Which printer is right for you?

Collectors of bound recipe books

If you want to preserve pages from bound books without removing them, look for a flatbed scanner with a suitably sized surface. Canon Germany recommends using the flatbed for thick or bound documents.

Anyone with loose recipe sheets

If you also scan stacks of loose sheets, an ADF can save you placing them one at a time. You’ll still need a suitable flatbed scanner for bound books.

Regular recipe printers

If you print recipes often, consider colour requirements, print technology and consumables as well as how you’ll scan them. The right option depends on what you print and how often.

What should you look for when buying?

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Placing bound books on the scanner Check the flatbed, supported paper sizes and whether there’s room for your largest book. Brother Germany states that the DCP-L2620DW has a flatbed scanner that supports up to DIN A4/LTR. When I scan a book, I want to place its pages on the scanner without taking it apart. Around 42% of consumers prioritise scanning bound originals.
Feeding loose sheets Check the ADF capacity and whether it scans one or both sides. Canon Germany states that the PIXMA TS7750i has a single-sided ADF that holds up to 35 sheets. When I have loose recipe sheets, I want to feed several pages through one after another. Around 25% of consumers prioritise this way of scanning.
Finding scans again later Check PDF output and the OCR software available, and test how well it recognises your own handwritten pages. Adobe explains that a scan may initially contain image data rather than searchable text. If I want to search for ingredients later, I need more than a PDF containing an image of the page. Around 17% of consumers prioritise being able to find things again later.
Printing costs and colour Estimate how much you print, then compare the printer price and the cost of suitable cartridges, ink or toner and drum over the same period. If I print recipes regularly, I want to budget for consumables that suit my colour and black-and-white printing needs. Around 16% of consumers prioritise ongoing printing costs.

Common misconceptions

  • An ADF is suitable for bound books too

    An ADF feeds suitable loose sheets; bound or thick originals should go on the flatbed. Check that the page of your book fits on the scanner glass of the specific model.

    For a book, start by checking the scanner glass and supported paper size. If you also have stacks of loose sheets, an ADF can be a useful extra.

  • Duplex printing means it can scan both sides

    These are different features. Canon Germany lists automatic duplex printing for the PIXMA TS7750i, but its ADF scans one side only.

    Check the specifications for duplex printing and duplex scanning separately for the exact model.

    With double-sided loose originals, you may need to turn and sort the pages manually.

  • A PDF scan is automatically searchable

    A PDF may initially contain only an image of the page. Text recognition is an additional step, and you should check any handwritten details afterwards.

    Test the whole process with your own pages and search for an ingredient before relying on text recognition.

    Text recognition may require extra checking and corrections.

  • Compare only the purchase price or advertised savings

    Cartridges, refill ink, toner and drums vary depending on the print technology. Manufacturers’ savings claims are based on specific comparison conditions, which may not reflect how much you print.

    Compare the printer and consumables costs for your estimated print volume over the same period of use.

Key brands at a glance

Canon

The PIXMA TS7750i and PIXMA TS7750i models are examples of colour inkjet multifunction printers with scanning and printing features.

  • Canon Germany states that the PIXMA TS7750i has a single-sided ADF for up to 35 sheets, automatic duplex printing and PG-585/CL-586 cartridges.
  • Duplex printing does not mean it can scan both sides. Also check that the flatbed is large enough for your book.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-2950 is an A4 colour multifunction printer with refillable ink tanks.

  • Epson Germany lists flatbed scanning and refillable tanks.
  • To decide whether a tank printer suits your print volume, weigh up the printer price against the cost of refill ink.

Brother

The DCP-L2620DW is a mono laser printer with a flatbed scanner; the DCP-J1360DW is a colour inkjet option with an ADF.

  • Brother Germany states that the DCP-L2620DW has a flatbed scanner supporting up to DIN A4/LTR, with separate toner and drum units. Brother lists a 20-sheet ADF for the DCP-J1360DW.
  • The DCP-L2620DW does not print in colour. The DCP-J1360DW’s ADF does not mean it can feed bound originals.

HP

The Smart Tank 5105 is a colour tank printer with printing, copying and scanning features.

  • HP lists scanning to PDF and a refillable ink tank for this model.
  • PDF scanning specifications do not confirm OCR for handwritten recipes or that the flatbed is large enough for your book. Check the scanning process for the exact model too.

Joybuy product selection

This selection features multifunction printers with flatbed scanners, so you can place the pages of a bound recipe book on the scanner one at a time.

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg colour laser printer

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

The flatbed scanner is useful for placing pages on the glass one at a time; check that its surface is large enough for your book.

Colour laser printing; automatic duplex printing.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

PANTUM BM2300NW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

The flatbed scanner is suitable for placing pages on the glass one at a time; check that its surface is large enough for your book before buying. The product description says it can scan in colour, but the title specifies monochrome printing.

A4 monochrome laser printing; 22 ppm; dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan a bound recipe book using the automatic document feeder?

Use the flatbed for bound or thick originals. An ADF is designed for suitable loose sheets; check that the page of your book fits on the scanner glass of the specific model.

Will a scan of my handwritten recipes be searchable automatically?

No, not simply because it’s saved as a PDF. Adobe distinguishes between image data in a scan and text recognised afterwards using OCR. Test text recognition on your own handwritten pages and check the results.

What ongoing costs should I budget for?

Compare cartridges or ink bottles suited to your print volume, or toner and drum if you have a mono laser printer. Compare the printer and consumables costs for the same print volume and period of use; manufacturers’ stated yields alone won’t tell you your individual cost per page.

Can I scan an entire recipe book in Germany and share the files?

There’s no blanket answer. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) permits private individual copies of protected material only under the conditions set out in the law; additional restrictions apply to making a substantially complete copy of a protected book. The provision does not generally allow copies to be distributed or made publicly available. Whether it applies to a particular book and intended use depends on the circumstances.

What should I do with an old printer I’m replacing?

Germany’s Federal Environment Agency states that electrical and electronic waste must not be put in household rubbish. Local collection points, such as recycling centres, are one way to return it; retailer take-back schemes are subject to their own conditions.