Which controller is right for you?

Shoot-’em-up players with very limited desk space

If there’s little room alongside your monitor and keyboard, you’ll need to allow space for your hands and the cable too. HORI specifically describes the Fighting Stick Mini as compact; a low-profile all-button controller, on the other hand, may still take up more desk space despite its shallow height.

Joystick players using a specific console

If you want to use a traditional joystick with your existing console, check that the model supports your exact platform. Some combinations may require additional hardware; for certain consoles, MAYFLASH says the F300 needs a wired controller connected as well.

Players who prefer entering directions with buttons

If you’d rather use directional buttons than a joystick, compare the layout and dimensions of the device. 8BitDo’s claims about the controller’s suitability for fighting games aren’t independent evidence of its performance in shoot-’em-ups.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether you want a joystick or directional buttons. Then check the footprint and platform compatibility, and allow for any extra devices and their cables.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important to?
Footprint and hand rest Measure the available width and depth, including room for cables, and compare them with the dimensions of the exact model. If I need to fit my controller, hands and cables on a cramped desk, every spare centimetre counts. Around 31% of consumers put footprint at the top of their list.
Directional controls Choose between a joystick and directional buttons, and check that you can set up the required button mapping in your game. If I prefer a joystick or deliberately choose buttons for repeated changes of direction, I want to pick the control style that suits how I play. Around 25% of consumers put control feel first.
Platform and connection Check the exact model, console or PC, and game. Also find out whether you’ll need an additional controller or adapter. If I want to use a controller with my existing platform, I need clear information about the exact connection setup. Around 25% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility.
Customisation and setup Check only the features you actually plan to use, and find out what extra parts you’ll need before buying. If I want to tailor button mapping or interchangeable parts to my preferences, I also consider the setup involved. Around 19% of consumers put customisation and effort first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “low-profile” means “takes up little desk space”

    According to the manufacturer, the 8BitDo Arcade Controller is 22 mm high, but it still needs a footprint of 301 × 201 mm.

    Measure the available desk space and compare both dimensions of the controller, rather than focusing only on its height.

  • Taking a platform list as a guarantee that no extra accessories are needed

    For PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360, MAYFLASH says the F300 needs a wired controller connected as well. Requirements for other platforms may vary depending on the model, firmware and adapter.

    Before buying, check the connection instructions for your exact combination of model, firmware, console and game.

  • Taking claims about fighting games as proof of shoot-’em-up performance

    8BitDo promotes the Arcade Controller for competitive fighting games; that doesn’t prove it offers an advantage in shoot-’em-ups.

    Choose between a joystick and directional buttons based on how you prefer to play, and check the button mapping your game needs.

Key brands at a glance

HORI

HORI’s Fighting Stick Mini SPF-038U is a joystick specifically described as compact and designed for PS5 and PS4.

  • HORI lists its dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches, with a microswitch joystick, eight buttons and a wired connection.
  • Its compact design doesn’t guarantee that the control surface will suit every hand size or that it will support every shoot-’em-up.

MAYFLASH

The F300 and F300 Elite offer joystick controls and, depending on the model, PC input modes or customisation options.

  • According to the manufacturer, the F300 can be used with Sanwa-compatible replacement parts; the F300 Elite is described as having Sanwa components.
  • The manufacturer lists the F300 as measuring 30,2 × 23,6 cm. Some consoles require an additional wired controller to be connected; connection requirements vary by model.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers a joystick arcade stick and a separate all-button controller for specified platforms such as Switch and Windows.

  • According to the manufacturer, the Arcade Stick measures 303 × 203 mm; the all-button controller is 22 mm high, with a footprint of 301 × 201 mm.
  • Manufacturer claims about precision in fighting games aren’t an independent comparison for shoot-’em-ups. The all-button model’s low profile doesn’t mean it has a correspondingly small footprint.

Qanba

According to the European manufacturer’s website, the Drone 2 is a joystick option with a platform selector for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba lists its footprint as 35,6 × 22,1 cm.
  • The manufacturer’s claim that it’s portable doesn’t automatically mean the model takes up very little space on a small desk.

Controllers to suit you at Joybuy

This selection features a leverless all-button controller for players who prefer to enter directions using buttons rather than a joystick.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller (Switch 2/Switch/PC/iOS/Android)

The leverless all-button design suits you if you want to enter directions using buttons rather than a joystick.

The product title lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android, as well as Bluetooth, 2.4G and wired connectivity.

The product title also mentions hot-swappable Fast-Trigger mechanical switches and RGB. This model doesn’t have a traditional joystick.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a “compact” case fit on my small desk?

Not necessarily. Compare the available width and depth with the footprint, and allow room for your hands and cables. 8BitDo lists the Arcade Controller at 301 × 201 mm; HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini’s dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches.

Do I need to connect anything else when using a MAYFLASH F300 with a console?

For PS4, Xbox One and Xbox 360, MAYFLASH says a wired controller must also be connected to the stick. Before buying, check your exact console, firmware and any adapters you may need; don’t assume a platform is supported based solely on a general list.

How do I set up the controls for my game?

First check which types of directional input your game accepts. According to the manufacturer, you can switch between D-pad and analogue-axis modes on the MAYFLASH F300; the button mapping on the 8BitDo Arcade Stick can be customised using the manufacturer’s software. Check your chosen layout in the game itself rather than assuming it will generally improve performance.

What should I know about extra accessories and returns?

Allow for any additional controller or adapter you need, and make sure you have somewhere to connect it. For online purchases in Germany, consumers generally have 14 days from receiving the goods to notify the seller that they wish to cancel, according to the Verbraucherzentrale.

Which legal product details are important when buying in Germany?

The Bundesnetzagentur explains that products covered by relevant EU harmonisation legislation must carry the CE marking. You can’t determine whether a specific version on sale meets the requirements that apply to it based solely on its model name or a general manufacturer’s website. The CE marking isn’t an independent quality award.