Which scanning approach is right for you?

Volunteers with full slide magazines

If you want to scan slides that are already sorted, first check whether your existing magazine system is compatible with the scanner. reflecta lists several compatible magazine types for the DigitDia 8000.

Image archive managers

If you may want to edit selected slides again later, plan your file formats, naming system and backups from the outset. The Library of Congress recommends considering the purpose, use and storage of digitised image files, while the Federal Office for Information Security recommends making regular backups.

Volunteers viewing slides together

If you don’t have a dedicated scanning PC, or need to handle different mounts and formats, check that the holders are suitable and that there’s a clear process for handing over files. reflecta and Kodak Photo Plus describe different holder and storage solutions for their respective devices.

What should your group look for?

PC magazine scanner

Best for: Large numbers of mounted slides in compatible magazines, with files to be managed or edited on a computer.

Things to consider: You’ll need a computer and suitable software. Magazine transport doesn’t replace checking the slides or organising the files.

PC-free magazine scanner

Best for: 35 mm slides in supported magazines when you don’t want a computer at the scanning station.

Things to consider: Check magazine compatibility and file output. The manufacturer’s scanning-speed figures don’t necessarily reflect the time needed for your club’s entire workflow.

PC film scanner with holder

Best for: Scanning and editing a manageable selection of 35 mm slides on a computer.

Things to consider: You’ll need to reload the holder. Check the software and system requirements for the specific model.

Compact scanner with SD storage

Best for: Volunteers who want to view and digitise compatible slides without needing a PC at the scanning station.

Things to consider: Check the file format and holder. According to Kodak Photo Plus, the SD card required for the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN is not included.

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

Best for: Scanning slides as well as other originals, provided a suitable, available device with compatible holders is on offer.

Things to consider: Epson Germany lists the Perfection V600 Photo as no longer available. For other models, check the transparency unit, holders and software separately.

What matters What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Loading effort for large collections Compare the number and arrangement of your slides with the magazines supported, or the number of slides that fit in the holder at a time. If I have lots of magazines that are already sorted to work through, reducing reloading is my main priority. Around 33% of consumers put throughput first.
Editable archive files Check the output formats and scanning settings for the specific model; keep original scans and working copies organised separately. If selected slides may need editing later, I need a suitable workflow for original files and backups. Around 27% of consumers prioritise editable archive files.
Compatible slides, mounts and magazines Compare your original slides and magazines with the holder, magazine system and items included with the model. If our collection includes different mounts or formats, I want to know in advance what will actually fit in the scanner. Around 20% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their formats and mounts.
A simple process for different volunteers Run a test scan from start to finish, including the PC or card reader, file name, destination folder and backup. If different volunteers use the scanning station, file handover should be straightforward for everyone to follow. Around 20% of consumers put a simple workflow first.

Common pitfalls

  • Using the manufacturer’s seconds-per-slide figure to plan the whole project

    The quoted scanning speed doesn’t automatically include sorting, reloading, checking the slides or organising the files. Magazine transport and short holder runs also involve different workflows.

    Before estimating how long the project will take, run a complete test with different slides, right through to saving and organising the files.

    Remember to allow volunteer time for sorting, naming and backing up files, too.

  • Assuming interpolated pixels represent captured image detail

    For the x33-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between standard output and a higher interpolated resolution. The Library of Congress recommends using image data that hasn’t been upscaled for digital photographic preservation.

    Compare the stated native or non-interpolated resolution, and make suitable test scans for your intended use.

  • Assuming one slide holder will fit everything

    Devices vary in the magazines, mount thicknesses and special formats they support. reflecta gives a maximum mount thickness of 3.2 mm for the x33-Scan; Pocket and Instamatic formats require a separate adapter set.

    Check the dimensions of a few original slides and magazines against the holder and accessories supplied with the specific model.

    Depending on your collection, you may need an additional adapter or a different type of scanner.

  • Planning around a reference model that is no longer available as a new product

    Epson Germany lists the Perfection V600 Photo as no longer available. Its features don’t confirm the availability or specification of another flatbed scanner.

    For a model currently on sale, check the transparency unit, compatible holders and software.

Brands to consider

reflecta

The DigitDia 8000, DigitDia evolution and x33-Scan offer different workflows for magazine and SD card scanning.

  • For the DigitDia 8000, reflecta lists CS, Universal DIN 108, LKM and Paximat magazine systems, as well as DNG output.
  • According to reflecta, the DigitDia evolution saves directly to an SD card, while the x33-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card.
  • Holders, magazines and supported file formats vary by model, so check them against your collection.

Plustek

The OpticFilm models are PC-connected film scanners for 35 mm slides; check which features apply to each model.

  • According to F.A.Z. Kaufkompass, the OpticFilm 135i can scan up to four mounted slides at a time.
  • Plustek lists an integrated infrared channel and scanning software supplied with the OpticFilm 8300i SE.
  • The OpticFilm 8300i SE’s features don’t necessarily apply to the 135i; check the requirements for the specific model.

KODAK Photo Plus

The SLIDE N SCAN described on the EU product page is an SD-based device supplied with adapters for the film formats listed there.

  • Kodak Photo Plus lists supplied adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film formats.
  • According to Kodak Photo Plus, an SD card is required to use the scanner and is not included.
  • Check the exact model name and your slides against the specifications for the device in question.

Rollei

The DF-S 310 SE is an SD-based option, and the inserts it supports need to suit your collection.

  • Rollei lists additional inserts for Pocket film and Super 8.
  • According to Rollei, the SD card slot accepts SD and SDHC cards with capacities of up to 32 GB.
  • Before choosing, check that your slides fit the inserts supplied.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo illustrates the flatbed alternative for prints and various film originals.

  • For this model, Epson lists a capacity of four 35 mm slides per holder pass and TIFF output.
  • Epson Germany lists the Perfection V600 Photo as no longer available; don’t assume its specifications apply to other scanners without checking the model.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How can our group get started without scanning the whole collection with an unsuitable device?

First, agree on the purpose, who will use the scans and how to handle the originals safely. Then test the full process with different mounts or magazines. The Library of Congress recommends taking future use and storage into account when planning digitisation.

Is it enough to leave the scans on the SD card?

An SD card shouldn’t be the only place where your group keeps its files. Transfer and organise them so they’re easy to identify, and check that you can restore them from a backup. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends making regular backups.

What else might we need to buy?

It depends on the device and your slide collection. According to Kodak Photo Plus, the SD card required for the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN is not included. Also check whether you need compatible adapters, storage media or a suitable computer, and compare the items supplied and software requirements with the specific model.

Can our club publicly display digitised slides that show identifiable people?

Not simply because the club owns or has scanned the slides. Under § 22 KunstUrhG, consent is generally required to distribute or publicly display images of people; § 23 sets out exceptions and limits them where legitimate interests would be infringed. Rights to the photograph itself may also apply. Whether a particular image can be published depends on the image and the relevant rights and circumstances of its use.