Who are the different styles best suited to?

Listeners in noisy trains

You want to follow the commentary without turning the volume up too high to overcome the sound of the train. So look for a comfortable fit and test how clearly you can hear speech with ANC on. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to help you avoid listening unnecessarily loudly in noisy environments.

Travellers with important connections

You want to listen to the commentary, but also be able to pause quickly and let in ambient sounds when you need to hear announcements or talk to someone. Deutsche Bahn notes that loud listening, including through headphones, is not welcome in ICE quiet areas.

Cricket fans travelling light

You want to save space in your luggage, so you’re comparing well-fitting ANC earbuds with over-ear models. With earbuds, both a comfortable fit and the size of the charging case matter.

What should you look for when buying?

The key question is whether the headphones make voices clear during your train journey and are easy to pause when needed. Then compare fit, size and battery life against the length of your journey.

What matters to you What to check before buying Who might prioritise this?
Speech clarity Try listening to spoken audio at a moderate volume; assess the fit and ANC separately. If I want to understand the commentary despite the sound of the train, I test voices rather than relying on a general ANC claim. Around 31% of consumers put speech clarity first.
Hearing announcements Before your journey, check how quickly you can pause playback and switch to ambient mode. If I need to get off or change trains soon, I want to pause the commentary quickly and hear what’s happening around me. Around 25% of consumers prioritise being able to hear announcements.
Comfort Test the fit for as long as you’d normally listen; with earbuds, check which eartip sizes suit you. If I want to listen comfortably on a longer journey, I check that the headband, cushions or eartips feel comfortable. Around 19% of consumers prioritise long-term comfort.
Pack size Consider the headphones and case together; with earbuds, don’t overlook the fit in favour of a general ANC claim. If I’m short on luggage space, I compare the overall size of each style, including its case, with that of over-ear headphones. Around 13% of consumers prioritise a compact pack size.
Battery life and costs Compare battery life with ANC on; for earbuds, distinguish between battery life per charge and battery life with the case. If I want to match battery life to my journey and assess extra services separately, I check the terms of each offer. Around 12% of consumers prioritise battery life and cost planning.

Which buying decisions could lead you astray?

  • Assuming an ANC claim guarantees clear commentary

    Fit, the type of train noise and your own hearing all affect how clearly you can hear the commentary. A CHIP review found that the JBL Tour One M3 struggled with very low frequencies.

    Try listening to spoken audio at a moderate volume, and only apply specifications to the specific model they refer to.

  • Relying on ambient mode alone for important announcements

    Ambient mode lets sounds through, but commentary that’s still playing may compete with an announcement.

    Before your journey, try pausing playback and switching to ambient mode. Pause the commentary when you need to hear an important announcement.

  • Comparing battery life across different operating modes directly

    Manufacturers sometimes quote different battery life figures depending on the ANC and audio modes. Bose, for example, distinguishes between battery life with and without 360-degree sound.

    Compare the figures for the mode you actually plan to use. With earbuds, also make sure you distinguish battery life per charge from battery life with the charging case.

  • Confusing optional extra cover with your statutory rights

    Your statutory rights when goods are faulty apply regardless of any voluntary guarantee or additional cover on offer.

    Compare what an extra cover plan includes, and what it excludes, with the rights you already have. Your Europe, the European Union’s information portal, explains consumer legal guarantees.

Which brands are worth considering?

Sony

The WH-1000XM6 is an over-ear ANC model with ambient mode and multipoint connectivity, suited to longer listening sessions.

  • Sony quotes up to 30 hours of music playback with noise cancelling switched on for the WH-1000XM6.
  • The manufacturer’s claim and the available features don’t prove that every train announcement will be clear. Check the fit, too.

Bose

The 2nd Generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones are an over-ear model with adjustable ANC and ambient mode.

  • Bose quotes up to 30 hours of battery life, or 23 hours with 360-degree sound.
  • These are manufacturer figures for different operating modes, not a test of how clearly you can hear cricket commentary.

JBL

The Tour One M3 is an over-ear model where you’ll need to weigh up fit, sound and battery life against how well its ANC handles train noise.

