Which type of controller is right for you?

Players in a dark room

If you want to identify gamepad controls more easily in low light, check which parts of the controller are lit, as well as whether it’s compatible with your platform. The models reviewed by PowerA and Turtle Beach feature RGB zones or a translucent casing.

Taiko players

If you’d rather play with drumsticks than gamepad buttons, you’ll need a drum version that’s compatible with your game and platform. HORI lists the SPF-042E as compatible with PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10; Bandai Namco lists the PlayStation/PC drum for the PC version of Rhythm Festival.

Players who want to play guitar parts

For guitar controls in supported music games, make sure you choose the right platform version. Turtle Beach lists the Riffmaster for Xbox and Windows, as well as Fortnite Festival and Rock Band 4.

What should you look for when buying?

Standard controller with lighting

A good fit if: Your rhythm game supports gamepad inputs and you want a controller that’s easy to see. PowerA lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11 compatibility; the PDP Afterglow is listed for Switch 2 and other specified Switch models.

Things to consider: The stated RGB zones or illuminated casing don’t mean that the action buttons themselves are backlit. The PowerA controller is wired, while the Afterglow is wireless.

Taiko drum

A good fit if: You want to play Taiko no Tatsujin by hitting a drum rather than pressing gamepad buttons. HORI lists the SPF-042E as compatible with PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10; the PC version of Rhythm Festival lists this PlayStation/PC drum as compatible.

Things to consider: A drum is a specialist controller rather than a versatile gamepad. The listed package includes drumsticks and a stand, but not the game software. Switch drums are a different platform version.

Guitar controller

A good fit if: You want to play guitar parts in Fortnite Festival or Rock Band 4, and the listed Xbox/Windows version is compatible with your platform.

Things to consider: Guitar controls don’t replace a standard gamepad input mode. For wireless use, make sure you have the right wireless receiver and a charged battery.

Wired PC gamepad

A good fit if: You’re looking for a gamepad for Windows where lighting isn’t a priority, and your game supports gamepad inputs. 8BitDo lists the Ultimate 2C Wired as compatible with Windows and Android.

Things to consider: No console platforms are listed for the model reviewed. 8BitDo’s stated 1000 Hz polling rate applies under ideal conditions; it isn’t a measurement of the entire game’s input delay.

What you’re looking for What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Finding your way in low light Check whether the buttons light up, or just the casing and RGB zones. Look for adjustable brightness on the specific version. If I want to find the controls more easily in low light, I want to know exactly what lights up. Around 25% of consumers put visibility in low light first.
Game and platform compatibility Check the full model name, platform version and game requirements. On PC, make sure the game supports gamepad inputs. If a controller doesn’t work with my game or platform, lighting won’t help. Around 31% of consumers prioritise finding the right game and platform combination.
Preferred type of input For Taiko, check that you have the right drum version and that drumsticks are included. For guitar games, check the platform version and wireless accessories. If I want to play drum or guitar parts, I’ll look for the right instrument controller. Around 25% of consumers put this type of input first.
Timing and calibration Check the game’s calibration options, as well as the connection, cable length or any required receiver and battery. If my inputs feel out of sync, I want to be able to check the game’s calibration and the controller connection separately. Around 19% of consumers focus on timing and calibration.

Common buying misconceptions

  • RGB doesn’t automatically mean backlit action buttons

    The product details reviewed describe RGB zones or illuminated parts of the casing. That doesn’t mean that every input button lights up.

    Check exactly which parts are illuminated on the specific model and whether you can adjust the brightness.

  • Don’t choose an instrument controller based on the music game genre alone

    Drums and guitar controllers are designed for specific games and platform versions. The HORI SPF-042E doesn’t include the game software.

    Check the game, platform version and what’s included in the box. If you’re buying a wireless Riffmaster, make sure you have the right receiver and a charged battery.

    You’ll need to buy the game software separately for the HORI drum; the receiver and battery are needed to use the wireless guitar.

  • A high polling rate isn’t the same as overall response time

    8BitDo’s stated 1000 Hz polling rate applies under ideal conditions and doesn’t describe the delay across the entire gaming setup.

    Consider the connection and the game’s calibration options separately from any single manufacturer specification.

Key brands at a glance

PowerA

PowerA offers a wired Advantage controller with Lumectra for Xbox Series X|S; the model page also lists Xbox One and Windows 10/11.

