People with hardbound sketchbooks
If you regularly scan bound pages, check whether the spine and page edges can be captured without pressing the book flat against a glass platen.
If you often scan bound pages and don’t want to press the book against a glass platen, an overhead scanner with a suitable capture area is an obvious choice. For a few pages that can be laid flat safely, an A4 flatbed scanner may be enough; if important lines are close to the spine, a model with a book-edge design is another option. Check a typical page and the space the scanner needs when set up, rather than basing your choice on resolution figures alone.
If you regularly scan bound pages, check whether the spine and page edges can be captured without pressing the book flat against a glass platen.
Measure your largest page and check a representative drawing to make sure the lines, colours and edges appear in the saved image file as you need them to.
If you only scan a few suitable pages, look for quick set-up, enough room for the open book and a way to clear the scanner and files from the shared workspace afterwards.
A good fit if: You regularly scan bound pages without laying them on a glass platen.
Things to consider: The scanner and open book need space while scanning; check any automatic corrections on one of your drawings.
A good fit if: You scan individual pages that fit safely and completely on the glass.
Things to consider: You place each page on the scanner separately; a stiff binding or an oversized double-page spread can’t easily be accommodated.
A good fit if: You can position pages individually against a book edge and need to capture lines close to the spine.
Things to consider: Claims about scanning close to the spine apply to the specific model and don’t replace a test scan of your drawing.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Binding and spine | Scan a typical double-page spread, including the spine and edges; compare the original with the corrected version. | If I want to protect the binding and capture the spine, scanning without laying the book flat is important. Around 28 % of consumers cite the binding and spine as their main concern. |
| Page size | Measure the largest single page and double-page spread, then compare the dimensions with the capture area of the exact model. | If I want my largest page to appear in full in a single capture, I’ll check its dimensions first. Around 22 % of consumers put format first. |
| Lines and colours | Capture a page with fine lines, light areas and details at the edges as an image file, then check it. | If I want to use the drawing later, I want to judge the result against the original rather than just compare a figure. Around 22 % of consumers say image detail and colour reproduction are their main concerns. |
| Desk space | Allow for the workspace needed when the scanner is set up, and somewhere to store the scanner and accessories. | If I need to clear the shared desk after scanning, the space needed during use matters just as much as storage. Around 17 % of consumers cite limited desk space as their main concern. |
| Files and software | Check the image format you need, your operating system and the storage location on the computer you use. | If I’m using a shared computer, I want to create suitable image files and choose where they’re saved. Around 11 % of consumers cite file management as their main concern. |
The optical resolution of a flatbed scanner and the sensor pixels of an overhead camera describe different things. So you can’t use the figures published by Canon and VIISAN to make a direct comparison of their scan results.
Compare the devices using the same typical drawing and check that the whole area you need is captured.
If the lines or edges aren’t right the first time, you may need to scan again.
Even a foldable scanner needs space for the open book and capture area while scanning.
Measure the available desk space with the scanner set up, and plan where to store it between scans.
Automatic correction doesn’t guarantee that the lines and details at the edges of your drawing will look unchanged.
Check the spine, page edges and fine lines before deleting the original scan. For important drawings, it may be worth keeping an additional uncorrected version.
Checking the result and, if needed, scanning again will take extra time.
The Aura Pro is a foldable overhead scanner; the ET series is a separate range for bound materials, up to the format specified for each model.
The VK16 is an overhead scanner for bound pages, with a capture area of up to A3.
The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner for pages that can be laid flat safely.
The FB10 is an A4 flatbed with a lift-up lid; the FB2280E is a separate A4 model with an angled book edge.
The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a USB-powered A4 flatbed scanner for pages that are the right size and can be laid flat safely.
No, not if you only need an image of your page. OCR recognises text and creates searchable or editable text files; VIISAN describes this separately from image capture. Instead, check the image format you need and test-scan a page with fine lines.
Check that the scan software you need works with your operating system and offers the features you’ll actually use. CZUR says the Aura Pro’s ABBYY OCR is currently incompatible with MacBooks featuring the M2 chip. If you only want to create image files, also check that the process for doing so works on your computer.
When the scanner is set up, allow enough space for the device and your sketchbook opened fully. Before a longer session, test-scan a page, including the spine and edges, and decide where to save the files. If scans shouldn’t remain on the shared computer after your session, remove them from the shared area.
Not in every case. Under § 53 UrhG, individuals may make single copies for private use only under the conditions set out there; additional restrictions apply to a substantially complete copy of a book. Copies made under § 53 must not be distributed or made available to the public. As drawings may be protected by copyright, check the rights and intended use before sharing someone else’s scans. § 53 UrhG, published on Gesetze im Internet, is the relevant provision.
Not simply because the desk is shared. If scanned pages contain personal data and their processing falls under the GDPR, those responsible must take appropriate steps to prevent unauthorised access. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains this principle; choose storage and sharing settings that suit the specific task. The type of scanner alone doesn’t mean that uploading to the cloud is permitted.