Who are these headphones for?

Listeners of quieter piano passages

If you want to hear the notes being struck and fading away without turning up the volume to drown out train noise, a good fit, ANC and your own experience with a familiar recording all matter. The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones in noisy environments.

Listeners on long journeys

For a whole recital, a comfortable fit over extended periods and enough battery life in the mode you actually use are important. Compare the relevant manufacturers’ figures, such as those from Sony, Bose or Sennheiser, under the appropriate operating conditions.

Travellers packing light

If you want to carry less and pause quickly when changing trains, check the fit, controls and battery life per charge. Apple lists several ear tip sizes for the AirPods Pro 3; on the train, though, make sure you can still hear important announcements.

Which buying priorities matter most?

Closed-back ANC over-ear headphones

A good fit if: you prefer an around-ear fit on longer journeys, have room for the case and can test the sound and fit with a familiar recording.

The trade-off: They take up more room in your luggage; comfort and sound vary by model and personal fit.

Sealing ANC in-ear headphones

A good fit if: travelling light matters and the ear tips feel comfortable and create a good seal throughout your journey.

The trade-off: In-ear fit is personal; compare listening time per charge rather than just the battery life including the charging case.

Buying priority What to check Who it matters most to
Train noise during quieter passages Test the fit and ANC at a moderate volume with a familiar, quiet recording; Sony explains that noise reduction works best on lower-pitched, steady sounds. If I want to hear soft notes over the sound of the train, a good seal matters more to me than simply turning up the volume. Around 29% of consumers say noise isolation is their top buying priority.
Piano sound and listening experience Listen to the same recording with each contender at a similar, moderate volume; adjust the sound settings only if needed. If the notes, tonal balance and fade-out matter most to me, I want to judge the sound for myself using a familiar recording. Around 23% of consumers put piano sound first.
Comfort and battery life Try over-ear headphones for as long as possible and compare battery life only in similar ANC modes and for a journey of a suitable length. For a whole recital, I need a comfortable fit and enough battery in reserve, not necessarily the smallest design. Around 18% of consumers say long-term comfort and battery life are their main priorities.
Size and announcements Check the case and ear tips, try the pause controls and deliberately pause playback for important announcements. If I’m changing trains with little luggage, I want to pack my headphones away quickly and pay attention to announcements. Around 18% of consumers prioritise portability and being able to hear announcements.
Cost and buying terms Compare models using the same sound and fit criteria; check the seller and cancellation terms before placing an online order. If I only want to pay for the features I actually need, getting the right value for money is what matters to me. Around 12% of consumers put cost first.

What should you look out for?

  • Expecting ANC to create complete silence

    Conversations and changing sounds may still be audible, even with noise reduction. Turning the volume up unnecessarily could work against your aim of listening to quieter passages at a moderate volume.

    Check the fit and ANC with a quiet, familiar recording, and keep the volume moderate. Pause playback for important announcements.

  • Confusing the charging case’s battery life with the earbuds’ battery life

    For the AirPods Pro 3, Apple distinguishes between up to 8 hours of listening per charge with ANC and up to 24 hours including the charging case. These figures refer to different conditions of use.

    For an uninterrupted journey, compare battery life per charge in the mode you actually use. Needing to stop and charge may interrupt a longer listening session.

  • Assuming every JBL Tour ONE M3 comes with SMART Tx

    JBL notes that some versions of the Tour ONE M3 are sold without SMART Tx.

    If you need the transmitter for your audio source, check what’s included with the specific version before buying.

  • Taking a general test ranking as a guide to personal suitability

    A general ranking assesses a range of features, but not how the headphones fit you or how you personally experience a piano recital on the train.

    Use test results to create a shortlist, then judge the sound, fit and controls for yourself in conditions similar to your own journeys.

Key brands at a glance

JBL

Tour ONE M3: ANC over-ear headphones for travellers who also want to check the connectivity options and what’s included.

  • CHIP ranked the Tour ONE M3 first in its general Bluetooth over-ear list. This is not a rating specifically for listening to piano music on the train.
  • In its ANC test, CHIP noted that some low frequencies got through. JBL says some versions are sold without SMART Tx.

Bose

QuietComfort Ultra Headphones 2nd Gen: an around-ear ANC option if noise isolation and adjustable sound matter to you.