  • For model XBGP0140-02, PowerA lists four RGB zones, assignable extra buttons and a 3 m USB-C cable.
  • The RGB zones don’t confirm that the action buttons are backlit. The model page gives conflicting information about the number of lighting modes.

PDP / Turtle Beach

The models reviewed include illuminated Afterglow gamepads and the Riffmaster guitar controller, for different games and platforms.

  • Turtle Beach lists adjustable RGB lighting and support for additional Switch models for the wireless Afterglow for Switch 2. The Riffmaster is listed for Xbox and Windows, as well as Fortnite Festival and Rock Band 4.
  • Features of one model don’t automatically apply to another. An illuminated casing doesn’t mean the input buttons are backlit.

HORI

HORI offers Taiko drum controllers for specific platforms. The European SPF-042E is listed for PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10.

  • HORI lists a pressure-sensitive playing surface, drumsticks and a stand for the SPF-042E.
  • The game software isn’t included. Features of the PlayStation/PC version can’t be assumed to apply to a Switch version.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wired is a wired gamepad option for games on Windows and Android that support gamepad inputs.

  • 8BitDo lists a D-pad and assignable extra buttons.
  • No console platforms or RGB button lighting are listed for the model reviewed. The manufacturer’s 1000 Hz specification applies under ideal conditions and isn’t a specific latency figure for a rhythm game.

Joybuy products

The Joybuy products below include gamepads for the Switch, Xbox and PC platforms listed in their product details. Several feature RGB or LED lighting; the Razer model featured here is a wired option.

NAXSIR Wireless Gamepad for Switch, T4-14707098

NAXSIR Wireless Gamepad for Switch, T4-14707098

For gamepad games on a supported Switch platform, if you’re looking for wireless use and LED lighting.

The product title lists Bluetooth, 7-colour LED lighting, vibration feedback and a range of 10 m.

View at Joybuy
Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White

Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White

For gamepad games on Xbox or PC, if a wired connection suits you.

The product details list Hall Effect sticks, HyperTriggers, four rear paddles and six assignable buttons.

The detachable USB-C cable is listed as 3 m long.

View at Joybuy
BIGBIG WON Rainbow 2 Pro Wired

BIGBIG WON Rainbow 2 Pro Wired

For gamepad games on one of the listed platforms, if you’re considering a wired controller with customisable RGB lighting.

Compatible platforms listed include PC, Nintendo Switch, Switch Lite and PS4.

The product details also list a gyroscope, macro and turbo functions, and customisable buttons.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Flux Enhanced Wired Controller

GameSir Kaleid Flux Enhanced Wired Controller

For gamepad games on the listed Xbox and Windows platforms, if you’re looking for a wired controller with RGB lighting.

The product details list Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11, as well as customisable RGB lighting and Hall Effect sticks.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Smoke Transparent RGB Wired

GameSir Kaleid Smoke Transparent RGB Wired

For gamepad games on the listed Xbox and Windows platforms, if visible lighting on your controller is important to you.

The product details list Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11, as well as illuminated front buttons and analogue sticks.

The controller is listed as wired.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do the buttons themselves need to light up when playing in the dark?

Not necessarily. But if you want to find specific buttons in low light, check that they’re illuminated: the RGB gamepads reviewed by PowerA and Turtle Beach are described as having lighting zones or an illuminated, translucent casing, but not explicitly backlit action buttons.

What can I do if the inputs don’t match the music?

First, check the calibration settings in the game you’re playing. According to Epic Games, Fortnite Festival offers settings to calibrate audio, visuals and input; this doesn’t mean the feature is available in every rhythm game.

What should I do if a Taiko drum stops registering hits correctly?

For the drum models listed, HORI recommends following the care instructions and tapping gently with the supplied drumsticks, as excessive force can cause damage. If the problem persists, HORI recommends contacting its support team.

What extra costs and rights should I be aware of when shopping online in Germany?

The HORI drum doesn’t include the game software. The Verbraucherzentrale (German Consumer Advice Centre) distinguishes between your statutory rights against the seller and a voluntary guarantee. Online purchases generally come with a right to cancel, usually within 14 days of receiving the goods; the terms of your specific purchase apply.

What safety and disposal rules apply in Germany?

According to the European Union, CE marking is required only for products covered by relevant harmonised EU legislation; it isn’t a quality mark for gaming performance. The German Environment Agency advises that waste electrical and electronic equipment should be collected separately.