Who is this selection for?

Theatre teams with a growing video archive

If you store recordings of several productions in one place, work out how much space you need for your existing archive and future performances for each separately stored copy.

Mobile production teams

A portable hard drive that doesn’t need a separate power adapter can make transferring files at different venues easier. Check the connections and file system on the computers you use beforehand.

People responsible for sensitive recordings

If your recordings show identifiable people, you’ll need to manage access and permitted uses. For an encrypted copy, you’ll also need a secure way to manage and recover the key.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out how much space you need for each separately stored copy. Then choose between a desktop model and a portable USB hard drive. If your recordings show identifiable people, you should also plan access controls and key management.

Consideration What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Capacity for a growing archive Add up the file sizes of existing performances, allow for future growth and calculate the space needed for each independently stored copy. As our archive grows with each production, I want to allow enough space for existing and future recordings. Around 36% of consumers would make capacity their top consideration.
Independent backup Allow enough storage for separate copies and keep them in separate locations; test recovery using sample files. I want to be able to restore recordings if a storage device or its storage location fails. Around 29% of consumers would prioritise keeping an independent copy that can be checked.
Portability and connections Check the USB connection, cable, power requirements and file system against the computers you actually use. When transferring files between a venue and my workplace, I need to know I can connect and power the drive at both locations. Around 21% of consumers would make portability their main concern.
Access protection Clarify who is responsible, the permitted purpose and who is authorised to access the files. If you use encryption, plan how to restore the copy too. When recordings show identifiable people, I want to control access to the files and clarify how they can be used. Around 14% of consumers would prioritise protection against unauthorised access.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming one large hard drive is a secure archive

    A single hard drive is still just one copy. A fault, accidental overwriting or damage to its storage location could put your archive at risk.

    Plan for an additional copy stored separately, and test whether you can restore the recordings using sample files.

    An additional copy requires extra storage space and a separate storage location.

  • Confusing USB bus speed with copying speed

    A stated USB transfer rate doesn’t automatically tell you how quickly the hard drive will actually copy files.

    Don’t treat interface specifications as a guaranteed sustained performance when copying long recordings of performances.

  • Switching between portable and desktop models without checking compatibility

    A desktop model may need mains power, while a portable model’s file system may matter for the computer you’re using.

    Before buying, check where you’ll use the drive, its connections, power supply and file system.

    Depending on your setup, you may need a compatible connection, mains power or to reformat the drive.

Key brands at a glance

Western Digital

Elements Desktop is a desktop range, while My Book also includes desktop models with higher-capacity options.

  • According to Western Digital, the Elements Desktop model reviewed, WDBWLG0080HBK-EESN, offers 8 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and a two-year warranty.
  • These specifications don’t guarantee how long archived data will last or make the drive suitable as your only copy.

Seagate

The Expansion Desktop range is designed for local storage at a permanent workstation.

  • According to Seagate, the model reviewed, STKP8000400, offers 8 TB.
  • The model needs a power adapter. Any data recovery services apply only under the terms of the relevant product version and are no substitute for a backup.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable range for transferring files and storing them locally.

  • Toshiba’s European product page lists the HDTB540EK3CA model as offering 4 TB, a USB-A to Micro-B connection and preformatted NTFS.
  • Toshiba says the drive needs to be reformatted for use with macOS. It isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution for larger archives.

Verbatim

Store ’n’ Go is a portable hard drive range powered via USB.

  • According to the manufacturer’s German website, the 4 TB model reviewed, 53223, doesn’t need an additional power supply and connects via USB 3.0.
  • The model is formatted as NTFS when it has more than 2 TB of capacity. The stated transfer rate refers to USB bus speed, not the hard drive’s measured copying speed.

Joybuy products for local theatre archives

The models below are suitable for storing performance files locally, using either portable USB hard drives or a desktop hard drive. You’ll need an additional storage device to keep an independent backup.

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

This portable model is a good choice if you want to transport performance files between a venue and your workplace.

5 TB, 2.5-inch casing and USB-C; the stated weight is 240 g.

You’ll need an additional storage device to keep an independent backup.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

This portable model is a good choice if you want to transport performance files between a venue and your workplace.

6 TB, 2.5-inch casing and USB-C; the stated weight is 240 g.

You’ll need an additional storage device to keep an independent backup.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

This portable model is a good choice if you want to transport performance files between a venue and your workplace.

4 TB, 2.5-inch casing and USB-C; the stated weight is 240 g.

You’ll need an additional storage device to keep an independent backup.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 2 TB, USB-C, exFAT

WD Elements Portable 2 TB, USB-C

This portable model is an option for storing files locally or transporting them between workplaces.

2 TB, 2.5-inch casing, USB-C, exFAT and USB-powered; the stated weight is 131 g.

You’ll need an additional storage device to keep an independent backup.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 8 TB, USB 3.0

WD Elements Desktop 8 TB

This desktop model is a good choice for an archive that stays mainly at a permanent workstation.

8 TB, 3.5-inch casing, USB 3.0 and an external power adapter.

You’ll need an additional storage device to keep an independent backup.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external hard drive enough for a theatre archive?

If you want your recordings to survive a drive failure, you shouldn’t rely on just one copy. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two storage media in separate locations. The German Federal Office for Information Security says that RAID mirroring doesn’t count as an independent backup. These are archiving and IT security recommendations, not a blanket legal requirement for a specific number of storage devices.

What should I check before using the drive with Windows and Mac computers?

Check the file system of the specific model and the USB connection you need. Verbatim says its Store ’n’ Go drives with more than 2 TB are preformatted as NTFS and need to be reformatted for use with macOS. Back up any existing data before reformatting a drive.

What additional costs or considerations should I allow for?

An additional copy stored separately needs extra storage space. For desktop models, you should also consider where to keep the drive and how to power it.

Does storing recordings without the cloud automatically mean I can film and publish them later?

No. The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Rhineland-Palatinate notes that processing photos of identifiable people requires consent or another legal basis. Under § 77 UrhG, performers have the exclusive right to record their performance on visual or audio media; the provision is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice. § 22 KunstUrhG sets out a consent requirement for distributing or publicly displaying images. The rights and exceptions that apply in a particular case can’t be determined by the choice of storage medium.