Joybuy Insights

Buying running shoes: how to choose for roads, trails and long distances

Running shoes should suit the surface you run on, how often you run and the shape of your feet. But product names such as ‘Cushioning’, ‘Performance’ or ‘Stability’ don’t automatically point you towards the right choice. What matters is having clear information about fit, midsole, outsole, upper and available sizes.

Common pitfalls when buying running shoes

1. Assuming more cushioning means more comfort

Cushioned running shoes can feel pleasantly soft when you try them on. But how suitable they are in practice depends on how the midsole, heel support, flexibility and running surface work together. A very soft shoe may feel less controlled on uneven ground, while a firmer shoe can offer a more direct feel underfoot on long road runs.

So don’t focus only on terms such as ‘maximum cushioning’. Check what the shoe is designed for and whether its construction suits your pace and the surfaces you run on.

2. Focusing on grip claims without checking the tread

An anti-slip outsole won’t perform equally well on every surface. Shallow rubber tread often works better on tarmac and paved paths. Trail running shoes, on the other hand, need a much more pronounced tread to grip loose ground, mud or gravel.

Terms such as ‘All-Terrain’ or ‘Anti-Slip’ should therefore be backed up with specific details about the tread, rubber compound and intended use. On wet rocks or muddy woodland paths, you’ll also need to adapt your running technique.

3. Choosing your running shoe size based only on your usual everyday size

Sizing varies between brands, lasts and models. Your feet may also swell slightly while you run. There should be a little room between your toes and the front of the shoe, without your heel slipping out when you walk.

Width across the forefoot is particularly important. If you need a roomier fit, look for running shoes with a wide toe box or a wider last. Simply going up a size won’t necessarily make a shoe wider.

The key things to consider when buying

Surface: road running shoes or trail running shoes?

For tarmac, park paths and paved routes, road running shoes with a relatively even tread are usually a good choice. They can be lightweight and help you roll through your stride smoothly. If you often run on woodland paths, gravel, roots or wet trails, consider trail running shoes with a grippy outsole and abrasion-resistant upper instead.

A road-to-trail model can be a good option for mixed routes. However, it shouldn’t be confused with a specialist mountain or mud shoe.

Midsole: cushioning, responsiveness and stability

Midsoles are often made from EVA foam or a brand-specific foam. Key things to consider include:

  • Cushioning: How soft or firm does the landing feel?
  • Responsiveness: How quickly does the foam return to its shape after being compressed?
  • Stability: Does the platform prevent excessive sideways rolling?
  • Weight: Lightweight running shoes can feel more direct during faster sessions, but they don’t automatically offer more support.

Stability running shoes often have a wider base, reinforced elements or a more secure heel area. This is a feature of the shoe’s construction, not a claim about medical benefits.

Upper and fit

Breathable running shoes are often made from mesh or woven textiles. These materials can promote airflow, but they don’t automatically protect you from rain. For longer runs, the tongue should be adequately padded and the heel should feel secure.

Check for:

  1. Toe room: Your toes shouldn’t touch the front or feel squeezed from the sides.
  2. Midfoot support: The shoe should feel secure without creating pressure points.
  3. Heel hold: Your heel shouldn’t lift noticeably as you roll through your stride.
  4. Sock thickness: Try the shoes on with the socks you plan to wear when running.

Our picks for different runners

Best for: budget-conscious beginners
PELLIOT Running Shoes Unisex Lightweight Cushioning – Clean & Breathable, White (EU 39)

PELLIOT Running Shoes Unisex Lightweight Cushioning – Clean & Breathable, White (EU 39)

Why this product suits this type of runner: This unisex model may appeal to anyone looking for a lightweight shoe for paved paths and the occasional off-road section. According to the product details, the upper is made from sandwich mesh and woven fabric.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product description specifies the materials, EVA midsole and shoe care advice. This makes it easier to assess breathability and care requirements than relying on a marketing term alone.

Key benefits & features

Lightweight mesh upper, EVA foam midsole and sizes from EU 35 to 39 listed for this version.

Best for: quality-conscious buyers
EU45 LI-NING RED HARE 9 PRO Men's Running Shoes

EU45 LI-NING RED HARE 9 PRO Men's Running Shoes BOOM FIBER

Why this product suits this type of runner: This model is aimed at runners looking for men’s running shoes with a wider platform, a woven upper and a construction designed for both training and faster sessions.

How this product avoids the pitfall

Rather than focusing on low weight alone, the product description specifies the platform width, TPU element, BOOM midsole and GCR rubber outsole.

Key benefits & features

Wider fit, reflective elements according to the product name, woven BOOM FIBER upper and GCR rubber tread.

Best for: specialist uses & frequent runners
PELLIOT Running Shoes Unisex Lightweight Cushioning – Stable & Durable, Obsidian Black (EU 43)

PELLIOT Running Shoes Unisex Lightweight Cushioning – Stable & Durable, Obsidian Black (EU 43)

Why this product suits this type of runner: For regular runs on mixed surfaces, the combination of a mesh upper, EVA midsole and ROCKYTEC rubber outsole is worth considering.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The description sets out the intended road-to-trail use, as well as the materials and sole construction. This makes it easier to check whether the shoe suits tarmac, woodland paths and gravel.

Key benefits & features

Abrasion-resistant upper, highly elastic EVA foam and ROCKYTEC rubber; standard and slim versions are listed as available.

Best for: trail running enthusiasts
PELLIOT Trail running shoes Men Black 43

PELLIOT Trail running shoes Men Black 43

Why this product suits this type of runner: This model is designed for runners looking for a dedicated trail running shoe for routes with mixed surfaces. Check the available sizes and product page before buying.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The choice is based on the shoe’s intended use on trails, not just its colour or weight. Before buying, check the tread, size details and returns policy.

Key benefits & features

Trail running design, men’s model in EU 43 and an upper that, according to the product details, is designed for its intended use on off-road terrain.

Looking for more options?

We’ve put together a complete, regularly updated list of products that meet these strict selection criteria and fully comply with the safety regulations in force in the EU.

Choosing the right size and caring for your shoes

Try on running shoes in the late afternoon or after some light activity if possible. Your feet are often slightly larger then than they are in the morning. For long-distance shoes, leave roughly a thumb’s width of space in front of your toes. Your heel should still feel secure.

To care for your shoes:

  • Remove dirt with a soft brush or damp cloth.
  • Leave shoes to air-dry, rather than placing them on a radiator.
  • Follow the manufacturer’s washing instructions.
  • If you alternate between two pairs, the materials can dry fully between runs.
  • Regularly check the tread, heel area and midsole for signs of significant wear.

There’s no set mileage at which you need to replace your shoes. Body weight, running surface, training volume and materials all vary. It’s worth replacing them when the tread is badly worn, the cushioning feels permanently changed or the upper no longer provides secure support.

Running shoe FAQs

How should running shoes fit?

Your toes should be able to move without hitting the front of the shoe. The midfoot should feel secure, while the heel shouldn’t slip noticeably when you walk or run. If you have wider feet, finding a suitable toe box is more important than simply choosing a longer shoe.

How long do running shoes last?

It depends on how often you use them and the surfaces you run on. Check the tread, sole, seams and heel support regularly. Visible signs of material fatigue or a noticeably different feel when running are more useful indicators than a general mileage figure.

Are lightweight running shoes suitable for long distances?

It depends on the fit, cushioning and what you’re used to. Lightweight running shoes can feel more direct at higher speeds. For long distances, they should also offer enough support, fit comfortably and suit the surfaces you run on most often.