Which solution suits you?

Players with an analogue console

If your console outputs Composite or S-Video and you have a recording PC, look for a grabber with the right input. The video standard and computer compatibility also need to suit your planned setup.

Players with an HDMI recording setup

An HDMI capture card may be suitable for a console with a compatible HDMI output, or with a signal converter connected first. If you want to play on a separate screen while recording, make sure the connections throughout the chain work together.

Players without a recording PC

If you don’t want a recording PC in your spare room, a standalone recorder could be a good fit. The key considerations are the video input you need and a compatible storage medium.

What to look for when choosing

Analogue USB grabber connected to a PC

Suitable if: Your console outputs Composite or S-Video and you have a compatible recording PC.

Trade-off: An analogue connection may save you from needing an HDMI converter, but it won’t necessarily offer HDMI passthrough for a separate screen.

Video processor plus HDMI capture card

Suitable if: You want to connect an analogue console signal to an HDMI recording setup, or already have a suitable HDMI output.

Trade-off: With an analogue source, you’ll need extra equipment and connections. Check compatibility with your specific console and the entire signal chain.

Standalone recorder

Suitable if: You want to record directly in your spare room without a recording PC.

Trade-off: Whether it suits your setup depends on the inputs and supported storage media of the specific model.

Requirement What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Direct analogue connection Check your console’s output, Composite or S-Video connection, suitable audio plugs, video standard and supported operating system. If I want to record an analogue console on my PC without an unnecessary HDMI converter, I’ll pay particular attention to the inputs. Around 36% of consumers have this as their main requirement.
HDMI signal chain Check the console’s output format, the video processor’s supported inputs and output, and the capture card’s HDMI input together. If I want to include my analogue retro console in an HDMI recording setup, the signal conversion needs to work with both the console and the capture card. Around 29% of consumers rank this as their top requirement.
Recording without a PC Check the recorder’s HDMI or Composite input, power supply and supported storage medium. If I want to record in my spare room without a recording PC, the inputs and compatible storage medium are crucial. Around 21% of consumers prioritise recording without a PC.
Separate gaming screen Check HDMI passthrough, the connections for your source and screen, and any preview settings on your PC. If I want to play on a separate screen while recording, I’ll check the planned connection route and distinguish it from the software preview. Around 14% of consumers prioritise this requirement.

Common assumptions to avoid

  • Connecting an HDMI capture card directly to Composite or S-Video

    An HDMI capture card needs a compatible HDMI signal. If your console is purely analogue, you’ll need a suitable signal converter before the card.

    First check your console’s actual video output, then plan the complete signal chain.

    Depending on your console, you may need an extra signal converter, suitable cables and a power supply.

  • Assuming PAL support means compatibility with every PAL console

    Support for a particular video standard or format alone doesn’t guarantee that a specific console and cable combination will work. RetroTINK provides specific guidance on certain console signals and using S-Video cables with PAL consoles.

    Check the details for your console model, output and cable, then test the specific combination.

  • Assuming a USB stick will work as storage with a PC-free recorder

    AVerMedia explicitly excludes USB flash drives as a storage medium for the EzRecorder 330.

    Before buying, check the storage medium you want to use against the specifications for the specific recorder model.

    If your existing USB stick isn’t supported, you’ll need to plan for another compatible storage medium.

  • Confusing the advertised recording resolution with the resolution of a retro source

    Specifications for an HDMI capture card and PAL recordings from an analogue grabber refer to different devices and stages of the signal chain. A high capture card resolution won’t automatically change your console’s output signal.

    Check the source signal, signal conversion and actual recording format separately. Choose a capture card resolution that suits your setup.

Relevant brands to consider

Hauppauge

Hauppauge offers both analogue USB recording devices and standalone HDMI recording models.

  • For the USB-Live2, Hauppauge specifies Composite and S-Video recording, stereo audio and PAL recording at 720 × 576 pixels and 25 frames per second. The stated Windows recording software applies to this model.
  • The HD PVR Rocket is a different model with different video inputs. Its ability to record to a USB memory stick shouldn’t be confused with the features of the USB-Live2.