  • CHIP gave the sound and fit a positive rating.
  • CHIP’s model review found that the ANC struggled with very low frequencies. JBL notes that some versions are sold without a Smart Tx transmitter, so check what’s included.

Sennheiser

The MOMENTUM 4 and MOMENTUM 5 Wireless are over-ear models. Make sure you check the battery life and features for the right generation.

  • Sennheiser quotes up to 57 hours of battery life with ANC on for the MOMENTUM 5, as well as a transparency mode.
  • This manufacturer claim for the MOMENTUM 5 is not a test result and doesn’t describe the features of the MOMENTUM 4.

soundcore

The Liberty 4 NC are a compact ANC earbud option; the Space One Pro is an over-ear alternative.

  • soundcore quotes up to 40 hours of music playback with ANC on for the Space One Pro, under the stated test conditions.
  • The manufacturer says that extra features can reduce battery life. The advertised noise reduction of the Liberty 4 NC doesn’t prove how well they’ll work on any particular train journey.

Joybuy products for train journeys

The following Joybuy products include over-ear ANC headphones and ANC earbuds, including open-ear and wired styles.

1MORE HQ51 SonoFlow Pro, Global, Mocha Brown

1MORE HQ51 SonoFlow Pro, Global, Mocha Brown

An option if you prefer over-ear ANC headphones for longer listening sessions.

The description mentions memory foam ear cushions and Bluetooth.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Wireless (2nd Gen), Rosewood Mauve

Bose QuietComfort Wireless (2nd Gen), Rosewood Mauve

An over-ear option if you want ANC and a mode that lets in ambient sounds.

The description mentions Quiet and Aware modes, physical controls, a case and soft ear cushions. The product title specifies Bluetooth 5.3, USB-C and 24 hours of battery life.

View at Joybuy
AirPods 5 open-ear earbuds with Active Noise Cancellation

AirPods 5 open-ear earbuds with Active Noise Cancellation

An option if you’re looking for an open-ear earbud design with ANC and a way to switch between noise-control modes.

The product title specifies an open-ear design and Active Noise Cancellation. The description mentions a transparency mode, a button for switching modes and pausing playback with the Digital Crown.

View at Joybuy
Sennheiser MOMENTUM 5 Wireless over-ear headphones

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 5 Wireless over-ear headphones

An option for longer listening sessions if you prefer closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC.

Sennheiser quotes up to 57 hours of playback with ANC on. The product title specifies Bluetooth 5.4, a closed-back design and a replaceable battery; the description also mentions a transparency mode and playback pause.

View at Joybuy
Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds, Dewdrop Mint

Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds, Dewdrop Mint

A wired earbud option if you want to use ANC and ambient mode on the go.

The description mentions Quiet and Aware modes, USB-C audio, S, M and L eartips, and an in-line remote with pause and mode buttons.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to switch ANC off completely to hear an announcement?

Not necessarily: ambient mode can let surrounding sounds through. Pause the commentary when an announcement matters, as ambient mode doesn’t guarantee that you’ll hear it clearly.

How can I listen more safely on a long journey?

The World Health Organization recommends keeping the volume low, taking listening breaks and using well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones so that background noise doesn’t tempt you to turn the volume up. Its guideline of 80 dB for up to 40 hours a week is health advice, not a blanket product limit.

Can I listen to cricket commentary through headphones in an ICE quiet area?

Deutsche Bahn says that loud listening, including through headphones, is not welcome in ICE quiet areas. This is a code of conduct for those areas and not a general statement about every train.

What are my rights when returning an online purchase or dealing with faulty goods?

For a typical distance purchase, you generally have 14 days from delivery to change your mind, although exceptions apply. Faulty goods are also covered by a statutory guarantee of at least two years. Your Europe, the European Union’s information portal, explains these consumer rights; the statutory guarantee is not the same as a voluntary guarantee or extra cover.

How should I look after and use my headphones on the go?

Follow the instructions for your specific model. For the soundcore Space One Pro, the manufacturer notes that the model is neither water- nor sweat-resistant; using extra features can also reduce the stated battery life.