Which scanner is right for you?

Collectors of bound journals

If you want to capture entries right up to the spine, first check whether the book can be placed on the scanner without putting it under strain. The Library of Congress highlights bindings that do not open easily or are damaged as a particular challenge; Plustek describes the OpticBook 4800 as having a book edge.

Collectors of large travel inserts

If maps, envelopes or decorated pages are larger than an A4 scan area, compare the usable area of each scanner with the items you want to scan. Canon lists a scan area of 216 × 297 mm for both the LiDE 300 and LiDE 400; Plustek and VIISAN offer A3 flatbed scanners.

Anyone creating a digital travel archive

To create an archive of photos and handwritten notes that you can search later, you’ll need both good-quality scans and a suitable workflow for text recognition and file organisation. Plustek describes an OCR workflow for the OpticBook 4800; test the results with a typical handwritten page.

What should you look for when buying?

Compact A4 flatbed scanner

A good choice if: your pages fit on the scan bed and the journal sits securely on it.

Trade-off: You’ll need to position each page individually; a stand or hinge does not automatically make a stiff binding suitable for scanning.

Flatbed scanner with a book edge

A good choice if: you often scan close to the spine and the particular book sits safely against the edge.

Trade-off: A manufacturer’s mention of a book edge does not prove that the book can be placed on it without damage or that the scan area will suit every item.

Larger A3 flatbed scanner

A good choice if: large pages or inserts will not fit fully on an A4 scan bed.

Trade-off: Allow more room for the scanner and its operation; a larger format won’t solve a problem with a delicate book spine.

Flatbed scanner with document feeder

A good choice if: you regularly scan suitable loose documents as well as bound journals.

Trade-off: The feeder won’t position the bound pages of a journal on the flatbed for you.

Buying priority What to check Who is this particularly important to?
Binding and spine Check the condition and how far the book opens; position a typical page without putting it under strain and assess a test scan of the fold. The Library of Congress advises taking particular care with bindings that do not open easily or are damaged. If my journal only opens with care, I want to capture the area near the spine without putting pressure on it. Around 29% of consumers put protecting the binding first.
Scan area for pages and inserts Measure the largest item in both directions and compare it with the scan area of the specific model. Canon lists 216 × 297 mm for both the LiDE 300 and LiDE 400; Plustek and VIISAN offer A3 models. If I want large maps or inserts to fit entirely in one scan, I want to check the usable area against my items before buying. Around 23% of consumers prioritise capturing large items in full.
Handwriting, photos and colours Compare optical specifications rather than just selectable resolutions, and test a typical page with handwriting, a photo and a fold using your intended settings. If detail in photos and handwritten entries matters to me, I want to check what my pages will actually look like before scanning a large batch. Around 18% of consumers prioritise preserving this image detail.
Organisation and text search Test PDF creation, page order and OCR search with a typical page; the software must be compatible with your computer. Plustek describes an OCR and searchable PDF workflow for the OpticBook 4800. If I want to find my scans again later, I need a clear filing system and a search function that I can test with my own entries. Around 18% of consumers prioritise being able to find their scans later.
Space and connection Allow space for the scanner, its open lid and the book; check the USB connection, power supply and compatible drivers for your computer. Epson lists a built-in stand and USB power for the V39II. If my hobby room is short on space, I want to be able to fit the scanner and open journal comfortably. Around 12% of consumers prioritise space and connectivity in their work area.

Common misconceptions

  • Assuming A3 format means gentler scanning for books

    A larger scan area and a book edge solve different problems. A3 alone doesn’t tell you whether a journal can be placed on the scanner without putting strain on the binding.

    A larger scanner takes up more space without solving a problem with the book spine.

    Measure the item and assess the binding separately. Consider a book edge only if the particular journal rests on it without needing to be forced open.

  • Expecting feeder speed to apply to bound pages

    A document feeder handles suitable loose sheets; a bound journal still needs to be positioned on the flatbed one page at a time.

    You’ll still need to position each journal page manually as part of the scanning process.

    Only count on the feeder for loose documents, and plan to scan bound pages separately.

  • Assuming a high dpi figure or PDF button guarantees a good archive

    A resolution figure doesn’t prove how well a scan of your particular journal will turn out. A PDF isn’t automatically searchable either: text recognition and the scan image are two different things.

    Before scanning a large batch, you may need to spend extra time on test scans and checking the recognised text.

    Create a representative test scan with handwriting, a photo and a fold, then check the image quality, page order and OCR results.

  • Assuming the Epson Perfection V39 and V39II are the same

    Epson lists the V39II as a separate model. Don’t assume that information about the older V39 also applies to the V39II.

    Check the exact model name, and make sure the drivers and software are compatible with the device on offer and your computer.

Key brands and model ranges

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 are A4 flatbed scanners for individual pages that fit on the scan bed.

  • Canon lists a 216 × 297 mm scan area and a Z-hinge for both models; the LiDE 400 also has USB-C and a stand.
  • These features don’t prove that a delicate or stiff journal can be laid flat safely.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner for photos and documents in a compact workspace.

  • Epson describes the V39II as having a built-in stand and USB power.
  • Check the exact model name; don’t assume that details about the older V39 also apply to the V39II.

Plustek

The OpticBook 4800 is designed for positioning pages close to the spine; the OpticPro A320E is an A3 flatbed scanner for larger items.

  • Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge and an OCR workflow for the OpticBook 4800; for the OpticPro A320E, the manufacturer lists A3 format and a CCD sensor.
  • The manufacturer’s claim of reduced shadowing at the fold is not independent proof of how it will work with your journal. These models are designed for different needs.

VIISAN

The VF3240 is an A3 flatbed scanner for larger pages or inserts.

  • VIISAN lists an optical resolution of 2,400 × 2,400 dpi.
  • Check separately whether it’s suitable for your particular binding; the stated scan time is for A3 colour at 200 dpi, not every scan mode.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with a document feeder for suitable loose sheets.

  • HP lists a 60-sheet feeder.
  • The feeder doesn’t replace the need to position each page of a bound journal on the flatbed.

Recommended products at Joybuy

Recommended products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I press an old journal firmly against the glass to get a sharper scan?

No, don’t press an old journal against the glass as a matter of course. The Library of Congress recommends assessing its condition and any potential damage before digitising it; bindings that do not open easily or are damaged are a particular concern. Canon also advises against pressing hard on the lid or glass in the LiDE 400 care instructions. First, try setting it up in a way that won’t put it under strain.

How do I clean the scanner glass after scanning pages with glued-in receipts?

For the CanoScan LiDE 400, Canon recommends unplugging the USB cable before cleaning and wiping the glass with a soft, dry cloth. Don’t spray liquid directly onto the device; for other models, follow the relevant user manual.

Does a PDF button automatically make handwritten journals searchable?

No, PDF creation and text recognition need to be checked separately. Plustek describes an OCR workflow that creates searchable PDFs for the OpticBook 4800, but that doesn’t tell you how reliably your handwriting will be recognised. Test a typical page and check the image, page order and search results.

Can I publish scanned travel journals containing other people’s images or text online?

Owning a journal or a private scanned copy doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish content protected by someone else’s copyright. § 53 UrhG permits private copies only under the conditions set out there and generally prohibits distributing or publicly sharing such copies. Check the rights for each item of content before publishing.