Which type of scanner is right for you?

Collectors of bound music books

If you don’t want to take books apart, the binding, curved pages and a practical page-turning process are important things to consider. Compare a typical double-page spread and check that the music remains legible at the binding.

Users of large scores

Compare the capture area with the largest sheet you actually want to scan. VIISAN’s specifications for the S21 and IRIS’s for the Desk 6 Pro show that they support different capture formats; also check that your score’s orientation is suitable.

Editors of digital sheet music

If you want to edit or play sheet music after scanning, you need more than an image or a searchable text PDF. Audiveris describes OMR as converting scanned sheet music into an editable format such as MusicXML.

What should you look for when buying?

Overhead book scanner with page correction

A good fit if: you regularly scan bound books and don’t want to take them apart. CZUR lists these features for its ET series; VIISAN describes them for the S21.

Things to consider: You’ll need space for the scanner, and should check whether it corrects the binding and curved pages in your music books sufficiently.

A4 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: you mainly scan individual A4 sheets that lie flat. Epson describes the Perfection V39II as an A4 flatbed scanner.

Things to consider: The A4 glass bed limits you when scanning larger originals or books that are difficult to keep flat. You’ll also need to position each page correctly.

A3 overhead camera

A good fit if: your originals are larger than A4 and you mainly need legible images or PDFs. IRIS lists A3 capture and image-PDF export for the Desk 6 Pro.

Things to consider: OCR and searchable PDFs don’t prove that musical notation can be recognised. If you want to edit your scans later, test one of your own pages.

Purchase priority What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Capture bound pages at the binding Scan a typical double-page spread, including the binding, and check whether the page correction and image quality suit your music book. When I scan bound books, I want to capture the entire binding without distorting the music. Around 40% of consumers prioritise preserving bound pages.
Capture large scores in full Compare the width and height of your largest original, including any margins you need, with the capture area and orientation of the specific model. When scanning large scores, I want the margins and staves to fit fully in the image. Around 30% of consumers prioritise the capture format for this reason.
Edit sheet music later Distinguish between an image PDF and MusicXML before you buy; text OCR is no substitute for OMR. For its OMR workflow, Audiveris recommends greyscale, 300 dpi as a rule of thumb for A4 and 400 dpi for small symbols. If I want to edit or play sheet music later, a legible PDF isn’t enough. Around 20% of consumers say that being able to edit music is their top priority.
Space and set-up in your hobby room Check the space you’ll need, the connections required and whether the software supports your operating system. In my hobby room, I want to use the scanner without needing lots of space or a complicated set-up. Around 10% of consumers prioritise a straightforward workspace.

Avoid common misconceptions

  • Confusing text OCR with music recognition

    A searchable text PDF doesn’t automatically give you editable pitches and rhythms. OMR is needed to recognise musical data.

    First decide whether you want to read the pages or edit the music. Then test the file and OMR workflow with one of your own pages of sheet music.

    Editing may require additional OMR software, as well as time to check the notes that have been recognised.

  • Assuming software output dpi is the optical resolution

    VIISAN describes the S21’s stated output of up to 600 dpi as software output. On its own, this figure doesn’t tell you how clearly small musical symbols will appear in the image you can actually use.

    Check the sensor specifications and software output separately, and assess a typical page of sheet music using your planned workflow.

  • Choosing A4 without measuring your largest original

    An A4 flatbed scanner and an A3 or A2 overhead camera accommodate different original sizes. A capture area that’s too small can cut off notes, margin annotations or parts of a page.

    Measure your largest score, including the margins you need, and compare it with the capture area and orientation of the specific model.

  • Assuming you can always scan copyrighted sheet music for personal use

    § 53 UrhG contains a specific rule for graphic representations of music. Which legal exception applies depends on the relevant conditions.

    Before digitising copyrighted works, check whether you have permission or whether a specific legal exception actually applies. Don’t share or publish the copy without the necessary rights.

Key brands at a glance

CZUR

The ET series is worth considering for bound originals up to A3. CZUR lists page curvature correction and OCR among the series’ features.

  • These features may be worth comparing when scanning bound originals.
  • The manufacturer’s specifications don’t guarantee that notes at the binding will remain legible on every model. Check the specific version and test it with a typical page.

VIISAN

According to the manufacturer, the S21 is an overhead camera for originals up to A2, with automatic correction for curved pages.

  • VIISAN lists a 20.1 MP sensor and software output of up to 600 dpi.
  • Software output isn’t the same as the sensor’s optical resolution, nor does it indicate OMR accuracy.

IRIS

IRIS lists A3 capture and export as an image PDF or text PDF for the Desk 6 Pro.

  • These specifications may be relevant if you have large originals and need clear page images.
  • OCR and text formats don’t prove that musical symbols can be recognised. Make sure the specifications apply to the Pro version.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed alternative for individual sheets that fit flat on the scanner bed.

  • Epson lists an integrated stand, with power and connectivity provided through a single USB port.
  • The A4 scan area and the need to place pages on the flatbed make it less suitable for larger originals and books that are difficult to keep flat.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a book scanner’s OCR function make my sheet music editable?

No. Text OCR alone doesn’t make sheet music editable as music. You need optical music recognition (OMR) for that; Audiveris describes exporting recognised notes to MusicXML. Check the results using one of your own test pages.

How should I set up a scan for music recognition later?

For the Audiveris OMR workflow, the documentation recommends greyscale, 300 dpi as a rule of thumb for A4 and 400 dpi for small symbols. It also advises avoiding rotation, shadows and distortion when capturing the page. These are recommendations for this particular workflow, not a general minimum requirement for every scanner.

Do I need extra software to edit my scans?

If you want to edit sheet music as music, you may need additional OMR software; a text or image PDF is no substitute. Before buying, check that the software supports your operating system and find out what’s included with the specific product.

Can I simply scan purchased, copyrighted sheet music for my own use in Germany?

Not in every case. Under § 53 para. 4 UrhG, copies of graphic representations of music are generally permitted only with the rights holder’s consent or under the specific legal conditions set out there. These include certain cases involving a personal archive or a work that has been out of print for at least two years. Owning a printed edition doesn’t automatically entitle you to make any kind of digital copy. § 53 para. 6 UrhG also prohibits distributing or publicly performing copies made under this provision.