Which scanner is right for which group?

Groups with delicate, bound sketchbooks

If you need to scan books repeatedly without taking them apart or pressing them firmly flat, it’s worth comparing overhead scanners. Ricoh says the ScanSnap SV600 offers contactless scanning and book correction; CZUR says its ET range corrects curved book pages.

Groups focused on drawing detail

If you need to assess fine lines and areas of colour, check the resulting image file using one of your own drawings rather than relying on text recognition or advertised speed. Canon and VIISAN publish technical resolution figures for their flatbed scanners, but these alone don’t show how well a specific original will be reproduced.

Groups with large originals

Before choosing a scanner, measure the largest individual page and the area you want to capture when a book is open. VIISAN describes the VK16 as an A3 overhead scanner and the VF3240 as an A3 flatbed scanner; Canon gives the LiDE 400 a scan area of 216 × 297 mm.

What should you look for when buying?

The proportions below relate to consumers digitising sketchbooks for a community group, with each person assigned their main buying priority.

Priority What to check when buying Who it matters most to
Binding and gutter How far your book opens; whether details near the gutter are visible in test scans. If you scan bound books repeatedly and don’t want to put strain on the binding, the gutter in the scan matters too. Around 36% of consumers prioritise scanning bound pages gently.
Lines and colours Scan the same test page with fine lines and areas of colour; take automatic image correction into account. If fine strokes and areas of colour need to be as clear as possible, the resulting image file is what counts. Around 29% of consumers put image fidelity first.
Original size Measure the largest individual page and the desired double-page spread separately; compare the measurements with the usable scanning area. If you want to scan a whole page or an open book in one go, first work out how much space you need. Around 21% of consumers prioritise the size of their original.
Shared workflow Check the software on the group’s computer; test the capture process, page order and file output together. If several people use the same scanning station, the process should be clear to everyone. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a consistent workflow for the group.

An overhead scanner with a book mode can avoid pressing bound pages against a glass surface. Even so, check that the gutter, edges and colours appear in your files as you need them to. With a flatbed scanner, the stated resolution isn’t the only thing that matters: the page must also rest on it gently and fit entirely within the scanning area.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Choosing based only on dpi or megapixels

    A resolution figure doesn’t show how the gutter, fine lines and colours in your drawing will look in the finished file.

    Before settling on a scanner type, compare test scans of a typical page of your own, including its gutter and areas of colour.

    Repeated scans and subsequent image correction can take extra time.

  • Assuming A3 is big enough for every double-page spread

    An open book may need a larger scanning area than a single A3 page.

    Measure the area you want to capture, whether it’s an individual page or an open book, and compare it with the scanner’s usable area.

    If the whole original won’t fit, you may need to scan it in sections and edit the images afterwards.

  • Assuming every bound book will fit on a flatbed

    A page resting on the glass doesn’t mean the book can be opened without putting strain on its binding.

    Check how the book opens without applying pressure. If that isn’t practical, compare an overhead scanner with a book-edge flatbed scanner.

Suitable brands and model ranges

CZUR

The ET range is designed for bound originals scanned from above.

  • CZUR Germany says the ET range can scan up to A3 and correct curved book pages.
  • Use your own drawings to check whether colours, lines and the gutter meet your needs after correction.

VIISAN

The range includes the VK16, an A3 overhead scanner, and the VF3240, an A3 flatbed scanner.

  • VIISAN lists automatic capture and digital page separation for the VK16; the manufacturer gives the VF3240 an optical resolution of 2400 × 2400 dpi.
  • The different scanner types and technical specifications don’t provide a direct comparison of image fidelity. Check which scanning method suits you and try one of your own pages.

Ricoh ScanSnap

The ScanSnap SV600 is a contactless A3 option for books and, according to Ricoh, drawings too.

  • Ricoh describes book correction and page detection for scanning from above.
  • Ricoh gives a maximum document thickness of 30 mm for contactless scanning. Bear this limit in mind when checking whether it can handle thick sketchbooks.

Plustek

The OpticBook 4800 is a book-edge flatbed scanner for individual pages that can be laid on it.

  • Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge and a scan time of 3.6 seconds for A4 colour scans at 300 dpi under the manufacturer’s test conditions.
  • You need to position each page individually. Check whether the book can be placed on the scanner without putting strain on its binding.

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is an A4 flatbed scanner for pages that can be laid on it gently.

  • Canon Germany lists a maximum scan area of 216 × 297 mm and an optical resolution of 4800 × 4800 dpi.
  • This doesn’t automatically make it suitable for a larger original or a book that only lies flat when pressed down.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell whether A4 is big enough for our sketchbooks?

Measure the largest page you want to capture in full in one go, then compare both measurements with the usable scan area. Canon gives the LiDE 400 a maximum area of 216 × 297 mm; for larger originals, look for a scanner with a suitably larger scanning area.

How do we set up a shared scanning station?

First, check that the intended software works on the group’s computer. Then use a test page to agree how books should be aligned, how double-page spreads should be checked and how files should be named. Automatic page separation doesn’t replace a visual check.

Can we publish scanned drawings online?

Owning a sketchbook doesn’t automatically give you the rights to use the drawings inside it. The German Patent and Trade Mark Office distinguishes, among other things, between reproduction and making a work available to the public; check the rights for each intended use. If files contain personal data, the group must also take into account the data protection requirements that apply to the specific way it processes that data.