Groups with bound diaries
If the writing runs close to the binding, your group will need to work out how to capture each page without forcing the book flat. The US National Archives recommends supported overhead scanning for books.
An A4 flatbed scanner could be suitable if the diary can be opened to the right position without forcing it and its pages fit on the scanning area. If writing often runs close to the binding, a book-edge model may be an option. For fragile volumes or those that cannot be opened very far, the US National Archives recommends overhead scanning with a book support. For larger pages that can safely lie flat, a larger scanning area makes sense.
If the writing runs close to the binding, your group will need to work out how to capture each page without forcing the book flat. The US National Archives recommends supported overhead scanning for books.
When dealing with fragile diaries, the condition of the paper and binding should help determine the scanning method. The German Federal Archives recommends handling written records carefully and appropriately.
If you want to capture larger inserts as well as standard diary pages, compare their dimensions with the usable scanning area of each device.
For a community group, it’s worth first assessing the diaries’ bindings and condition, then measuring the largest pages and planning how everyone will scan them.
| Buying consideration | What to look for | Who is it most relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Writing near the binding | Try the intended method with a typical diary; don’t force the binding flat to scan it. | If I need to capture writing close to the inner edge, I check whether the book can be positioned without pressure. This applies to around 33% of consumers whose main concern is readability near the binding. |
| Protecting the original and its binding | Check the condition and safe opening angle; with fragile books, compare supported overhead scanning with a flatbed. | If a diary is fragile or can only be opened a little, preserving the original matters more to me than scanning quickly. Around 27% of consumers put protecting the paper and binding first. |
| Capturing full pages and inserts | Measure the largest originals, including any margins you need to keep, and compare them with the maximum scanning area of the specific model. | If I want to capture larger inserts or marginal notes in full, I check the scanning area before considering other device features. Around 20% of consumers say accommodating different formats is their top priority. |
| A shared scanning workflow | Check compatibility with the computer being used, including connections and drivers, as well as the required file formats and how files will be named and backed up. | When several people are scanning repeatedly, I need a clear process so that files can be matched to the originals and backed up. Around 20% of consumers prioritise this group workflow. |
A hinge or raised lid doesn’t prove that a particular diary will sit correctly or that writing near its binding will be captured legibly.
Check the opening angle and the position of the writing in a comparable volume. For fragile originals, consider supported overhead scanning.
A high dpi figure doesn’t make the scanning area any larger. Canon Germany gives the Canon CanoScan LiDE 400 a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm; Plustek lists a maximum of 297 × 431,8 mm for the OpticSlim 1180.
First measure the entire original, including any margins you need to keep, then compare the dimensions with the scanning area of the specific model.
An automatic document feeder won’t capture pages from a bound diary in the same way as a flatbed. The US National Archives advises against using automatic feeders for fragile loose papers.
Consider a feeder only for additional loose documents that are suitable for it, and plan to use a different method for fragile pages.
German copyright law distinguishes between the right to reproduce a work and the right to publish it. If personal data is involved, you must also consider whether you have a suitable legal basis for processing it.
Before sharing, check who owns the rights to the text, who should receive the files and whether they contain personal information.
The CanoScan LiDE 400 is an A4 flatbed scanner for originals that fit on its scanning area.
The Perfection V39II is an A4 photo and document flatbed scanner for a space-conscious scanning setup.
Plustek describes different models for bound originals and larger items that can lie flat.
According to VIISAN, the VF3240 is an A3 flatbed scanner for larger originals.
According to HP, the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with an automatic document feeder for suitable loose documents.
No. If it can’t be opened to the right position without force, your group should consider supported overhead scanning instead of pressing down on the binding. The US National Archives recommends using a copy stand and book supports for books.
Give the pages clear file names, record basic details about the original and make backup copies. The US National Archives recommends file naming, metadata and backups as good practice, not as a legal requirement in Germany.
No. You don’t need OCR to capture a page as an image. If your group needs searchable text, test text recognition on representative handwritten pages and check the results. An advertised OCR feature alone doesn’t guarantee reliable recognition of this handwriting.
Check that the drivers support your existing computer and that you have space for the device, the original and, if needed, a gentle scanning support. Also plan how the group will name and back up files, and whether you’ll need extra storage.
There’s no straightforward yes-or-no answer without knowing who created the work, who owns the rights, what it contains and how you plan to use it. German copyright law distinguishes, among other things, between reproduction and publication. If the files contain personal data about living people, processing it requires an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR. You should assess access within the group separately from making the files publicly available.