Which scanning method is right for you?

Groups with bound journals

If you want to scan pages without removing them from the binding, check the usable scanner glass area against the actual size of your originals. Brother describes the MFC-1810 as having an A4 flatbed for bound originals.

Groups with lots of loose inserts

An ADF can make the process easier when scanning additional notes or individual double-sided sheets. For double-sided originals, look specifically for confirmation of duplex scanning, as offered on the Canon MAXIFY GX6550 and HP OfficeJet Pro 9132e.

Groups with colour originals and printouts

If you want to digitise colourful keepsake pages or print documents, consider the colour-scanning capability, printing technology and consumables of the specific device. Canon and Epson, for example, offer models with refillable ink.

What should your group look for when buying?

Start with your originals: a flatbed scanner and a document feeder are designed for different scanning tasks. Then consider whether your group regularly handles lots of loose or double-sided inserts, colour originals, searchable files or printouts.

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Bound pages Check the usable scanner glass area against the journal’s dimensions; see how easy it is to scan an open book. If we’re scanning bound journals, the book needs to fit on the glass without removing any pages. Around 36% of consumers say bound originals are their main consideration.
Loose inserts Check for an ADF and compatible originals; for double-sided sheets, look specifically for duplex scanning. When we have lots of loose notes, I don’t want to keep placing each sheet on the scanner by hand or turning over double-sided pages. Around 29% of consumers prioritise scanning stacks of loose pages.
Colour and files Try scanning colour originals; check the file format and that any OCR solution you need is compatible. If colourful keepsake pages and files that are easy to find later matter to us, the whole scanning and filing process counts. Around 21% of consumers put colour and file use first.
Printing needs and ongoing costs Compare your expected print volume and the relevant consumables; check whether the model uses separate drum units or has specific cartridge requirements. If we print regularly as a group, I want to know which consumables each device uses. Around 14% of consumers consider printing needs and ongoing costs their top concern.

Avoid common misconceptions

  • Assuming an ADF can scan bound books

    A document feeder is designed for suitable loose sheets. It does not replace placing bound pages on the flatbed scanner, so you’ll still need to position each book page by hand.

    Check the journal’s dimensions against the usable scanner glass area, and think of the ADF as an extra for loose inserts.

    Placing each page by hand adds to scanning time.

  • Confusing duplex printing with duplex scanning

    Automatic double-sided printing doesn’t tell you whether a device can automatically scan both sides of an original. Epson describes the XP-7100 as supporting duplex printing, while Canon specifically lists a duplex ADF for the MAXIFY GX6550.

    If you have double-sided inserts, check the scanning features of the full model rather than relying on its printing specifications.

    Without suitable duplex scanning, you’ll need to turn over and sort double-sided originals by hand.

  • Comparing only the device’s features

    The Brother DCP-L2550DN uses separate toner and drum units. HP says the OfficeJet Pro 9132e has a dynamic security feature that may block cartridges without a new or reused HP chip.

    Before choosing a model, check which consumables it uses and whether your planned replacement cartridges meet its requirements.

  • Assuming that being able to scan means you can share files with your group

    The fact that a journal can technically be scanned doesn’t automatically mean you’re allowed to share it. The German Federal Ministry of Justice lists different rules on reproduction and making works available to the public under Sections 53 and 19a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG).

    Before sharing, check the relevant rights, who will receive the files and, where personal information is involved, which data protection legal basis applies.

Key brands to consider

Brother

The models mentioned here have different strengths: a flatbed for bound originals or black-and-white printing with a document feeder.

  • Brother describes the MFC-1810 as having an A4 flatbed and an ADF. The manufacturer lists a 50-sheet ADF for the DCP-L2550DN.
  • The DCP-L2550DN doesn’t print in colour, and the toner and drum are separate consumables. These details apply to the models mentioned, not to the brand as a whole.

