Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

People responsible for recordings of one-off performances

If a performance cannot be repeated, plan for a separate, verifiable backup as well as your NAS. The BSI recommends storing physical backup media in a different location.

Teams with a growing performance archive

If you regularly add new video files, plan the usable storage you need, the available drive bays and potential expansion options before buying. Synology lists a separate expansion unit as an option for adding bays to the DS925+.

Editing and documentation teams

If several authorised people need local access to your material, suitable network connections and manageable access permissions are important. The BSI describes access rights based on the need-to-know principle as an advantage of network drives.

What should you look for when buying?

Two drive bays

A good fit if: You can store a modest archive in one place and the planned usable capacity is enough for your current files and future growth.

The trade-off: There are fewer internal bays for adding drives later, and you will still need a separate backup.

Four drive bays

A good fit if: You regularly add new performances or several people transfer large files over your local network.

The trade-off: More bays or faster network connections do not determine the usable storage capacity or the actual transfer rate.

Requirement What to check before buying Who is this particularly important to?
Recoverability Plan for a physical backup medium stored separately, and test that you can restore your files. The BSI recommends keeping such media in a different location. If a one-off performance cannot be recorded again, I want to keep an additional local copy. Around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to recover their recordings.
Archive growth Work out the size of your existing files and how much you expect the archive to grow; calculate usable capacity using the compatible drives you plan to install. If new performances are added regularly, I want to plan the bays and usable storage capacity to match that growth. Around 27% of consumers put archive growth first.
Local transfers Check how the NAS, switch and workstations’ connections will work together with your actual workflow. If several workstations use large video files locally, I want to choose the whole network setup to suit my needs. Around 20% of consumers prioritise file transfers over their local network.
Restricted team access Check whether you can manage user and folder permissions, and decide who is allowed to read, edit or delete files. If recordings are intended for specific team members only, I want to restrict access according to each person’s responsibilities. Around 20% of consumers focus on controlled access permissions.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming the number of bays equals usable archive capacity

    Four bays alone do not tell you how much storage your drive configuration will actually make available. According to Synology, adding more bays to the Synology DS925+ requires a separate expansion unit.

    Work out how much space your existing original files need and how much you expect them to grow before choosing between two and four bays.

    Allow for the compatible drives you need and, if applicable, a separate expansion unit.

  • Treating drive redundancy as a complete backup

    A fault, user error or damage at the shared location could put your archive files at risk. The BSI recommends keeping physical backup media separately.

    As well as your NAS, plan for a local copy that is regularly checked and kept at a different location. Test that you can restore your files.

    A separate backup medium and time for backup and recovery tests need to be part of your workflow.

  • Assuming cloud-free storage means setup can be completed entirely offline

    Storing an archive locally does not automatically mean that the initial setup, or a particular step, can be completed without an internet connection.

    If you need to use the NAS entirely offline during setup too, check this for the specific model and software version.

  • Assuming that buying a local NAS settles recording and usage rights

    Where you store a recording does not determine whether it is permissible to record a performance and keep it permanently. Under § 77 UrhG, performers have exclusive rights to the recording and reproduction of their performance. If people are identifiable, you should also check the relevant data protection requirements.

    Before archiving recordings, check that you have the necessary permissions and record the purpose, who will have access and how the recordings are intended to be used.

Which brands are worth considering?

Synology

The DS224+ is a two-bay option, while the DS925+ offers four bays for an archive that may grow.

  • According to Synology, the DS925+ has two 2.5GbE ports.
  • Adding bays requires a separate expansion unit. Check drive compatibility and whether you need an expansion unit for your specific setup.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G combines two drive bays with two 2.5GbE ports, while the TS-464 is a four-bay option.

  • The models listed offer different numbers of bays to suit different archive plans.
  • According to QNAP, neither model includes HDDs, so you will need to budget for the drives separately.

ASUSTOR

The AS5404T is a four-bay option for a growing archive or several local workstations.

  • According to the official model specifications, it has four drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports.
  • These specifications do not guarantee a particular transfer rate in a theatre setup; take the rest of your network equipment into account too.

TerraMaster

The F4-425 Pro is a four-bay option if you are considering a 5GbE local network connection.

  • TerraMaster lists two 5GbE ports for the F4-425 Pro.
  • Check the processor and memory specifications for the exact version on offer before taking these features into account.

Joybuy products for local archives

This selection includes Synology NAS models with two, four and eight drive bays for archiving theatre recordings locally.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ with four drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS

If you are planning an archive with four internal drive bays, this model offers that configuration.

Four drive bays; two 2.5GbE ports; expandable to up to nine bays.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ with eight drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-Bay NAS

If you are planning for eight drive bays for a larger archive, this model offers that configuration.

Eight drive bays; two 2.5GbE ports; optional 10GbE and up to 360 TB listed in the product name.

View at Joybuy
Synology DS225+ with two drive bays

Synology DS225+ 2-Bay NAS

If the planned usable capacity is enough for a modest archive, a two-bay model could suit your needs.

Two drive bays; one 2.5GbE port and one Gigabit Ethernet port; RAID 0, RAID 1 and JBOD listed. Described as a diskless enclosure; drives are not listed as included.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a NAS replace a second backup of my performance recordings?

No. The BSI recommends backing up important files and keeping physical backup media in a different location. Also test that the copy is readable and that you can restore it.

How do I set up a local archiving workflow?

Start by transferring a test recording, assign access permissions according to each person’s responsibilities, create a separate local backup and test that you can restore it. If the initial setup must also be completed without an internet connection, check this for the specific model and software version.

What should I budget for in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Allow for compatible drives and a separate backup medium. According to QNAP, HDDs are not included with the QNAP TS-264-8G.

Can I keep a theatre performance in a permanent archive simply because the files are stored on my own NAS?

No. Where the files are stored does not remove the need to check your rights. Under § 77 UrhG, performers have exclusive rights to the recording and reproduction of their performance. If people can be identified, you should also check that you have an appropriate legal basis under data protection law for the specific purpose of processing; consent is one possible basis, but not the only one.

Do I need to inform people if recognisable recordings are stored?

Where the GDPR applies, you have information obligations unless a legal exemption applies. The obligations for a particular recording workflow depend on the processing involved.