AVerMedia

AVerMedia offers the DVD EZMaker 7 C039 analogue USB grabber and the EzRecorder 330 ER330 standalone recorder.

  • According to AVerMedia, the C039 records Composite and S-Video and supports PAL/SECAM. The ER330 has HDMI and Composite inputs for standalone recording.
  • According to the manufacturer, the C039 doesn’t support macOS. For the ER330, AVerMedia lists Micro SD, external drives and NAS, but excludes USB flash drives as a storage medium. No S-Video input is listed for this model.

Elgato

The Game Capture 4K S is designed for an HDMI recording and passthrough setup with a computer.

  • Elgato describes an HDMI input and output, and connection of the 4K S via USB 3.0.
  • A direct Composite or S-Video input isn’t listed for this model. Its advertised recording resolution doesn’t mean an analogue retro source outputs at that resolution.

RetroTINK

The RetroTINK-2X Pro is a video processor that could be used before an HDMI capture card; it isn’t a capture card itself.

  • According to the manufacturer, the 2X Pro supports Composite, S-Video and Component, as well as 240p, 288p, 480i and 576i formats.
  • RetroTINK notes potential issues with Composite signals from certain Sega Genesis and PS1/PSOne consoles, as well as unsuitable S-Video cables for PAL consoles. Check the guidance for your specific combination.

Joybuy products for HDMI recording

This selection includes HDMI capture cards for a PC setup with a compatible HDMI signal. If your retro console is purely analogue, you’ll need a suitable signal converter first.

4K HDMI Capture Card, USB 3.0, Black + Red

4K HDMI Capture Card, USB 3.0, Black + Red

For recording on a computer with a compatible HDMI signal and HDMI passthrough to a separate screen.

HDMI input up to 4K 30 Hz; recording at 1080p 60 Hz; USB 3.0.

If your console has a purely analogue output, you’ll need a suitable signal converter before the HDMI input.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0

VIELLAN 4K HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0

For a PC setup where the console or a video processor connected first provides a compatible HDMI signal.

4K passthrough; 1080p recording; USB 3.0. Compatible with Windows, macOS and Linux according to the product description.

If your console has a purely analogue output, you’ll need a suitable signal converter before the HDMI input.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0, with microphone input and headphone output

VIELLAN HDMI Video Capture Card, USB 3.0

For HDMI recording on a computer. Before buying, check that the microphone input and headphone output suit your planned setup.

Recording up to 1080p; 4K HDMI passthrough; USB 3.0; UVC and UAC support according to the product description. With microphone input and headphone output.

If your console has a purely analogue output, you’ll need a suitable signal converter before the HDMI input.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I set up analogue recording in OBS?

In OBS, add a Video Capture Device source and select the connected device. In its driver or settings, check that you’ve selected the correct Composite or S-Video input and a supported recording format. A short test recording lets you check the picture and sound together; the available options depend on the device.

What extra equipment do I need to record an analogue console over HDMI?

If your console doesn’t provide a compatible HDMI signal, you’ll need a signal converter that suits the console before the HDMI capture card. For the RetroTINK-2X Pro, make sure you have a suitable power source and the right cables. For connecting a screen, Elgato specifies a second HDMI cable for the Game Capture 4K S. Check the connections for your specific console and cable setup.

Which storage medium is suitable for a PC-free setup?

For the AVerMedia EzRecorder 330, the manufacturer lists Micro SD, external drives and NAS, but explicitly excludes USB flash drives. Before buying, check that your chosen medium is supported and which cables and accessories are included. Check service terms with the relevant seller.

Can I save or publish retro game recordings for private use in Germany?

Under certain conditions, Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows individuals to make individual copies for private use, but this doesn’t mean that every recording or publication is automatically permitted. Section 95a of the UrhG protects effective technological measures against circumvention under the conditions set out in that section. These provisions are included in the version of the legislation provided by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice. Whether a specific recording can be uploaded publicly depends on the rights involved in the game, music and any other content.