  • CHIP awarded this specific model a sub-rating of 1.0 in its ANC best-of list. The test result applies to the conditions used in that test.
  • Bose quotes up to 30 hours of playback, or 23 hours with 360-degree sound; these modes are not directly comparable.

Sony

WH-1000XM6: closed-back ANC over-ear headphones with ambient sound mode and a 3.5 mm connection.

  • Sony quotes up to 30 hours of music playback with noise cancelling switched on and up to 40 hours with it switched off.
  • CHIP ranked the model third and gave it an ANC sub-rating of 1.0. That doesn’t guarantee silence on the train.

Baseus

Inspire XH1: an over-ear alternative among the models tested by CHIP.

  • CHIP ranked the Inspire XH1 fourth on its list.
  • Its ANC sub-rating of 1.8 was behind Bose and Sony’s sub-ratings in this test list. Manufacturer claims about sound and comfort are no substitute for trying the fit and sound for yourself.

Sennheiser

MOMENTUM 4 Wireless: an over-ear option for buyers looking for long claimed battery life and adjustable sound.

  • Sennheiser quotes up to 60 hours from a full charge for the MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, as well as EQ and transparency mode.
  • CHIP ranked this specific model fifth. The manufacturer’s battery-life figure and its test ranking alone can’t tell you whether the fit and piano sound will suit you.

Apple

AirPods Pro 3: compact ANC in-ear headphones, provided the ear tips fit and any additional features you need are compatible with your devices.

  • Apple lists five sizes of silicone ear tips and up to 8 hours of listening per charge with ANC.
  • Apple’s quoted total battery life of up to 24 hours includes the charging case; it is not the earbuds’ continuous battery life.

Joybuy products for your travels

The following Joybuy products include wireless in-ear headphones and ANC over-ear headphones for listening to music on the go.

Acer OHR548 wireless in-ear headphones with Type-C charging case

Acer OHR548 Wireless Earphones

An option for wireless listening on the go if you’re looking for in-ear headphones with touch controls; check that the noise cancelling meets your needs before choosing.

Bluetooth 5.4; HiFi decoding; 3D surround sound; touch controls; Type-C charging case.

View at Joybuy
MINISO MG210 wireless over-ear noise-cancelling headphones

MINISO MG210 Wireless Noise-Cancelling Over-Ear Headphones

Worth considering if you’re looking for wireless over-ear headphones with noise cancelling.

Battery life stated in the product title: 24 hours.

View at Joybuy
Sennheiser Momentum 5 wireless over-ear headphones

Sennheiser Momentum 5 Wireless

An over-ear option if you’re looking for wireless listening and Active Noise Cancellation.

Bluetooth 5.4; up to 57 hours of battery life according to the product title; replaceable battery; closed-back design.

View at Joybuy
Sennheiser Accentum Plus Wireless over-ear headphones

Sennheiser Accentum Plus Wireless

A good choice if you’re looking for wireless over-ear headphones with Active Noise Cancellation.

Bluetooth 5.2 with aptX and Multipoint; 50 hours of battery life according to the product title; fast charging; detachable cable.

View at Joybuy
JBL LIVE BUDS 3 true wireless earbuds with charging case

JBL LIVE BUDS 3

A compact true wireless option if you’d rather take in-ear headphones than an over-ear model.

True wireless earbuds; charging case; wireless charging according to the product title.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should I simply turn up the volume for quiet piano passages on the train?

No, don’t automatically turn it up. The WHO recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the temptation to increase the volume in noisy environments; volume and listening time still matter.

Why can I still hear conversations with ANC on?

ANC doesn’t work equally well on every sound. Sony explains that noise reduction works best on lower-pitched, steadier sounds; changing voices may still be audible.

How should I test in-ear headphones before a longer journey?

Try ear tips that feel comfortable and check that they stay in place when worn for longer periods. Then compare listening time per charge with ANC on, rather than just the total battery life including the charging case.

Can I listen to music on headphones in the quiet carriage on an ICE train?

Deutsche Bahn says that listening to music loudly, including through headphones, is not welcome in its ICE quiet carriages. This is guidance on behaviour in those carriages, not evidence of a general legal ban on using headphones.

What are my rights if headphones bought online don’t fit or are faulty?

According to Verbraucherzentrale, online orders generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, starting from the date you receive the goods. If an item is faulty, your statutory rights are against the seller; a voluntary guarantee is separate. Check the terms of your specific purchase.