Canon

The PIXMA G650 and MAXIFY GX6550 cater to different needs, with a focus on photo printing and document feeding respectively.

  • Canon lists a 35-sheet duplex ADF for the MAXIFY GX6550. The PIXMA G650 uses six refillable photo inks.
  • According to Canon, duplex printing on the PIXMA G650 is selected manually; this doesn’t confirm automatic duplex scanning.

Epson

The models mentioned include devices with document feeders and refillable ink.

  • Epson describes the EcoTank ET-3950 as having refillable ink and an automatic double-sided document feeder; an ADF is listed for the XP-7100.
  • On the XP-7100, automatic duplex operation refers to printing and shouldn’t be confused with duplex scanning. ET-3950 page-yield figures are based on manufacturer estimates.

HP

The OfficeJet Pro 9132e is a colour multifunction printer with an ADF and double-sided scanning, according to HP’s specifications for this model.

  • HP lists an automatic document feeder and double-sided scanning for this specific model.
  • HP warns that its dynamic security feature may block cartridges without a new or reused HP chip, including after firmware updates.

Joybuy products for scanning and printing

The colour inkjet and laser models below combine printing, scanning and copying. For bound journals, check the usable scanner glass area; for loose stacks, check the feeder on the specific model.

HP Envy 6520 All-in-One Wireless Inkjet Printer

HP Envy 6520

For groups that want to print in colour and scan loose, multi-page inserts; check the device’s scanner glass area for bound pages.

All-in-one inkjet printer with wireless connectivity.

View at Joybuy
HP Envy 6120 All-in-One Wireless Inkjet Printer

HP Envy 6120

For groups looking to combine scanning, copying and printing in one device. Check the scanner glass area for journals, and whether a feeder suits your workflow when handling stacks of pages.

All-in-one inkjet printer with wireless connectivity.

View at Joybuy
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg Multifunction Colour Laser Printer

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

For groups that need colour laser printing and want to scan bound originals, the flatbed scanner described may be useful. Automatic double-sided printing is not the same as duplex scanning.

Colour laser multifunction printer with automatic double-sided printing, touchscreen, Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300AW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

PANTUM BM2300AW

The listed ADF is useful for loose inserts, while the described flatbed scanning option may also suit bound pages. Check the scanner glass area, and note that this model prints in monochrome.

A4 monochrome laser multifunction printer, 22 pages per minute, Wi-Fi and ADF.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

PANTUM BM2300NW

The described flatbed scanning option may be useful for bound pages; check the usable area against the journal’s dimensions. This device prints in monochrome.

A4 monochrome laser multifunction printer, 22 pages per minute, dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan a bound travel journal using the document feeder?

The flatbed scanner is the right option for bound originals; an ADF is designed for suitable loose pages. Before buying, check that the specific book pages fit on the usable scanner glass area.

Does automatic duplex printing also mean automatic double-sided scanning?

No. Automatic duplex printing refers to printing; the specific model must explicitly list a scanning feature for scanning both sides. Canon lists a duplex ADF for the MAXIFY GX6550, while Epson describes the XP-7100 as having automatic duplex printing.

How can I create a searchable journal archive?

Decide on your filing system and file-naming conventions before scanning, and check that any OCR solution you use for text searches is compatible with your device and operating system. Epson describes OCR for its ScanSmart software; this doesn’t apply to every Epson multifunction printer.

Which consumables should our group compare?

Check which ink bottles, cartridges or toner are compatible with each model, and look out for separate components such as the drum unit in the Brother DCP-L2550DN. HP also highlights the chip requirement for cartridges used with the OfficeJet Pro 9132e.

Can we share scanned journals with our group in Germany without restriction?

No, you can’t assume that sharing is automatically permitted. The German Federal Ministry of Justice lists certain reproductions under Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) and making works available to the public under Section 19a separately. Where personal information is involved, you also need an appropriate legal basis for processing it, as explained by the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information. Check the specific use and who will receive the files before sharing them.