Learning harmony vocals on train journeys
If you want to hear a practice track clearly while travelling, you’ll need to decide whether passive isolation is enough or whether ANC is more important for dealing with train noise.
If you already have a separate harmony practice track and want to listen without relying on a headphone battery, closed-back wired studio headphones could suit your needs. If train noise is your main concern, ANC travel headphones may be a better option; check the battery, operating mode and connection to your device. Neither type of headphones can isolate a harmony vocal from a finished mix on its own.
If you want to hear a practice track clearly while travelling, you’ll need to decide whether passive isolation is enough or whether ANC is more important for dealing with train noise.
For listening on the go, check that the cable, plug and, if necessary, an adapter are compatible with your specific device.
A comfortable fit over extended periods, a sensible listening level and consideration for other passengers all matter. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting headphones and, in noisy environments, noise cancelling too, so you don’t need to turn the volume up unnecessarily.
A good fit if: you have a separate practice track and want to listen without relying on a headphone battery.
The trade-off: Passive isolation depends on the fit, and a cable can get in the way at your seat.
A good fit if: train noise often tempts you to turn the volume up.
The trade-off: ANC and other active features may depend on the battery level and operating mode; that doesn’t automatically make travel headphones suitable as studio monitors.
| Buying priority | What to check before buying | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Picking out the harmony vocal | First check whether you have a separate harmony vocal or a suitable practice track; assess the sound using that exact material. | If I can’t pick out the vocal in a finished recording, I need a suitable track rather than just different headphones. Around 29% of consumers put this need first. |
| Managing train noise | Be sure to distinguish passive isolation from ANC and check the fit; with ANC, also check the battery and operating mode. | If train noise makes me keep turning the volume up, I look for a good fit and consider ANC. Around 29% of consumers put this need first. |
| Connectivity and portability | Compare the plug, cable length and what’s included with your device and the space at your seat. | If I want to practise on the way, my headphones should work easily with my mobile phone, tablet or audio player. Around 24% of consumers prioritise ease of use on the go. |
| Comfort and consideration for others | Check the fit during extended use and whether sound leaks out at your usual listening volume. | If I’m practising for longer or sitting in a quiet carriage, I want to listen comfortably without disturbing others. Around 18% of consumers put comfort and consideration for others first. |
The wired studio models described here rely on passive isolation. In a noisy train, that may tempt you to turn up the volume.
Check whether the specific model is listed as having passive isolation or ANC. If you often travel on noisy trains, consider ANC headphones too.
Headphones play back the audio signal as it is, but they won’t automatically separate an individual vocal track.
Before changing headphones solely for this purpose, check whether a separate harmony vocal or suitable practice material is available.
You may need additional material or separate audio processing to practise specific parts.
Wired headphones are only practical on the go if the connection and cable length suit your device and seating position.
Before buying, compare the cable and plug specifications with your audio player, and check whether you’ll need an adapter or a different cable.
The closed-back, wired MDR-M1 is a studio monitor; the WH-1000XM6 is a separate ANC travel option. The two types of model are not interchangeable.
The closed-back DT 700 PRO X is a wired monitoring option if detachable cables and available replacement parts matter to you.
The ATH-M50x is a closed-back, wired monitor headphone that the manufacturer also describes as suitable for use on the go.
The closed-back HD 280 PRO is a wired monitoring option with a foldable design.
AKG describes the closed-back, foldable K371 as studio headphones designed with mobile use in mind.
This selection features ANC travel headphones for listening and practising on the go. For each model, check that the listed connections and listening modes suit your device and how you plan to use it.
No image available
Listed as an ANC option for train journeys; check that it connects to your audio player.
No image available
Listed as ANC travel headphones for a range of listening situations; check whether Bluetooth or the wired connection suits your device.
Listed in the product name: Bluetooth 5.4 and wired listening.
No image available
Listed as an ANC option for train journeys; check that you can practise using the appropriate operating mode and connection.
Listed in the product name: Bluetooth 5.4, a supplied 3.5 mm audio cable and a replaceable battery.
No image available
Listed as an ANC travel option; check whether you’d rather listen wirelessly or use the detachable audio cable on the train.
Listed in the product name: wireless over-ear headphones with noise cancelling.
No image available
Listed as an ANC option for listening on the go; check that the foldable design and Bluetooth suit the way you plan to use it.
Listed in the product name: True Adaptive Noise Cancelling 2.0, Bluetooth 6.0 Multipoint and a stated maximum battery life of 80 hours.
No. Headphones play back the signal as it is; they don’t separate individual vocal tracks by themselves. Use a separate practice track if possible. Vocal separation tools are another option, but results depend on the recording and may not give you a completely clean separation.
Make sure your headphones fit well and consider ANC if the noise persists. The World Health Organization recommends keeping the volume low, being mindful of how long you listen and taking breaks.
Check that the plug on the specific model is compatible with your audio player, and see whether the cable or ear pads can be replaced. The manufacturer lists detachable cables and available replacement parts for the beyerdynamic DT 700 PRO X; Sennheiser says the ear pads on the HD 280 PRO are replaceable.
For a distance purchase, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel, starting from delivery; exceptions and conditions apply. For faulty goods, you generally have a statutory right to a minimum of two years’ legal protection against the seller. This is separate from any voluntary guarantee.
Deutsche Bahn says that listening to music loudly, even through headphones, and other noisy activities are not welcome in the ICE quiet area. Keep the volume low enough not to disturb others; singing along loudly isn’t suitable for the quiet area.