For recording interviews on a noisy train, well-fitting, closed-back headphones with ANC are a sensible starting point. The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy environments. However, ANC alone does not prove that a particular recording will sound clearer. If you need to hear announcements or instructions, make sure pause and ambient mode are easy to access. Deutsche Bahn advises passengers to follow instructions from on-board staff.
Which features suit different listeners?
Listening to interviews on noisy trains
If you’re listening to conversations you’ve already recorded, look for a good fit and check speech clarity using a recording of your own. Don’t simply turn up the volume to hear an unclear section. The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy environments.
Travellers who change trains frequently
If you need to hear announcements or speak to staff along the way, easy-to-reach pause controls and a quick way to activate ambient mode are useful. Deutsche Bahn advises passengers to follow instructions from on-board staff.
Long-distance listeners
If you spend long journeys wearing headphones, compare how they fit your own head, the stated battery life and how they connect to your playback device. Manufacturers’ battery-life figures depend on the model and conditions.
What should you look for when buying?
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| Understanding interview voices |
Check the fit and seal. If possible, compare the same difficult passage at a moderate volume with ANC switched on and off. |
If I want to understand a recorded voice despite the noise of the train, I check playback using one of my own files. Speech clarity is a priority for roughly 31% of consumers. |
| Hearing announcements |
Check that pause and ambient mode are easy to access; don’t assume ambient mode will make every announcement clear. |
If I need to pay attention to announcements and staff while listening, I want to be able to pause playback quickly or hear what’s going on around me. Around 25% of consumers put awareness of their surroundings first. |
| Comfort on longer journeys |
Check the ear-cup size, pressure and fit with glasses on; consider the packed size and case if you need to change trains. |
If I’m listening over longer distances, I want the headphones to feel comfortable on my head without pressing. Around 19% of consumers prioritise comfort. |
| Connectivity and power |
Check the connection on your playback device, any cables you’ll need and the stated battery life with ANC switched on. |
If I’m relying on a particular connection or need the headphones to last through a long journey without recharging, I check the connections and battery life for my device. Reliable playback connectivity is the main concern for around 13% of consumers. |
| Cost and needs |
Match the features to your listening needs; check the terms of the specific offer and seller. |
If I only want to pay for features I’ll actually use, I compare the specification with my needs rather than choosing based on product category alone. Roughly 12% of consumers put keeping costs down first. |
What should you watch out for when buying and using them?
-
Assuming ANC guarantees clear interviews
Noise cancellation is designed to reduce background noise. Recording quality and how clearly a particular voice comes through are separate factors.
Try a difficult passage from one of your own recordings at a moderate volume.
-
Blocking out noise without paying attention to your surroundings
Announcements and instructions may be important while you’re travelling. Ambient mode doesn’t guarantee that every announcement will be clear.
Keep pause or ambient mode within easy reach, and take your headphones off if necessary. Follow instructions from on-board staff.
-
Assuming similarly named versions come with the same accessories
JBL notes that some versions of the Tour ONE M3 are sold without the SMART Tx transmitter.
Before buying, check the full model name, connections and what’s included with the specific version.
Depending on the version, an extra transmitter or connection you need could make set-up more involved.
Which brands are worth considering?
Sony
Worth considering if you want to compare closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC and ambient mode, or an additional wired connection option.
- Sony quotes up to 30 hours of music playback with NC for the WH-1000XM6. For the WH-CH720N, Sony quotes up to 35 hours with NC, plus passive wired playback.
- These are manufacturer figures for the respective models, not proof of how clearly specific interview recordings will sound or how comfortable they’ll be for you.
Bose
The QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) are over-ear ANC headphones with an audio cable and adjustable settings.
- Bose quotes up to 30 hours of playback, or 23 hours with 360-degree sound.
- Bose’s claims about noise cancellation or comfort don’t prove that these headphones outperform others for interview recordings.
Sennheiser
The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless and MOMENTUM 5 Wireless are separate generations of the range. When comparing them, check the battery-life conditions for each model.
- Sennheiser quotes up to 60 hours per charge for the MOMENTUM 4 and up to 57 hours with ANC switched on for the MOMENTUM 5.
- The figures are given under different conditions and don’t directly demonstrate performance for interview recordings.
soundcore
The Space One and Space One Pro give you models to compare for adaptive ANC features and adjustable ambient modes. The Pro model is foldable.
- soundcore quotes 40 hours of playback with ANC for the Space One.
- The advertised voice reduction feature applies to external noise; it doesn’t prove that quiet voices in an interview recording will sound clearer.
JBL
The Tour ONE M3 is worth considering if you want to connect different audio sources, but the exact version matters.
- JBL describes a SMART Tx transmitter for analogue and USB-C sources.
- JBL says some Tour ONE M3 models are sold without this transmitter, so check what’s included with the specific version.
Joybuy products for travel
The following closed-back over-ear models are described as having ANC and are worth comparing for listening on the go.
No image available
Bose QuietComfort Ultra (2nd Generation), Midnight Violet
A good option to consider if you want to compare ANC and several ways to connect your playback device.
Bluetooth, USB-C audio and a 2.5 mm connection are listed. Battery life is stated as up to 30 hours.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Bose QuietComfort Headphones Wireless, Twilight Blue
A good option to consider if you want to switch between noise isolation and awareness of your surroundings, as well as use a wired connection.
The description lists Quiet Mode, Aware Mode, Bluetooth and wired listening. Battery life is stated as up to 24 hours.
View at Joybuy
No image available
1MORE SonoFlow MAX (Upgraded HQ51) HQ60 Over-Ear Headphones
A good option to consider if you want to compare over-ear headphones with ANC and USB-C playback for listening on the go.
Bluetooth 6.0, USB-C playback and QuietMAX ANC 2.0 are listed. Check the stated battery life for the specific version before buying.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Sennheiser Accentum Plus Wireless, Black
A good option to consider if you want to compare ANC, wired listening and longer playback times.
The description lists Bluetooth 5.2, ANC, a detachable cable and up to 50 hours of battery life.
View at Joybuy
No image available
JBL LIVE 780NC, Champagne
A good option to consider if you’re looking for adaptive noise cancellation and foldable over-ear headphones that are easy to carry.
Bluetooth 6.0, Multipoint and True Adaptive Noise Cancelling 2.0 are listed. Battery life is stated as up to 80 hours.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Will ANC automatically make a poorly recorded interview voice easier to understand?
No. ANC is designed to reduce background noise and won’t automatically improve the original recording. Try a difficult passage from one of your own files at a moderate volume.
How should I use headphones if there might be an announcement or someone speaking to me?
Keep pause or ambient mode easy to access and take your headphones off if necessary. Deutsche Bahn advises passengers to follow instructions from on-board staff; transparency mode doesn’t guarantee that you’ll understand every announcement.
How can I avoid listening too loudly on the train?
The WHO recommends well-fitting headphones and noise cancellation to reduce the need to turn up the volume in noisy environments. Consider volume and listening time together; this doesn’t guarantee a specific volume setting for any particular model.
What are my rights when buying online or if something goes wrong in Germany?
When you buy from a trader, you generally have a legal guarantee of at least two years from the date you receive the goods. Distance sales generally come with a 14-day right to cancel; exceptions and the terms of the specific contract should be taken into account. Your Europe explains these EU consumer rights. A voluntary manufacturer’s warranty is separate.
Can I listen to interviews through headphones in the ICE quiet carriage?
Deutsche Bahn says that playing music loudly, including through headphones, is not welcome in the quiet carriage. Listen in a way that doesn’t disturb others; this wording does not amount to a general ban on listening quietly.