Which scanning option is right for you?

Societies with loose maps up to A3

If you want to digitise robust originals and print your society’s documents at the same workstation, the actual scanning area of the specific model is what matters. The German Federal Archives notes that the required resolution depends on how the image will be used later.

People responsible for fragile maps

For fragile or bound originals, consider what kind of handling is appropriate before choosing a device. The German Federal Archives recommends handling archival material appropriately and with care.

Societies with larger maps

If a map is larger than the scanning area of an A3 all-in-one printer, you’ll need a separate scanning option that can accommodate it. Plustek lists a maximum document size of 29,7 × 43,1 cm for the OpticSlim 1180.

What should you look for when buying?

A3 all-in-one printer

Suitable if: Loose, sufficiently robust maps fit on the specified scanning area and your society also wants to print or copy.

Things to consider: Check the print, copy and scan formats separately. An automatic document feeder designed for office documents isn’t automatically suitable for historical maps.

All-in-one printer plus A3 flatbed scanner

Suitable if: The all-in-one printer scans smaller documents, but your maps fit on the scanning area of a separate A3 flatbed scanner. Plustek lists a maximum size of 29,7 × 43,1 cm for the OpticSlim 1180.

Things to consider: A second device needs space and a separate workflow. Maps larger than its scanning area still won’t fit on the scanner bed in one go.

Overhead scanner or specialist scanning service

Suitable if: Maps are larger than the available scanning area, or bound or fragile originals need to be handled differently. VIISAN describes the S21 as an A2 overhead scanner.

Things to consider: An overhead scanner doesn’t replace a printer. The S21’s output of up to 600 dpi, as specified by the manufacturer, is software-interpolated and doesn’t demonstrate an equally high optical capture resolution.

What you need What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Original size and scanning area Measure your largest map; compare the flatbed and document feeder’s scan formats separately from the print format. If I want to scan the largest map in one go, the usable scanning area is what counts; around 36 % of consumers put the right format first.
Careful handling Assess the condition, binding and permitted degree of laying flat or opening before choosing a flatbed, overhead scanner or scanning service. If maps are fragile or bound, I want to find an appropriate way to capture them; around 29 % of consumers prioritise protecting the originals.
Printing needs and ongoing costs Estimate your planned print volume and coverage; compare consumables over the same period of use. If the device will also be used regularly to print society documents, I’ll consider the ongoing cost of ink and paper; around 21 % of consumers put this first.
Shared scanning and file workflow Check the specific model’s connections, scan destinations and software, as well as the resolution needed for viewing or printing. If several people will be involved, I want us to be able to scan and save files together; around 14 % of consumers prioritise the team workflow.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Confusing A3 printing with A3 scanning

    A device may print up to A3 but scan only smaller documents. Brother lists the MFC-J5340DW as printing up to A3, but scanning and copying only up to A4.

    Before buying, check the scan format for the exact model and compare it with your largest map.

    If the maps don’t fit on the scanning area, you may also need a suitable scanner or a scanning service.

  • Assuming the document feeder is the standard option for old maps

    An automatic feeder isn’t suitable for historical maps simply because it can handle office documents. The condition and type of original determine how it can be handled appropriately.

    Assess the original in advance and choose a method that’s suitable for it. The German Federal Archives highlights the importance of handling archival material with care.

    A conservation assessment or a different scanning method may involve extra organisation.

  • Mistaking interpolated scanner dpi or print dpi for captured detail

    The German Federal Archives distinguishes between the resolution of a digital image in ppi and print resolution in dpi. VIISAN describes the S21’s output of up to 600 dpi as software-interpolated.

    Check whether the figure refers to optical capture, interpolation or printing, and choose the required image size according to how you plan to use it.

  • Using ink yield figures to calculate the cost of large map prints directly

    Manufacturer estimates of ink yield don’t replace working out your own print volume and coverage. These factors affect how much ink and paper your society’s prints will use.

    Compare cartridge and tank systems based on your own print jobs and the same planned period of use.

Key brands at a glance

Brother

MFC all-in-one printers where the specific scan format is key when scanning maps.

  • Brother lists scanning up to A3 for the MFC-J6940DW.
  • The MFC-J5340DW prints up to A3, but Brother lists scanning only up to A4. This doesn’t tell you whether it will handle historical originals carefully.

Epson

WorkForce all-in-one printers with cartridges and EcoTank models with refillable tanks. For A3 maps, check the scan specifications for the specific model.

  • Epson lists A3 scanning and A3+ printing for the ET-16605. The WF-7840DTWF is listed with A3+ printing and an automatic A3 document feeder.
  • Manufacturer format specifications aren’t independent quality or cost tests.

HP

Large-format OfficeJet Pro all-in-one printers combine scanning and printing.

  • HP describes the OfficeJet Pro 9730e as a device for printing and scanning up to A3.
  • HP notes that the model’s dynamic security feature may block cartridges with non-supported chips. Check which consumables are supported before buying.

Canon

MAXIFY GX all-in-one printers with refillable ink tanks, including models for regular document printing.

  • Canon lists a flatbed scanner for the GX7050.
  • For the document feeder, Canon lists A4, A5, Letter and Legal, but not A3. So don’t choose a model solely for its tank system if you need to scan large maps.

Plustek

Separate flatbed scanners for scanning jobs that an all-in-one printer can’t handle.

  • Plustek lists a maximum document size of 29,7 × 43,1 cm for the OpticSlim 1180.
  • The scanner doesn’t provide a printing function. You’ll need to assess separately whether fragile originals should be scanned on it.

Matching products on Joybuy

Matching products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does 600 dpi on a spec sheet mean map details will be easy to read?

Not necessarily. Check whether the figure refers to optical capture, software-interpolated output or printing, and consider the level of detail you need for your intended use. The German Federal Archives distinguishes between the ppi of a digital image and the dpi of a print. For its own digitisation, it generally specifies 400 ppi based on the original size; this isn’t a general minimum requirement for societies.

Can our society feed a historical map through the automatic document feeder?

Not simply because the device has an A3 feeder. Assess the condition and type of original first. Fragile items may need to be scanned using a different, gentler method.

What should our society set up for sharing after scanning?

Agree on file names, a storage location and access permissions, and check the scan destinations available on the specific device. If files contain personal data, you’ll need to check the data protection requirements for the specific processing involved.

What are our rights if the device we buy is faulty?

Statutory rights are separate from a voluntary guarantee, as the German consumer advice centre explains. The rights that apply in a particular case also depend on who entered into the contract with the seller as the buyer.

Can our society publish scans of historical maps online in Germany?

Not simply because the maps are old. Maps may be protected as representations of a scientific or technical nature under § 2 UrhG. Under § 64 UrhG, copyright generally expires 70 years after the author’s death. Whether a particular map can be published depends on who created it, the rights involved and, where applicable, the terms of use set by the institution that holds it. The relevant legislation is the Copyright Act of the German Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice.