Editors sharing a room
If you listen back to sections repeatedly, background noise can get in the way. Closed-back headphones can also help reduce sound leakage, although how well they do so depends on the model and the fit.
If you work alongside others in a student room, want to reduce background noise or monitor your guitar recording through your headphones, a well-fitting closed-back pair is the obvious place to start. In a quiet room on your own, open-back or semi-open models are also worth considering, as long as sound leakage won’t be a problem. Check the fit and compatibility with your device for each model: the design alone guarantees neither neutral playback nor that you’ll hear every editing flaw.
If you listen back to sections repeatedly, background noise can get in the way. Closed-back headphones can also help reduce sound leakage, although how well they do so depends on the model and the fit.
If you monitor through your headphones while recording, low sound leakage is important to help prevent the microphone picking up the headphone signal. RTINGS.com and Audio-Technica both cite low sound leakage as a relevant factor when recording.
In a quiet room, you can also consider more open designs when making editing and sound decisions. Bear in mind that more sound from your surroundings may get in, and more sound from your headphones may leak out.
A good fit if: You edit alongside other people, have distracting background noise or monitor through your headphones while recording guitar.
Trade-off: This design can reduce sound leakage and background noise, but the actual level of isolation also depends on the fit and model. RTINGS.com describes closed-back headphones as more suitable for recording than open-back models.
A good fit if: You mostly work on your recordings alone in a quiet setting, and sound leakage won’t bother anyone.
Trade-off: You may hear more sound from your surroundings, and sound from your headphones may leak out more easily. This design is therefore less suited to monitoring right next to a recording microphone.
A good fit if: You work in a quiet listening space and can judge for yourself whether the sound leakage and background noise are acceptable.
Trade-off: “Semi-open” doesn’t automatically mean enough isolation for a shared room or microphone recording. Don’t treat this design as equivalent to closed-back headphones.
| Criteria | What to look for when buying | Who should pay particular attention |
|---|---|---|
| Isolation and sound leakage | Check the design and fit on your own head; when recording with a microphone, consider how much headphone sound reaches the mic. | If I’m recording in a shared room, I want to reduce distracting background noise and keep as much headphone sound as possible out of the microphone. Around 36 % of consumers would make isolation and low sound leakage their top buying priority. |
| Judging edits and guitar tone | Compare familiar sections of your own recording at the same, moderate volume; assess the sound of the specific model rather than relying on its design category alone. | When I need to judge small changes to an edit or guitar tone, I want playback that makes it easy to compare my own sections. Around 29 % of consumers would put this ability to assess edits first. |
| Comfort during longer sessions | Try the fit and clamping force over a realistic listening period if possible; consider whether suitable replacement ear pads are available. | When listening back repeatedly or for longer periods, I want headphones that fit my head and have comfortable ear pads. About 21 % of consumers would make long-term comfort their top buying priority. |
| Connection, cable and care | Check that the impedance and plug match your headphone output; consider cable length, routing and any adaptors you’ll need. | If I want to use my headphones with my existing laptop or audio interface, I want to choose a connection and cable length that work with my desk setup. Approximately 14 % of consumers would consider device connectivity and care first. |
If you share a room or use a recording microphone, background noise and sound leaking from your headphones may still be an issue.
Choose based on your listening space and recording setup. Test how much sound leaks from the specific headphones at your workstation.
Impedance alone doesn’t tell you how loud a pair of headphones will be with your existing device. Focusrite points out that higher-impedance headphones generally need more power from the headphone output.
Check the exact model variant against the output on your laptop or audio interface before planning to buy any extra accessories.
An unsuitable headphone output may make your intended setup harder to use, but extra hardware isn’t always necessary.
WELT.de placed the Yamaha HPH-MT5 at the top of its comparison list. HIFI.DE described the Audio-Technica ATH-M50x as having a pronounced bass emphasis. These model-specific comments are no substitute for assessing your own recordings.
Use comparison lists as a starting point for potential options, then listen to familiar sections yourself at a moderate volume.
The closed-back DT 770 PRO and open-back DT 990 PRO represent two different designs. Both models are available in several impedance variants.
The closed-back ATH-M40x may be worth considering if a detachable cable and different cable options suit your workspace.
The semi-open K240 Studio and closed-back K271 MKII are different options for quiet listening spaces and for monitoring and mixing.
The MDR-7506 is a wired pair of headphones in Sony’s studio range.
The closed-back HPH-MT5 is a monitoring option if you’re looking for isolation and a foldable design.
If you monitor through your headphones while recording, closed-back headphones are the more obvious place to start because they leak less sound. Check your microphone setup to see whether headphone sound is being picked up in the recording; open-back models provide less isolation.
Not necessarily. Higher impedance can require more power from the output, but the volume you can achieve also depends on the headphones and the specific output. Check the exact variant against the specifications for your laptop or audio interface.
Listen at a moderate volume and take your total listening time into account. The World Health Organization gives an average of 80 dB for up to 40 hours per week as an example; at higher levels, the corresponding safe listening time is considerably shorter. This is general listening advice, not a product feature.
Look for replacement ear pads for the exact model variant. If there’s a defect, statutory consumer rights are separate from a voluntary guarantee; the Verbraucherzentrale explains this distinction for consumers in Germany.