Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Archive managers with irreplaceable recordings

If you need lectures to remain available even after accidental deletion or device failure, plan for a separate backup and a tested recovery process. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security also recommends making sure that you can restore your data.

Groups with a growing lecture collection

If you regularly add recordings, compare your existing collection and expected growth with the usable capacity of your planned drive configuration. Synology notes that usable capacity depends on the drives and storage method.

Groups with several people who need access

A shared storage location can support different roles and access permissions. If people can be recognised or heard in recordings, the group must also consider the specific purpose and legal basis for processing their data, as highlighted by the data protection authority for Rhineland-Palatinate.

What should you consider when choosing one?

First, assess your current collection and expected growth. Then plan your backup and access permissions, and finally check whether you really need extra bays or faster network ports for your day-to-day workflow.

When choosing a NAS for a shared lecture archive, it helps to start with your main priority.

Purchase priority What to check before buying Who is this most important to?
Restorable backup Plan and test a separate backup destination and a way to restore the files you need. If a recording can’t easily be replaced, I want to be able to restore an independent copy. Around 28% of consumers put restorable backups first.
Usable capacity and room to grow Compare file sizes and expected growth with the usable capacity of your specific drive and storage pool configuration. If we regularly add new lectures, I want to allow for future storage needs too. Around 22% of consumers say capacity and archive growth are their top priority.
Access permissions Check whether you can set up separate accounts and appropriate folder permissions for the tasks involved. If several people work with the archive, I want to grant access according to their roles. Around 22% of consumers put access control first.
Complete archive solution Plan for everything together: what’s included, the drives you need and a separate backup destination. I want to know which components I’ll need for storage and backup in addition to the NAS enclosure. Around 17% of consumers focus on getting a complete setup.
Transferring large files Compare the ports on the NAS, computers and other network components, and consider how often you’ll transfer large files. If we regularly transfer large recording files, the whole network path needs to support this. Around 11% of consumers prioritise transfer speeds.

Which assumptions should you avoid?

  • Assuming mirrored NAS drives count as a complete backup

    The shared hardware and its location are still potential points of failure. Mirroring alone can’t protect your archive against every kind of loss, such as accidental deletion or damage where the NAS is kept.

    Plan for an independent copy and test whether you can restore a file from it.

  • Assuming raw capacity is the same as usable archive space

    The capacity actually available depends on the drives and the storage layout you choose.

    Calculate it using your planned drive configuration and allow for expected growth.

  • Planning around an empty enclosure as if it were a complete storage solution

    According to the manufacturers, the QNAP TS-264-8G and UGREEN NASync DXP4800 Plus are supplied without hard drives.

    Check what’s included with the specific offer and allow for suitable drives and a separate backup destination.

  • Assuming a fast NAS port guarantees fast copy speeds

    The port specification alone doesn’t tell you what transfer speeds your group will achieve across its network.

    Check the ports available on the NAS, computers and network components in between, and consider how often you’ll transfer large files.

Key brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a useful comparison point for a two-bay NAS.

  • Synology lists a 2,5-GbE port and photo and video management features for the DS225+.
  • Usable capacity and actual performance depend on the configuration. Also check drive compatibility for the specific model and DSM version you’re using.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is worth comparing if ports and expansion options matter as well as file storage.

  • QNAP lists two 2,5-GbE ports and two M.2 slots for this model.
  • According to the manufacturer, the model is supplied without hard drives. Its extra features don’t replace a separate backup.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are useful comparison points among two-bay NAS enclosures.

  • In its NAS test of 5 September 2026, Computer Bild rated both of these models as fast.
  • Computer Bild also noted that both models have high power consumption. These test findings apply to the models mentioned, not the entire range.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a useful comparison point for an archive with four drive bays and a planned high-speed network connection.

  • UGREEN lists four bays and 10-GbE and 2,5-GbE ports for this model.
  • According to the manufacturer, hard drives are sold separately. Computer Bild noted slightly high power consumption in its test; the ports alone don’t guarantee a particular speed on your network.

ASUSTOR

The AS5402T is another model to consider when comparing two-bay NAS devices.

  • The AS5402T specifications list two 2,5-GbE ports and USB ports.
  • Port specifications alone don’t show what difference the transfer connections will make on your group’s network.

Joybuy products for your archive

The following products include Synology NAS devices with four or eight drive bays, offering a starting point for archives with room to expand. You’ll also need to plan for a suitable drive configuration and a separate backup.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS925+ – 4-bay NAS, Dual 2.5GbE, expandable to 9 bays, M.2 NVMe SSD caching, Black

Could suit an archive expected to grow, provided the planned drive configuration meets your storage needs.

Four drive bays; expandable to 9 bays according to the product name. Dual 2.5GbE; M.2 NVMe SSD caching.

An independent backup also requires a separate destination and a tested recovery process.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ – 8-bay NAS, Dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE, up to 360TB, Metal, Black

The eight drive bays listed in the product name could be useful for an archive with greater or growing storage needs.

Dual 2.5GbE; optional 10GbE; up to 360TB according to the product name.

Usable capacity depends on the configuration you choose. Plan for an independent backup separately.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID 1 replace a separate backup of our lectures?

No. Mirroring can help if a drive fails, but it isn’t an independent copy that protects against accidental deletion or damage where the NAS is kept. Plan for a separate backup medium and check that you can restore files from it. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security also advises testing that you can restore your data.

Can we simply install an existing hard drive in the Synology DS225+?

First, check that the specific drive is compatible. Synology also warns that installing a drive containing existing data will erase its contents when it is formatted. Make sure you back up that data first.

Can our group archive or publish recordings featuring identifiable participants just because they’re stored on our own NAS?

No. Owning the hardware doesn’t provide a legal basis. If people can be identified, you must consider the purpose and legal basis for processing their data; any later publication must be assessed separately. The legal basis in a specific case depends on the recording, the people involved and how it will be used. The data protection authority for Rhineland-Palatinate explains these requirements.

What should we consider when handing over archive management?

Decide who needs which files for which tasks, and limit access to what’s necessary. If recordings contain personal data, you should also clarify how long you plan to process it. The data protection authority for Rhineland-Palatinate notes that not every club member should have access to all personal data.

When are more than two drive bays useful?

More bays may be useful if you already have a large number of recordings or expect the archive to grow. Compare your needs with the usable capacity of the specific drive configuration. Extra bays don’t replace a separate backup.