Who are the different scanning options suitable for?

Groups with a mix of film formats

If you’re looking through 35mm negatives, 120 roll film or other formats together, first check the image windows and compatible holders. The specifications published by reflecta, Plustek, Epson and KODAK Photo Plus list different formats and device limitations.

Teams with lots of 35mm strips

When you have many compatible 35mm strips, the film transport can affect your workflow. reflecta states that the RPS 10S automatically transports strips with 3 to 40 frames.

Groups working with historical portraits

If you want to check for dust, scratches or tonal values, factor in the file output, software and film type. LaserSoft Imaging notes that infrared-based tools cannot be used with traditional black-and-white film in the same way as they can with compatible film.

What should you consider when choosing?

What you need What to check before buying Who this matters most to
Film format and holder Film type and actual image window; inserts and scan area for the specific model. If my collection hasn’t been sorted yet, I want to be sure the negatives I have will fit the holders provided. Around 31% of consumers put format compatibility first.
Large numbers of negative strips Number and condition of the strips; stated transport range and its requirements. With a large collection of 35mm strips, I want a workflow that doesn’t depend on manually advancing every single one. Around 25% of consumers prioritise throughput for compatible strips.
Editing scans Output format, software and computer compatibility; whether the correction features are suitable for the film type. If I want to adjust individual portraits later, I want to plan the file output and retouching in advance. Around 25% of consumers prioritise the flexibility to edit.
Viewing without a PC Storage and memory card requirements; who will transfer and back up the files afterwards. If several volunteers need to select images directly on the device, I want a simple way for everyone to review them together. Around 19% of consumers prefer viewing images without a dedicated computer setup.

Common buying mistakes

  • Focusing only on the highest megapixel count

    For the x66-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated output of 22 MP. The higher output figure alone doesn’t prove that more detail has actually been captured.

    Compare the sensor and output figures separately, then assess a test scan against your intended use.

    If the files aren’t good enough for the editing you have in mind, you may need to scan them again.

  • Confusing automatic 35mm transport with format variety

    reflecta gives the RPS 10S a maximum scan area of 24,3 × 36,5 mm, so it isn’t a medium-format solution. The x66-Scan, by contrast, lists other specific formats.

    Before buying, sort your collection by film type and image size, then check these against the holders supplied with the specific model.

  • Assuming infrared correction works on every old negative

    LaserSoft Imaging explains that infrared-based tools cannot be used with traditional black-and-white film in the same way as they can with compatible film.

    Check the film type and test damaged portraits with suitable scans. If necessary, plan to use a different retouching method.

    Additional visual checks and manual or software-based retouching may be part of the process.

  • Assuming an older model description applies to a current listing

    Epson Deutschland describes the Perfection V850 Pro as no longer available, while KODAK Photo Plus’s EU manufacturer website lists the SCANZA as currently unavailable. These statements refer to the specific models mentioned.

    Use their documented features as a guide only, and check the model version and availability again before making a specific purchase.

Brands and product ranges to consider

reflecta

The documented models suit different workflows: viewing without a PC across several specified formats, or automatically transporting compatible 35mm strips while connected to a computer.

  • reflecta lists 135, 127 and 120 formats for the x66-Scan; JPEG files are saved to an SD card.
  • The x66-Scan’s 22 MP output is interpolated; reflecta specifies a 14 MP sensor. The RPS 10S is limited to 35mm film.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE is a PC-based option for carefully editing 35mm negatives.

  • Plustek specifies a 35mm scan area, 8-/16-bit greyscale output and SilverFast SE Plus 9.
  • Your computer, operating system and software must suit your workflow; medium-format support isn’t specified for this model.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro specifications describe a transparency flatbed scanner workflow for several film formats, with TIFF output.

  • Epson lists film holders for several formats, including 120/220, as well as TIFF output.
  • Epson Deutschland marks this specific model as no longer available. Its specifications don’t apply to other Epson models.

KODAK Photo Plus

According to the EU manufacturer website, the SCANZA offers a standalone option for specified 110, 126 and 135 negatives.

  • The EU manufacturer website lists JPEG files and inserts for the film formats specified.
  • The format list doesn’t include 120 film; the EU manufacturer website lists the model as currently unavailable.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Relevant products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to know whether the portraits are on 35mm film or roll film before choosing a scanner?

Yes, the film format is crucial when choosing a device. The Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is specified for 35mm film, while reflecta lists certain 127 and 120 formats and holders for the x66-Scan. Check the actual image window on your originals.

Will a scanner with infrared functionality automatically remove scratches from old black-and-white portraits?

You shouldn’t rely on this with traditional black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that infrared-based tools aren’t suitable for certain film types. Test the correction on the film you have, and keep an unaltered copy of the scan.

How should a group organise scans and originals?

Agree on a clear system for matching files to originals, naming files and backing them up, and keep the negatives. The German Federal Archives documents details such as the condition and size of originals during restoration work. This archival practice can be a useful guide, but it isn’t a general technical requirement for clubs.

What rights do I have if a scanner I’ve bought is faulty?

According to information from Your Europe, consumers buying from a professional seller are generally entitled to a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the seller. An additional manufacturer’s guarantee doesn’t replace this. Whether your group’s specific purchase counts as a consumer purchase depends on who the contract is with and the circumstances of the purchase.

Can a group simply publish identifiable scanned portraits online?

No. The age of a negative or owning it doesn’t settle the rights to publish the image. Under § 22 KunstUrhG, consent is generally required to distribute or publicly display portraits; the exceptions under § 23 must be considered on a case-by-case basis and take legitimate interests into account. For identifiable living people, you must also check that there is an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR. Rights in the photograph may also apply, so it isn’t possible to say in general whether a particular image can be published without further permission.