Choose your scanner based on the type of originals you have, the local file format you need and how the slides are fed into the scanner. A computer-connected magazine scanner may suit compatible magazines and a DNG workflow, while a small slide holder or standalone SD scanner works differently. Check the exact model, compatible magazines and output formats before you decide.
Which scanning method suits you?
Building an editable archive of your slides
If you want to keep scans locally and edit them again later, look for an explicitly stated output format and a clear file workflow. reflecta specifies DNG for the DigitDia 8000 and JPEG for the x33-Scan; Epson specifies TIFF for the Perfection V600 Photo.
Owners of lots of slides in magazines
If your mounted slides are already stored in magazines, check that the scanner supports your exact magazine type. F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says that the tested Plustek OpticFilm 135i can handle up to four mounted slides per pass; reflecta describes the DigitDia 8000 as processing compatible magazines.
Collectors with a mix of originals
If you want to digitise film strips, other film formats or prints as well as slides, compare the originals and holders supported by the specific model. Epson, Kodak Photo Plus EU and Rollei Deutschland describe different scanning methods for these types of originals.
What to look for when buying
First decide which files you want to keep for editing later, and how your slides are stored. Then you can work out whether an individual holder, an SD scanner or a magazine scanner best suits your workflow.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Files you can edit locally |
Check the output format for the exact model: reflecta specifies JPEG for the x33-Scan and DNG for the DigitDia 8000; Epson specifies TIFF for the Perfection V600 Photo. Also check that the scanning software and your computer fit your planned file workflow. |
If I want to keep scans locally as source files and edit them again later, the format matters more than a quick preview. Around 36% of consumers put an editable archive first. |
| Throughput and reloading |
Count your slides and check whether they are stored in magazines or individual mounts. Compare the supported magazine type or number of slides per pass with the specific scanner. |
With a large collection, I want to avoid reloading slides as often as possible, so I need a compatible magazine feed. Around 29% of consumers prioritise less reloading. |
| Compatible originals |
Make a note of your film formats, mounts and magazines before choosing a model. Check which originals the exact model supports and which holders are included. |
If my collection includes film strips or prints as well as slides, the holders and scanning methods need to suit them. Around 21% of consumers pay particular attention to compatibility with their originals. |
| Easy scanning and editing afterwards |
Check whether an SD card is required and how files are transferred. For Kodachrome and traditional black-and-white film, don't assume that infrared-based dust removal will be suitable. |
If I want to view images and save them locally without a scanning PC, the workflow needs to suit me. I also want to know which adjustments my types of film may need. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a straightforward scanning process. |
Avoid common misconceptions
-
Confusing interpolated pixel counts with extra image detail
For the x33-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between an output of 4608 × 3072 pixels and an interpolated maximum of 5760 × 3840 pixels. A higher interpolated pixel count does not automatically mean that more image detail has been captured.
Compare the scanning specifications for the exact model and consider which source file you need for further editing.
-
Assuming a short slide holder works like a magazine feed
F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says that the tested OpticFilm 135i can handle up to four mounted slides per pass. By contrast, reflecta describes the DigitDia 8000 as processing compatible magazines. These feed systems are not interchangeable.
Count your slides, check how they are stored and make sure the magazine type or holder capacity matches the exact model.
-
Assuming SD storage means a raw file format
reflecta specifies JPEG as the output format for the x33-Scan and DNG for the DigitDia 8000. An SD slot alone does not tell you which format the scanner saves in.
Decide which source format you want and check the full model name to confirm it.
-
Assuming infrared dust removal works with every type of film
LaserSoft Imaging notes that software-based correction may be relevant for black-and-white film and Kodachrome, where infrared-based methods may not help.
Take your film types into account and test challenging originals with a sample scan, rather than assuming a particular correction feature based on the device name alone.
Key brands at a glance
Plustek
35 mm film scanners for a computer-based slide and negative workflow.
- F.A.Z. Kaufkompass rates the scan quality, software and holder of the tested OpticFilm 135i positively.
- According to F.A.Z. Kaufkompass, the holder for the tested 135i accommodates up to four mounted slides per pass. Features listed for the 135i Ai, such as an infrared channel or SilverFast Ai Studio 9, should not be assumed to apply to the 135i.
reflecta
Offers different ways to save scans locally: standalone JPEG output or computer-connected magazine scanning with DNG.
- reflecta specifies JPEG saved to an SD card for the x33-Scan and DNG output for the DigitDia 8000.
- The magazine type and computer requirements need to be right for the DigitDia 8000; the x33-Scan's maximum pixel count is interpolated.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is a documented flatbed scanning option for slides, film strips, medium-format film and prints.
- Epson Deutschland specifies TIFF output and support for different types of originals for this exact model.
- Epson Deutschland marks the Perfection V600 Photo as no longer available. Its features therefore do not confirm that it is available new and cannot be applied to another Epson model.
KODAK Photo Plus
The SLIDE N SCAN described on the EU website saves scans directly to an SD card without needing a computer.
- KODAK Photo Plus EU lists holders for 135, 110 and 126 film, as well as direct SD storage.
- The supplier says an SD card is required for operation and is not included. The term ‘digital files’ does not specify a particular TIFF or DNG format.
Rollei
According to the German manufacturer website, the PDF-S 240 SE combines scanning options for mounted slides, negatives and prints.
- The listed originals include slides, 24 × 36 negatives and prints.
- This range of supported originals does not confirm that the scanner has a magazine feed. Check the resolution and items included against the offer for the exact model.
Suitable products on Joybuy
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is an SD slide scanner enough if I want to edit the files later?
It depends on whether its stated file format suits your editing workflow. reflecta specifies JPEG saved to an SD card for the x33-Scan and DNG for the computer-connected DigitDia 8000. Epson specifies TIFF for the Perfection V600 Photo, which Epson Deutschland marks as no longer available.
Can I load my existing slide magazines straight into the scanner?
Only if the scanner explicitly supports your magazine type. reflecta lists CS, Universal-DIN-108, LKM and Paximat magazines for the DigitDia 8000; a holder for individual slides is not a magazine feed.
What should I check before installation and maintenance?
Check your computer meets the operating system and storage requirements; reflecta specifies at least 40 GB of free hard drive space for the DigitDia 8000. Carefully remove any visible dust and check a sample scan. LaserSoft Imaging says software-based correction may be relevant for black-and-white film and Kodachrome when infrared-based methods do not help.