syncing and backup destination before storing recipe files there.
-
Assuming mirrored drives count as a complete backup
Mirroring also copies accidental changes or deletions. In its guidance for organisations, the Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes this kind of mirroring from a data backup.
Keep a separate copy and test restoring a recipe file from it.
An additional backup medium and regular restoration tests take time and planning.
-
Buying a NAS for occasional copies from one computer
If you don’t need shared access on your home network, the ongoing setup and maintenance may be more than you need. The Federal Office for Information Security also lists removable hard drives as a storage medium for personal backups.
Before buying, compare a simple copying process using an external hard drive and think about how you’d retrieve a file.
A NAS involves setup and maintenance; with an external hard drive, you need to stick to a reliable copying schedule.
NAS brands at a glance
The details below relate to documented features of specific models and aren’t a general assessment of entire brands.
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is one example of a central document store with local file access.
- Synology describes local file management and several backup destinations for the DS223j. The product manual also lists a USB port for external drives.
- QuickConnect and public cloud syncing are additional options. To store files without using the cloud, keep recipe files local and don’t sync them to a public cloud destination.
QNAP
QNAP describes the TS-233 as a NAS with two drive bays for central storage on your home network.
- QNAP’s specifications list Gigabit Ethernet and USB ports.
- Ports alone don’t set up a backup. QNAP advises against making a NAS directly accessible from the internet without protection.
ASUSTOR
According to the manufacturer, the Drivestor 2 AS1102T has two drive bays and local SMB file services.
- ASUSTOR lists USB ports and 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet. The specifications state that the model supports internal 3.5-inch SATA hard drives.
- The network port alone doesn’t prove you’ll see a practical speed benefit with small recipe documents. The rest of your network setup would also need to be suitable.
TerraMaster
TerraMaster describes the F2-212 as a home storage device for files and documents.
- The manufacturer’s description lists file management features.
- It also mentions remote access and syncing with public cloud services. For your intended use, it depends on which storage destinations you actually set up.
Products for local storage and backups
This Joybuy selection includes NAS models for central file storage, as well as an external hard drive as a possible alternative for occasional copies from one computer. You’ll need to set up each NAS for local use and choose your preferred storage destinations.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS
A good option for a central recipe archive on your home network if you need several drives and file sharing. Set it up without public cloud storage destinations.
- 4 drive bays
- Two 2.5GbE network ports
- Expandable to up to 9 drive bays
- M.2 NVMe SSD caching
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS
An option for a central recipe archive if you need several drive bays. Check first whether you can set up local access without public cloud storage destinations.
- 8 drive bays
- Two 2.5GbE network ports
- Optional 10GbE
- Up to 360 TB
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 2TB Portable External Hard Drive
This could be an alternative if you occasionally copy recipe files from one computer and don’t need shared access over a NAS network. For important files, plan an additional, separate backup.
- 2 TB
- USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1
- 2.5-inch format
- exFAT
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to enable remote access over the internet for local recipe files?
No. You don’t need remote access over the internet to access files on your home network. Synology describes file access via common network protocols separately from QuickConnect. QNAP advises against making a NAS directly accessible from the internet without protection, so check the settings on your specific device.
How can I check that my recipe backup works?
Make an extra copy on a separate storage device and test restoring a recipe file from it. The Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes data mirroring from a separate backup, so test that you can actually restore your files.
What costs and components should I consider when buying a NAS?
Check what’s included in the specific offer, which drives you’ll need and whether you need an additional backup device. Whether drives are included depends on the offer.
Does a NAS need regular maintenance?
Yes. Remember to check for and install available software updates. The Federal Office for Information Security explains that updates can fix errors and close security vulnerabilities.
Does the GDPR apply to my privately stored recipe archive?
According to the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information, the household exemption applies when personal data is processed solely for personal or family purposes. Whether it applies in a particular case depends on how the data is used; choosing between a NAS and the cloud doesn’t settle the question on its own.