Who is this buying decision relevant to?

Groups sitting at an angle to the screen

If you’re not all sitting directly in front of the screen, check the connection and visibility from your actual seats. For Joy-Con connection issues, Nintendo recommends, among other things, moving closer to the console; this doesn’t guarantee a particular range from any given seating angle.

Fans of motion-controlled mini-games

If a game requires individually held controllers or specific motion features, the controllers need to be compatible with your console generation. Nintendo also advises attaching the wrist straps when using Joy-Con wirelessly and individually.

Hosts inviting extra players

If you’re inviting more guests, count the inputs required by the specific game before buying extra controllers. For local play on one console, Nintendo specifies one Joy-Con per person for Super Mario Party; supported games may also accept input from smartphones.

What should you look for when buying?

Joy-Con for individual use

A good choice if: The game requires individual Joy-Con or their motion features, and you need additional inputs.

Keep in mind: Count the controllers and straps you already have; older Joy-Con can’t be charged while attached to the Switch 2.

Joy-Con 2 for Switch 2

A good choice if: You need extra controllers for individual use with a Switch 2, or a compatible game supports mouse mode.

Keep in mind: Joy-Con 2 don’t work with the original Switch and don’t have an IR Motion Camera.

Wireless gamepad

A good choice if: The specific game supports button controls and the gamepad you choose works with it. Nintendo confirms that every mini-game in Mario Party Superstars supports button controls with the Switch Pro Controller.

Keep in mind: Motion controls alone don’t prove that a gamepad can replace individual Joy-Con or any additional features the game requires.

Smartphone instead of an extra controller

A good choice if: The game you’ve chosen supports smartphone or browser input. Nintendo offers a smartphone mode for Everybody 1-2-Switch!; in Jackbox, players join through a browser using a room code.

Keep in mind: Everybody 1-2-Switch! requires an internet connection in smartphone mode, and everyone needs to be able to see the shared game screen.

Priority What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Connection and visibility Test the controller from the intended seat; position the console in an open space and, if the connection drops, check the distance and possible sources of interference. If we’re sitting to one side, I want to check from my seat that the connection works and I can see the game screen. Around 36% of consumers say this setup is their main priority.
Game compatibility Check the game mode, console generation, supported controllers and any required sensor features. If I want to play a particular mini-game, I want to be sure it supports the controls I need. Around 29% of consumers put this compatibility first.
Enough inputs for everyone Count the players and controllers you already have, then check the player and input rules for the game mode. If extra guests are joining in, I want to provide suitable controls for everyone. Around 21% of consumers say having inputs for more players is their main concern.
Buying and charging Check the devices you already own, the charging options you’ll need and whether a smartphone mode will work before buying extra controllers. If I want to avoid unnecessary device or charging purchases, I first check what I already have and whether a different game mode will do. Around 14% of consumers have this as their main concern.

Common misconceptions

  • Motion controls don’t automatically make a gamepad a Joy-Con replacement

    A gamepad may have motion sensors and still not replace individually held Joy-Con or the IR features required by a game.

    Before buying, check the specific game mode and its control requirements.

    If a mode requires individual Joy-Con, buying an unsuitable gamepad could mean you need to make another purchase.

  • Joy-Con 2 aren’t compatible with the original Switch

    Nintendo designed Joy-Con 2 for Switch 2. Older Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be charged while attached to the console.

    Check which console generation you have and, if you’re using older Joy-Con, make sure you know how you’ll charge them.

    To charge older Joy-Con with a Switch 2, you may need an original Switch or suitable charging accessories.

  • Smartphone mini-games don’t always need extra controllers

    Some games accept input through a smartphone or browser, but this isn’t an option in every game. The smartphone mode in Everybody 1-2-Switch! requires an internet connection.

    Choose your game and mode first, then count how many additional input devices you actually need.

  • A handheld attachment isn’t necessarily a wireless controller

    HORI describes the Pikachu Black & Gold Split Pad Pro as non-wireless and for handheld mode only.

    Check whether the specific version works wirelessly on its own or needs to be attached to the console.

Useful brands to know

Nintendo

Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 are relevant for Switch mini-games played with individually held or motion-controlled controllers. The right option depends on the game and your console generation.

  • Nintendo lists motion sensors for the original Joy-Con; a Joy-Con 2 set includes wrist straps.
  • Joy-Con 2 don’t work with the original Switch and don’t have an IR Motion Camera.

PowerA

According to the manufacturer, the Enhanced Wireless Controller Rechargeable is a wireless gamepad for supported Switch games.

  • PowerA lists a rechargeable battery, motion controls and two mappable buttons for this model.
  • PowerA says it doesn’t have HD Rumble, IR or amiibo NFC. These specifications don’t show that it can replace an individually held Joy-Con in specific mini-games.

8BitDo

The Ultimate Bluetooth Controller with Charging Dock is a gamepad alternative for supported Switch games.

  • 8BitDo lists motion controls when used with Switch and customisable controls.
  • According to the manufacturer’s Switch instructions, it doesn’t have NFC, an IR camera or HD Rumble. Check the firmware version and whether it’s supported in your specific game.

HORI

The reviewed Split Pad Pro for Pikachu Black & Gold is an example of a handheld attachment, not a controller that can be used separately for a group playing together.

  • HORI describes the controls on this version as being for handheld mode.
  • According to HORI, this model is non-wireless and doesn’t have motion controls, HD Rumble, NFC or an IR camera.

Joybuy products for party mini-games

This selection includes Joy-Con 2 for Switch 2 and wireless gamepads whose product details state that they’re compatible with Switch. The key thing is whether the specific game and mode support the controller you choose.

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2, 2-pack, Blue/Light Yellow

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2, 2-pack, Blue/Light Yellow

For local multiplayer modes on Switch 2 that support individually used Joy-Con.

The set includes one left and one right Joy-Con 2, plus two wrist straps. The product description lists motion controls and a mouse mode for compatible games. Not compatible with the original Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy
NAXSIR Wireless Gamepad for Switch, Bluetooth, Model 04-66666666

NAXSIR Wireless Gamepad for Switch, Model 04-66666666

A gamepad option for Switch games that support this wireless model.

The product title lists Bluetooth and Switch compatibility. Check whether your chosen mini-game supports a gamepad; wireless connectivity alone doesn’t guarantee a reliable connection from every seat.

View at Joybuy
Gaming Controller with Dual Vibration and Gyro for Switch and PC

Gaming Controller with Dual Vibration and Gyro for Switch and PC

For Switch games that support this gamepad; check the control requirements for the specific mode.

The product title lists Switch and PC compatibility, as well as gyro and dual vibration. These details don’t show that the gamepad can replace individual Joy-Con or specialist sensor features.

View at Joybuy
BIGBIG WON Rainbow 3 Wireless Controller for Switch 2 and other platforms

BIGBIG WON Rainbow 3 Wireless Controller

For Switch or Switch 2 games that support this wireless gamepad.

The product title lists Switch 2 and other platforms, and specifies a 6-axis gyroscope. Check that the specific game mode supports it before relying on a particular type of input.

View at Joybuy
BEITONG KP70 Elite Wireless Gaming Controller

BEITONG KP70 Elite Wireless Gaming Controller

For Switch or Switch 2 games that support this wireless gamepad.

The product title lists Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, as well as six programmable buttons and haptic trigger feedback. Check whether these features are useful in the game you want to play.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one full-size gamepad enough for Mario Party Superstars?

Yes. Nintendo confirms that Mario Party Superstars supports button controls and that every mini-game can be played with the Nintendo Switch Pro Controller. Don’t assume this also applies to Super Mario Party or other titles without checking first.

What should I check first if my Joy-Con stop responding from a seat to one side?

Check the charge level and button mapping, move closer if necessary, and position the Switch away from potential sources of interference. For motion controls that aren’t working properly, Nintendo also recommends calibration under ‘Controllers and Sensors’.

Do I need to attach wrist straps when playing with detached Joy-Con?

Nintendo instructs users to attach the wrist straps and fasten them around their wrists when using Joy-Con wirelessly and individually. This manufacturer guidance applies to that type of use, not necessarily to every gamepad.

Can I use older Joy-Con with Switch 2, and charge them there?

Older Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but they can’t be attached to the console or charged there. Nintendo lists an original Switch or suitable charging accessories as charging options.

What are my rights when buying a controller online in Germany?

For a typical distance sale from a business seller, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel, starting from delivery; exceptions may apply in specific cases. Your Europe, the European Union’s consumer portal, states that faulty goods are covered by a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the seller. This is separate from any additional manufacturer’s guarantee.