Groove listeners on noisy trains
You listen to individual drum patterns on repeat and don’t want to drown out the train noise simply by turning the volume up.
For repeatedly listening to a drum groove on the train, ANC over-ear headphones are a sensible starting point if the steady rumble bothers you and you find over-ears comfortable. However, ANC won’t reliably block out changing voices. If you want to tap or play along in time, first check that the connection is suitable and consider the latency of your entire playback chain. Compact in-ears save space, while closed-back studio headphones offer passive isolation and don’t need a headphone battery.
You listen to individual drum patterns on repeat and don’t want to drown out the train noise simply by turning the volume up.
You compare your tapping or playing directly with the recording. So check that the connection is suitable and that the whole playback chain feels in sync for your practice.
You want to hear the finer details of a groove on the go without carrying bulky over-ear headphones, so compact in-ears that fit well are important to you.
A good fit if: You want to listen with focus on longer train journeys and find over-ears comfortable.
Things to consider: ANC doesn’t dampen every sound equally well; also check the ambient mode, fit and charging needs.
A good fit if: You want to travel light and listen without needing a headphone battery.
Things to consider: The ear tips and audio output need to be compatible; how well they block sound also depends on the fit.
A good fit if: You want to analyse a recording with a cable and don’t mind carrying a larger model.
Things to consider: Passive isolation isn’t ANC; check the connection and fit in advance.
| Priority | What to check when buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Hear groove details despite train noise | Fit and seal, ANC or passive isolation, and a way to hear what’s happening around you. | If I want to pick out quiet drum details on the train, I don’t want to drown out the noise simply by turning the volume up; around 33 % of consumers therefore put being able to hear clearly despite train noise first. |
| Feedback when tapping along | Check the audio output, any adapter you need and playback with the practice app you actually use. | If you want to tap or play along with the groove in real time, it’s especially important to check that the connection and playback chain work for your practice; around 25 % of consumers prioritise this direct rhythmic feedback. |
| Fit and space in your luggage | Check the fit of the ear tips or ear pads, and consider how easy the model is to pack. | If I have little room for headphones when travelling, I want a compact style that’s comfortable to wear too; around 25 % of consumers put size and fit first. |
| Cost and parts you’ll need | Factor in the complete connection setup, what’s included and any replacement parts you might need. | If you’re weighing up the cost of headphones and any connection accessories you need, you’ll want to know before buying whether they’ll work with your equipment; around 17 % of consumers prioritise the total cost. |
Changing voices can still be audible, even with ANC. Turning the volume up in response won’t necessarily make up for the sound that’s getting through.
Check the fit and seal, and keep the volume moderate rather than relying on a higher volume to compensate for poor isolation.
An included cable is only useful if you can actually connect it to the smartphone, tablet or laptop you use.
Before buying, compare the plug with your device’s output and check whether you’ll need an adapter.
Depending on your device, you may need a compatible audio adapter or a different connection cable.
For the Sony WH-1000XM6, Sony gives different maximum battery life figures with noise cancelling on and off. The figure therefore depends on the mode you choose.
Only compare battery life figures when the same mode is being used, and plan charging opportunities around your journey.
Sony offers ANC over-ears such as the WH-1000XM6 and WH-CH720N, both with an ambient mode.
The wired SE215 is a compact in-ear model with a detachable cable and a choice of ear tips.
The wired, closed-back ATH-M50x is designed for anyone looking for over-ears with passive isolation and a detachable cable.
According to the manufacturer, the MOMENTUM 4 Wireless combines adaptive noise cancellation with a transparency mode.
The QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen) are ANC over-ears with an Aware Mode.
The models below include wireless ANC over-ears and a wired in-ear option for listening on the go. If you want to tap along in real time, pay particular attention to the connection and the latency of your entire playback chain.
No image available
An option for focused listening on the go if you’re looking for wireless over-ears with ANC.
The product title specifies Active Noise Cancellation and a closed-back over-ear design. Check that the transparency mode and connection options suit the way you plan to use them; changing voices may still be audible, even with ANC.
No image available
A wireless over-ear option for repeated listening if you want ANC to dampen train noise.
The product title specifies Bluetooth and noise cancelling. Check that the fit works for you and that you can use a transparency mode if needed; ANC won’t reliably block out changing voices.
No image available
A wired in-ear option if you prefer a compact design for travelling.
Check that the USB-C connection is compatible with your playback device. If you’re tapping along, also consider how in sync the entire playback chain feels with your practice.
No image available
A wireless over-ear option if you want to use ANC for focused listening on the train.
The product title specifies active noise cancelling and a multipoint connection. If you need to hear sounds around you, check the Smart Ambient mode and continue to listen out for announcements.
No image available
A wireless over-ear option for train journeys if you’re looking for noise cancelling and an ambient sound mode.
Sony lists an Ambient Sound mode for the WH-CH720N. Check whether it lets you hear enough of what’s happening around you, and remember to listen out for announcements.
Not as reliably as it does with more consistent, lower-pitched noise. Sony says changing speech is harder to suppress, so it’s also worth checking the fit and passive seal.
Don’t simply turn the volume up to drown out the train. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting or noise-cancelling headphones so you don’t have to turn the volume up unnecessarily in noisy surroundings; at 90 dB, it gives a listening time of four hours per week.
Compare the headphone plug with the audio output on your playback device and check whether you’ll need an adapter. Shure lists a 3.5 mm cable for the SE215; Audio-Technica describes the ATH-M50x as having a detachable cable.
Yes. Deutsche Bahn says that playing music loudly in the quiet area is unwelcome, even through headphones. Make sure other people can’t hear your recording, and keep an eye out for announcements.
If a product is faulty, you have statutory rights against the seller; these are separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee. The Verbraucherzentrale says that online orders generally come with a 14-day cancellation period from delivery. Check the current returns information before placing your order.