First, check whether the film you want to watch and the app you need are available on your existing TV. If you can also listen privately through it, you may not need an extra player. If the app is missing, an HDMI stick may be enough if your Wi-Fi and headphone setup are suitable. A separate box may be a better option if you need to use Ethernet or want to listen with two compatible pairs of AirPods or Beats headphones. “Silent” does not necessarily mean there is no sound: ARTE describes a silent film with musical accompaniment.
Who should consider these devices?
Film fans who want to keep the noise down
If you want to hear the musical accompaniment without disturbing your housemates, check how private listening works and whether one or two people can listen at the same time. Apple Support describes audio sharing with up to two compatible pairs of AirPods or Beats headphones; Roku Support Germany explains a headphone mode that uses an app and a mobile device.
People looking for silent films
If you’re after a particular classic or a collection, first check that you can access the title, find out which app you need and see whether you’ll have to sign in. filmfriend offers a silent film collection and says you’ll need a library card or university account to sign in.
Shared houses with unreliable Wi-Fi
If your TV’s connection is unreliable, a usable network connection may influence your choice. Google lists Ethernet for the Google TV Streamer (4K); on the 3rd-generation Apple TV 4K, Ethernet is available only on the Wi-Fi + Ethernet model.
What should you look for when buying?
An app on your existing smart TV
A good fit if: the film you want and the app you need already work on your TV, and you have a suitable way to listen privately.
Bear in mind: app support and headphone features vary by TV model.
A compact HDMI stick
A good fit if: your TV is missing the app, you have an HDMI port and power supply, and the Wi-Fi signal is strong enough where the TV is set up.
Bear in mind: private listening depends on the model; the headphone mode described by Roku requires a mobile device on the same Wi-Fi network.
A separate streaming box
A good fit if: you need a usable Ethernet connection or want to listen together using compatible headphones.
Bear in mind: check how much space it needs and whether you’ll have to buy an HDMI cable separately.
First, check whether you can access the film you want on your TV. Then compare headphone options, connections and what’s included in the box.
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Listen to the film music privately |
Check headphone compatibility and whether one or two people can listen at the same time. |
If we want to listen together, I need a headphone setup that works with our devices. Around 31% of consumers prioritise private listening. |
| Access to the film you want |
Check the specific title, whether it’s available in Germany, any sign-in requirements and which app you’ll need. |
If I’m looking for a particular classic, I want to check I can access it before choosing a device. Around 31% of consumers put access to the film first. |
| Connection to the TV |
Check whether Wi-Fi is enough or whether you can actually connect an Ethernet cable where the TV is set up. |
If the Wi-Fi is unreliable, I need a connection I can really use by the TV. Around 19% of consumers prioritise a network connection. |
| Connections and setup |
Check for a free HDMI input, a power supply and what’s included with the exact model. |
If my TV has limited space or connections, I want to know in advance what I can plug into it. Around 13% of consumers focus first on setting up their device by the TV. |
| Extra costs for access and accessories |
Check whether you already have library or university access and whether the HDMI accessories you need are included. |
If I want to avoid extra costs, I’ll check access and what’s included before buying. Around 6% of consumers put potential additional costs first. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming “silent film” means “no sound”
A silent film can still have an audible musical accompaniment. ARTE specifically describes one of its silent films as having musical accompaniment.
Check the sound in the film you want to watch, and decide whether you’ll be listening through headphones alone or with someone else. Check that the specific device supports your chosen setup and is compatible with your headphones.
-
Buying a stick just because you’ve found a film collection
A collection doesn’t necessarily mean you can watch a particular film in Germany or access the service.
Check the title and sign-in requirements before choosing a device. filmfriend says you’ll need a library card or university account to access the service.
-
Assuming similarly named Xiaomi sticks are the same model
According to Xiaomi, the Xiaomi TV Stick 4K (2nd Gen) uses Google TV, while the older, similarly named model runs Android TV 11.
Check the generation and operating system in the description for the exact model.
-
Assuming an HDMI cable comes with a streaming box
Google says a certified HDMI 2.1 cable for the Google TV Streamer (4K) is sold separately. Apple also says a separate HDMI cable is required for the 3rd-generation Apple TV 4K.
Before ordering, check what comes with the exact model and whether you already have a suitable cable.
If you don’t have a suitable cable, you may need to buy one separately.
Brands to consider
Apple
Worth considering if you want to share audio with up to two compatible pairs of AirPods or Beats headphones.
- Apple Support describes audio sharing on Apple TV 4K.
- This feature isn’t available with any two Bluetooth headphones. On the 3rd-generation Apple TV 4K, Ethernet is available only on the Wi-Fi + Ethernet model; an HDMI cable is required separately.
Google
The Google TV Streamer (4K) is a separate box with an Ethernet port.
- Google lists Ethernet and 32 GB of storage for this model.
- The certified HDMI 2.1 cable is sold separately. The technical specifications don’t tell you whether a particular silent film is available to you.
Roku
The Roku Streaming Stick 4K (Model 3820) is an HDMI player; the Roku app can enable private listening on supported devices.
- Roku Support Germany describes a headphone mode using wired or Bluetooth headphones connected to a mobile device.
- Support depends on the device, so check the exact model. This method requires a mobile device on the same Wi-Fi network.
Xiaomi
The Xiaomi TV Stick 4K (2nd Gen) is an HDMI stick with Google TV.
- Xiaomi lists a power adapter and HDMI extension cable as included.
- According to Xiaomi, the older, similarly named model runs Android TV 11. Take care not to confuse different model generations.
Streaming devices at Joybuy
When browsing streaming devices at Joybuy, compare compact HDMI sticks such as the Roku Streaming Stick 4K (Model 3820) and Xiaomi TV Stick 4K (2nd Gen) with separate boxes such as the Google TV Streamer (4K) and Apple TV 4K (3rd generation). Check that the film and app you want are available, confirm that your headphones work for private listening, and check whether the exact model includes the HDMI cable you need.
Frequently asked questions
Are silent films automatically silent when you play them?
No. ARTE specifically describes one of its silent films as having musical accompaniment. Check the sound in the film you want to watch and use a suitable private listening option if needed.
Can I watch filmfriend simply by mirroring my phone screen?
No. filmfriend says it doesn’t support standard screen mirroring because of copyright protection. Instead, the service describes using Cast or AirPlay with supported devices on the same Wi-Fi network.
What should I check before setting up by the TV and connecting to Wi-Fi?
Check for a free HDMI input, a power supply and a reliable connection where the device will be set up. To use Ethernet, you’ll need a working cable connection there; the certified HDMI 2.1 cable for the Google TV Streamer (4K) is sold separately.
Do I need a separate film subscription for filmfriend?
filmfriend says you’ll need a library card or university account and password to sign in. Before buying a device, check that your own account gives you access.
What requirements apply to Wi-Fi or Bluetooth streaming devices in Germany?
Radio equipment placed on the market in the EU must meet the applicable requirements. For products covered by the rules, the Federal Network Agency says CE marking is required before they are placed on the market. This general requirement doesn’t confirm that a specific product listing is compliant. The Federation of German Consumer Organisations also warns against unlicensed streaming portals.