If you already have a suitable stick and often adjust the throttle on long trading flights, a standalone throttle is a sensible place to start. If you have neither a stick nor a throttle, a HOTAS set may be a better fit. For lateral and vertical adjustments when docking, compare the additional analogue axes on a throttle grip with a second stick, and check how they can be mapped in the game you play. For long sessions, grip position, resistance, stability and room for both hands matter too – manufacturer specifications alone don’t prove that a device will be comfortable to use without fatigue.
Who are the different controls best suited to?
Long-haul traders who already have a stick
If you want to adjust the throttle with your free hand on longer trading flights and keep frequently used commands close to hand, a standalone throttle can complement your existing stick. Thrustmaster says the TWCS has adjustable resistance, but how it feels in your hand depends on your setup.
Traders who dock frequently
If you want to control more than just forward thrust, compare the analogue axes on a throttle grip with a second stick. Logitech G lists mini analogue sticks on the X56, while VKB lists an X/Y gimbal in the grip of the STECS Space Mini Plus Left-Hand. You’ll need to map the inputs to suit the game you’re playing.
Beginners with limited desk space
If you don’t yet have a stick or throttle, check the contents, setup and accessibility of the controls together. According to Thrustmaster, the T.16000M FCS HOTAS includes a stick and the TWCS; VKB lists a desktop base and mounting option for the STECS Space Mini Plus Left-Hand.
What should you consider when choosing?
Standalone throttle
A good fit if:You already have a stick and want to control thrust and frequently used commands with your other hand.
The trade-off:A stick isn’t included. Extra axes and detents are only useful if you can map them appropriately in your game.
HOTAS set
A good fit if:You need a stick and a separate throttle. The T.16000M FCS HOTAS includes the TWCS; Logitech G lists mini analogue sticks on the X56 for additional control axes.
The trade-off:Two control units take up space. If you already have a stick, the extra one in the set may be redundant.
Second stick
A good fit if:You want your free hand to control movement through space rather than a throttle setting that you leave in place for longer periods.
The trade-off:You’ll need to set up the throttle and movement controls you want in the game itself; a second stick doesn’t work in the same way as a throttle.
| What matters to you |
What to check before buying |
Who it matters most to |
| Throttle control over long distances |
Grip position, usable lever travel and adjustable resistance; Thrustmaster lists 80 mm of sliding travel for the TWCS. |
If I often make adjustments on long trading flights, the lever needs to be easy to reach in my setup. Around 33% of consumers put particular importance on having throttle controls within easy reach. |
| Axes for docking manoeuvres |
The number and position of analogue inputs, and how they can be mapped in your game. Logitech lists mini analogue sticks on the X56; VKB lists an X/Y gimbal in the grip of the STECS Space Mini Plus Left-Hand. |
If I want to make lateral or vertical adjustments when docking, I need suitable analogue inputs and a working control mapping. Around 27% of consumers prioritise these correction axes. |
| What’s included and how much space it takes up |
Check the exact set name, included controls, hand orientation, footprint and any mounting requirements. |
If I only want to add the devices I’m missing and set them up in the space I have, the exact contents matter. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the equipment included and how it can be set up. |
| Game controls and profiles |
Check that your game supports the input devices and axis mappings you want. Once set up, test the axes and save your profile if supported. |
If I want to configure the controls specifically for my game and use them again, the mapping needs to be easy to follow. Around 20% of consumers prioritise control mapping. |
Avoiding common buying mistakes
-
Buying a HOTAS set when you only need a throttle
The T.16000M FCS HOTAS and X56 each include a stick and a throttle; the TWCS is also available separately.
Compare the equipment you already have with the full contents listed for the exact product.
A set could mean an unnecessary second stick and extra space taken up.
-
Assuming extra buttons are the same as ready-to-use axes for space flight
Even existing analogue axes need to be assigned to the functions you want in the game you’re playing.
Count analogue inputs separately from buttons, then test the mappings in-game and check for possible conflicts.
Setting up and checking the mappings takes time.
-
Judging a compact design without considering setup and how it feels in your hand
Differences in the base and setup don’t tell you whether a device will be comfortable to use during a long session.
Before buying, check the space it needs, how much room it has to move and whether your chosen version requires a mount.
Depending on the version and setup, you may need an additional mount.
-
Using an old ranking or similarly named models as up-to-date evidence
The list published by heise online / TechStage on 20 February 2023 is historical; similarly named Warthog versions aren’t automatically the same product.
Put previous rankings in context and, when looking at a current offer, check the model name and what’s included again.
Key brands at a glance
Thrustmaster
Its product range includes standalone PC throttles and HOTAS sets that also include a stick.
- Thrustmaster lists adjustable resistance for the TWCS and six configurable detents for the Sol-R.
- The T.16000M FCS HOTAS set includes a stick and the TWCS. Manufacturer features don’t prove that a product will be more comfortable during long sessions.
Logitech G
The X56 is a HOTAS set for buyers looking for a stick and additional analogue thumb inputs as well as a throttle.
- Logitech lists dual throttles and mini analogue sticks.
- If you already have a stick, you’ll get another one in the set; you’ll need to check that the axis mappings you want work in your game.
VKB
The STECS Space Mini Plus and Standard are aimed at buyers looking for a standalone, configurable throttle for space flight.
- VKB lists an X/Y gimbal in the grip, a desktop base and a mounting option for the STECS Space Mini Plus Left-Hand.
- The base, hand orientation and what’s included vary by version. The manufacturer’s description doesn’t prove that it will suit a particular control mapping in a game.
VIRPIL
The MongoosT-50CM4 is another product line offering a standalone throttle with two lever axes.
- VIRPIL lists an analogue mini stick and interchangeable detent plates.
- These manufacturer specifications don’t prove that it will be more comfortable during long sessions or that it will work with the mappings you want in a particular game.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is a standalone throttle enough if I don’t have a joystick yet?
A standalone throttle doesn’t include a stick for flight control. If you want to buy both, compare what’s included in a HOTAS set; according to Thrustmaster, the T.16000M FCS HOTAS includes a stick and the TWCS.
How do I set up extra axes for my game?
Start by checking the input options in the specific game you play. Roberts Space Industries explains that Star Citizen supports customisable joystick and HOTAS mappings, as well as exporting your own profiles. This doesn’t mean other games offer the same options.
How do I test the throttle after setting it up?
In-game, test the direction and mapping of each axis you use, and check for any control conflicts. Roberts Space Industries explains how to change and save control profiles for Star Citizen; resistance and detent options depend on the model.
What are my rights when shopping online in Germany if the controls aren’t right for me or the device is faulty?
For an online purchase as a consumer, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel. According to Verbraucherzentrale, you have to tell the seller you’re cancelling; simply returning the item isn’t enough. This is separate from your statutory rights if the goods are faulty, which you exercise against the seller. Your Europe explains that goods bought in the EU come with a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the date you receive them; this is separate from any additional manufacturer’s guarantee.