Which scanning method is right for you?

Holiday slide editors

If you want to edit your scans repeatedly and keep the original files unchanged, check the file transfer options and output format. A working copy is no substitute for a separate backup; the German Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up your data regularly.

Owners of full slide magazines

If you have lots of slides already sorted into magazines, a slide magazine scanner can save you from loading each one individually. reflecta lists specific compatible magazine types for the DigitDia 8000, so check whether yours is included.

Scanners for use away from a computer

A standalone scanner can save directly to an SD card. reflecta says the x33-Scan outputs JPEG files to SD, while Rollei lists internal memory and an SD/SDHC slot for the DF-S 310 SE. To create working copies and a separate backup, you’ll need to transfer the files afterwards.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether you want to organise your scans on a computer straight away or capture them without a PC. Then check that the formats, collection and output options meet your needs.

What you need What to look for when buying Who this matters most to
Keeping original scans and working copies separate Check the initial storage location, file transfer options and output format; plan for a separate backup. If I want to keep original scans separate from edited versions, I need a clear route from the scanner to a backup. Around 33% of consumers put having separate scan versions first.
Slide format and holder compatibility Check the film format, mounts and holders against the specific model; for slide magazine scanners, check the magazine type too. If my slides come in different formats, I want to be sure the mounts and holders will actually fit. Around 27% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their existing originals.
Time and effort for your collection Try the whole process, from loading the slides to checking and backing up the files, with a representative batch. If I have a large collection, I want to avoid loading slides one by one and get a sense of the total time involved. Around 20% of consumers prioritise throughput.
Image checking and further editing Distinguish between sensor resolution and interpolated output resolution; check the output format and any available correction features. If I want to edit my scans, I need to understand the specifications and be able to check the results. Around 20% of consumers prioritise image checking.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating your only SD card as a backup

    Keeping working copies and scans on the same card won’t protect them if the card is lost or damaged.

    Keep the original files separate from your edits and make an additional backup on another device. Check that you can restore the files.

    Remember to allow time to transfer the files and check the backup too.

  • Confusing interpolated pixel counts with sensor resolution

    Manufacturers may list the sensor resolution separately from a higher, interpolated output resolution. These figures are shown separately for the reflecta x33-Scan and Rollei DF-S 310 SE.

    Compare the sensor and output figures separately, and test the results with one of your own slides.

  • Assuming “for slides” means it will work with every mount

    Supported formats and magazines vary by model. reflecta lists specific magazine types for the DigitDia 8000, while the Plustek OpticFilm 135i is described as suitable for 35 mm material.

    Before buying, check a few of your actual slides, mounts and magazines against the specifications for the specific model.

    Depending on your collection, you may need additional holders or time to change them.

  • Assuming the scan time per image applies to your whole archive

    Figures for scanning an individual image don’t necessarily include loading, reviewing, organising files and backing them up.

    Try the whole process with a small, representative part of your collection, continuing until the files have been checked and backed up.

    Allow extra time for loading, reviewing, organising and backing up.

Key brands at a glance

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i is a computer-connected option for compatible 35 mm material and smaller batches.

  • Plustek says it can scan up to four mounted slides at a time and includes an infrared channel.
  • The F.A.Z. gives the scan quality of the 135i it tested a positive review, but notes that its batch size is limited for large collections. This applies to the model tested, not to every device from the brand.

reflecta

The models offer different workflows: the x33-Scan saves directly to SD without a PC, while the DigitDia 8000 connects to a computer and works with compatible magazines.

  • According to reflecta, the x33-Scan saves JPEG files to SD. For the DigitDia 8000, the manufacturer lists specific magazine types and DNG output.
  • The higher output resolution listed for the x33-Scan is interpolated. The magazine and file format specifications for the DigitDia 8000 don’t automatically apply to the x33-Scan.

Rollei

The DF-S 310 SE offers a standalone scanning option with a display, internal memory and an SD/SDHC slot.

  • Rollei lists support for SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB and image capture at 14 MP.
  • The advertised output of up to 24 MP is interpolated. Check the card requirements, compatible holders and how you’ll transfer files for a separate backup.

Kodak Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan sold in the EU is a standalone device with adapters for specified film formats.

  • According to the EU product page, it comes with adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film, a 14 MP sensor and support for SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
  • An SD card is not included. These specifications apply to this version and don’t automatically apply to other Slide N Scan models.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does an SD card containing your scans count as a separate backup?

No. If the SD card is your only storage location, you don’t have an independent backup. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up your data regularly and checking that you can restore the saved files.

How can I create separate working copies?

Once you’ve captured the scans, transfer them and keep one unchanged version. Edit duplicates in clearly labelled folders or use distinctive file names. Also back up important original files to a separate device; if you’re using an SD card scanner, transferring the files is part of the process.

Can I scan 110 or 126 slides in any 35 mm slide scanner?

No. Check the exact film format and compatible holders for the specific model: Kodak Photo Plus EU lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film for the Slide N Scan, while Plustek describes the OpticFilm 135i as suitable for 35 mm film.

What should I check before buying?

The EU version of the Kodak Slide N Scan requires an SD card for operation, and one isn’t included. For computer-connected models, make sure your computer, operating system and software are compatible with the device. You’ll also need another storage device for separate backups.

In Germany, can I digitise holiday slides to make private working copies and share them publicly?

Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows individuals, subject to the conditions set out there, to make individual copies for private use that is not directly or indirectly for commercial purposes. This does not amount to general permission to share them publicly: Section 53(6) of the UrhG generally prohibits distributing or publicly displaying such copies. Whether further rights or permission are required for a specific image belonging to someone else must be assessed separately.