If you regularly distribute lots of updated rota plans, compare ink tank and cartridge printers based on the purchase price, consumables and paper handling. For the occasional print job, a cartridge printer could be a good fit too. Check the specific model for automatic double-sided printing, connections that suit your shared printer area and, if needed, scanning. Manufacturers’ stated ink yields won’t tell you how much ink your plans will actually use.
Which printer suits whom
Coordinators printing lots of copies
If you regularly distribute updated plans, it’s worth weighing up refill costs, paper capacity and double-sided printing together. c’t explains how cartridge and tank printers differ in purchase price and ink costs; Brother lists differences between ink cartridges and ink bottles for specific models.
Coordinators printing only a few copies
For occasional print jobs, potential savings on ink don’t necessarily outweigh the purchase price. c’t compares cheaper cartridge printers with refillable tank models that have lower ink costs, without recommending one as the right choice for everyone.
Groups with a shared printer area
If several people in charge print plans from different devices, check that the connections are suitable for the intended location and your devices. If plans include personal information, it’s also important to consider who receives or can see them. The Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority points out that data protection obligations also apply to clubs and associations.
What to consider when buying
Cartridge inkjet printer
A good fit if: You print only a few plans and the purchase price matters more than frequent refills.
Trade-off: If you print lots of copies, replacement cartridges can add up. Consumables and ink yields vary by model.
Ink tank inkjet printer
A good fit if: You regularly update several copies and want to compare ink costs over time with the price of the printer.
Trade-off: Tank printers vary in their paper handling and double-sided printing features; the tank design alone doesn’t tell you what features are included.
| Priority |
What to check when buying |
Who it matters most to |
| Cost of printing lots of updated copies |
Compare the number of pages, colours required and suitable consumables on the same basis of use. |
If you regularly print lots of plans, you’ll want to weigh up ink and paper costs against the price of the printer. Around 36 % of consumers are likely to have this as their main priority. |
| Easy-to-read plans and changes |
Test your own template at its final font size, and check whether double-sided printing is automatic or manual. |
If names, times and changes need to be clear on the printout, it also matters how easy it is to print an updated plan. Around 29 % of consumers are likely to prioritise this. |
| Printing in a shared space |
Check that Wi-Fi, USB or LAN suits the intended devices and network. Only factor in scanning and document feeding if you’ll use them. |
If several people share the printer, it needs to work with the devices you use in its actual location. Around 21 % of consumers are likely to have this as their main priority. |
| Infrequent use and maintenance |
Consider how often you’ll use it and check the maintenance instructions for the specific model. If print quality is poor, start with the recommended nozzle check. |
If you print only occasionally, the purchase price and maintenance may matter more than having a large supply of ink. Around 14 % of consumers are likely to put this first. |
Common misconceptions
-
Comparing only the price of the printer
A cheaper cartridge printer and a more expensive tank printer also differ in their ink costs. The right option for your group depends on how many plans you print and which consumables the specific model needs.
Estimate how much you print and compare the purchase price and consumables for the same level of use, rather than assuming manufacturers’ stated yields reflect your actual usage.
-
Assuming every tank printer has automatic double-sided printing
Tank printers don’t all handle paper in the same way. Canon says the PIXMA G3570 offers manually selectable double-sided printing, while the MAXIFY GX4050 has automatic double-sided printing under certain paper conditions.
If you want to print multi-page plans without turning the paper by hand, check the double-sided printing specifications for the exact model, including the paper size and type.
With manual double-sided printing, you’ll need to turn multi-page plans over yourself.
-
Running print head cleaning repeatedly when prints look faint
Cleaning can use ink on Epson printers. If print quality is poor, Epson recommends running a nozzle check first and cleaning only if needed.
Follow the maintenance instructions for your specific printer, and don’t keep running cleaning cycles just in case.
Key brands at a glance
Brother
The cartridge-based DCP-J1460DW and refillable-tank DCP-T780DW offer different ink systems in A4 all-in-one printers.
- Brother lists automatic double-sided printing and a 150-sheet cassette for both models.
- The DCP-J1460DW uses LC521 cartridges, while the DCP-T780DW uses ink bottles. This doesn’t mean the overall costs will be the same or different for every group.
Epson
According to Epson Deutschland, the EcoTank ET-2950 is a refillable A4 all-in-one printer with double-sided printing, copying, scanning and Wi-Fi.
- This model combines printing and scanning with a refillable ink system.
- Epson Deutschland currently lists the ET-2950 as unavailable. Advertised yields and savings apply under the conditions stated by the manufacturer.
Canon
The PIXMA G3570 and MAXIFY GX4050 differ in paper handling and double-sided printing.
- Canon says the G3570 offers manually selectable double-sided printing and a rear feed of up to 100 sheets. For the GX4050, Canon lists automatic double-sided printing under certain paper conditions.
- According to Canon, the GX4050’s automatic double-sided printing is available with specified paper conditions. These differences apply to these models, not the entire range.
HP
The Smart Tank 7005 is a refillable all-in-one printer with Wi-Fi for groups that need to print, scan and copy.
- HP lists these features for the German model 28B54A#BHC.
- Check that the connections and features of the specific model suit your shared printer area.
Matching products at Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does a rota plan need automatic double-sided printing?
Only if you want to print multi-page plans on both sides without turning the paper by hand. Check the exact model: Canon says the PIXMA G3570 offers manually selectable double-sided printing, while the MAXIFY GX4050 has automatic double-sided printing under the stated paper conditions.
What should I do if prints have streaks or faded patches after a break from printing?
Follow the instructions for your specific printer. For the relevant devices, Epson recommends running a nozzle check first if print quality is poor and cleaning only if needed; cleaning uses ink. This is manufacturer guidance for the relevant Epson devices, not general maintenance advice for all models.
What should I look out for with ink, repairs and the warranty?
Compare the consumables that are compatible with the exact model, and consider the warranty terms separately. If you’re buying as a consumer, your statutory rights against the seller are separate from any voluntary guarantee. Whether a purchase by a community group counts as a consumer or business purchase can’t be determined without details about the buyer.
Can names and times on printed rota plans be displayed wherever we like?
No. Printing personal information doesn’t mean it can be made public without restriction. If a plan identifies individuals, the group responsible should check which legal basis applies to its specific purpose and audience. The Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority points out that the GDPR also applies to charitable and unregistered clubs and associations. Whether a particular noticeboard display is permitted depends on how it is presented and who can access it.