What should you consider when choosing?
When scanning bound lecture notes at a shared desk, your choice will mainly depend on whether you prioritise legibility at the spine, clear desk space, searchable text, large volumes of pages or avoiding the purchase of a scanner.
Overhead scanner with book mode
Suitable if: you regularly scan bound pages without placing them on a glass surface.
Consider: the scanner and open book will both take up desk space while you scan, and you’ll need to check how well it corrects the curve at the spine.
A4 flatbed scanner
Suitable if: you mainly scan loose pages or pages that can be opened out sufficiently.
Consider: the bound booklet needs to be opened and placed on the glass surface, so a flatbed isn’t automatically the right type of scanner for bound materials.
A smartphone or library scanner you already have access to
Suitable if: you only need occasional extracts and would rather not buy your own scanner just yet.
Consider: with smartphone scans, you’ll need to judge the image quality and legibility yourself; access to library scanners varies by location.
| What matters to you |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Binding and spine |
Check that the specific model has a book mode and can correct curved pages; assess a typical double-page spread, including the spine. CZUR, Ricoh and VIISAN list these features for certain models. |
When I scan bound notes, I don’t want to press the binding against a glass surface, and I need the text around the spine to be legible. Around 29% of consumers put protecting the binding and legibility at the spine first. |
| Clear desk space |
Allow for the scanner’s footprint as well as the space needed for the open booklet and turning pages. IRIS describes the Desk 7 Pro as a short-arm device; you’ll still need to check how it fits on your own desk. |
When I share a desk, I want there to be enough room for the next person to use it once I’ve finished scanning. Around 24% of consumers prioritise clear workspace. |
| Searchable files |
Check that it can export searchable PDFs, and test text recognition with your own materials. The IRIS manual describes this type of PDF export; VIISAN lists OCR for the S21. |
When I want to find passages in my study materials later, a searchable PDF matters more than just having an image of the page. Around 18% of consumers prioritise text search. |
| Large numbers of pages |
Check the page-detection or timed mode and try it with your own booklet. Ricoh describes page detection for the ScanSnap SV600; the IRIS manual explains how scanning can start automatically after you turn a page. |
When I scan lots of pages in a row, I don’t want to have to manually start a new scan every time. Around 12% of consumers prioritise the workflow when scanning large volumes of pages. |
| Avoiding an unnecessary purchase |
Consider how often you scan and whether you can access a scanner that’s already available. The University Library of Regensburg is a local example, not a guarantee that a library scanner will be available to you. |
When I only need occasional extracts, I want to check first whether a scanning option I already have access to will do the job. Around 17% of consumers prioritise avoiding an unnecessary purchase of their own scanner. |
Suitable products
Suitable products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
What’s the best way to scan bound pages with an overhead scanner?
Place the open book fully within the capture area, use book mode and check the preview carefully, especially at the spine. For the Desk workflow, the IRIS manual describes automatic capture after turning a page, export as a searchable PDF, and then rotating, sorting and cropping the pages.
Does a higher dpi value automatically mean better quality?
No. Compare optical capture and software-interpolated output separately. The VIISAN brochure lists an optical 20.1 MP sensor for the S21 and software-interpolated output of up to 600 dpi. You’ll also want to check whether the text and spine are legible in scans of your own materials.
What should a group check before installing the scanning software?
Check the software version for every operating system you’ll actually use. CZUR lists downloads for Windows, Mac and Ubuntu for the ET24 Pro; this doesn’t automatically mean that every CZUR model is compatible with every computer you already have.
What rights do you have if a new scanner is faulty?
According to the Verbraucherzentrale, consumers in Germany can generally assert their statutory warranty rights against the seller for new faulty goods within two years of delivery or receipt. The statutory warranty is separate from a voluntary guarantee.
Can I scan an entire bound set of notes or share the file with a study group?
This depends, among other things, on who owns the copyright, whether permission has been given, the licence and how the material will be used. Under Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), private copies are subject to certain conditions; making a substantially complete copy of a book or journal is restricted, and copies made under this provision generally must not be distributed. Section 60a of the UrhG sets out separate rules for non-commercial teaching at educational institutions. These generally cover up to 15% of a published work and apply to specific purposes and recipients. Sections 53 and 60a of the UrhG, published on Gesetze im Internet, do not give blanket permission to scan or share all lecture notes.