Which recording option is right for you?

Choir leaders who want quick rehearsal recordings

If you want to listen back to the rehearsal together and don’t need to edit individual microphones afterwards, a stereo USB signal may suit your needs. Microphone placement in the room is still important. Yamaha lists four mono microphone/line channels and USB audio with 2 IN / 2 OUT for the MG10XU.

Recordists who need separate choir tracks

If you want to balance choir microphones or accompaniment separately later, you’ll need suitable inputs, separate USB recording channels and a computer set up accordingly. Allen & Heath documents four microphone inputs and four selectable USB recording channels on the ZEDi-10.

Choir leaders who don’t want to use a computer

If you want to record straight to storage during a rehearsal in the classroom, consider a mixer with a built-in recorder. Check whether it saves a stereo mix or individual tracks: Zoom describes the LiveTrak L-8 as recording individual tracks to an SD card, while Tascam lists a built-in 12-track SD recorder on the Model 12.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether you need a finished stereo mix, separate tracks or a recording setup that doesn’t rely on a computer running. Then count the microphone inputs you actually need and plan a test in the rehearsal room.

What you need What to check before buying Who is it most relevant to?
Simple rehearsal recording Which signals the mixer actually sends over USB; make a short test recording on the computer you plan to use. If I mainly want a recording we can all listen back to together, and can set the balance during rehearsal, a stereo setup is more likely to suit me. Around 29% of consumers are likely to have this priority.
Editing individual tracks How many microphone inputs and separate USB channels can be used at the same time; routing and phantom power requirements. If I want to balance choir sections or accompaniment separately later, I need separate recording signals and a suitable computer-based workflow. Around 29% of consumers are likely to place particular importance on this kind of post-production.
Recording without a computer Whether it records directly to an SD card, which tracks are saved and how the mixer is powered during rehearsal. If I don’t want a computer running in the classroom, a built-in recorder is essential for me. The storage media and power supply also need to suit the setup. Around 21% of consumers are likely to prioritise this.
Capturing the choir’s sound in the room Position the microphones appropriately first, then listen to a test recording made in the actual room. Only then decide how many inputs you need. If I want to capture voices and the classroom acoustics in a balanced way, I’ll check microphone placement first rather than expecting extra mixer channels to solve problems with the room’s sound. Around 21% of consumers are likely to prioritise this.

Avoiding common misconceptions

  • Assuming mixer channels are the same as USB tracks

    The number of inputs doesn’t automatically tell you how many separate signals will reach your computer. Yamaha lists four mono microphone/line channels on the MG10XU, but USB audio with 2 IN / 2 OUT; four separate USB sources are documented for the ZEDi-10.

    Before choosing a mixer for individual tracks, check the number of USB recording channels and how they’re routed on the specific model.

  • Assuming all inputs accept the same type of microphone connection

    According to Behringer, XLR microphone inputs 1 and 2 on the FLOW 8 have switchable +48 V phantom power. The ten USB send channels are a separate specification.

    Match each microphone you plan to use with a suitable input, and check whether it needs phantom power.

  • Expecting a better mixer to automatically improve the room sound

    Shure emphasises the choice and positioning of microphones for choir recording. A different mixer won’t fix poor microphone placement, and adding more microphones also means more setup and balancing.

    Test microphone positions in the rehearsal room and listen to a short recording before deciding how many inputs you need.

  • Confusing the ability to record with having the right permissions

    Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers, among other things, the unauthorised recording of spoken words that are not intended for the public, and making such a recording accessible to others.

    Before the rehearsal, clarify the purpose of the recording, who is taking part and who it may be shared with. For a school event, you should also take into account the data protection requirements that apply to the school concerned.

A guide to the key brands

Yamaha

The MG10XU is an option for recording two channels to a computer, with several mono microphone/line inputs.

  • Yamaha lists four mono microphone/line channels.
  • USB audio with 2 IN / 2 OUT doesn’t confirm that four separate USB tracks can be recorded.

Allen & Heath

The ZEDi-10 is aimed at computer-based recording where several microphones need to be recorded separately in your recording software.

  • Allen & Heath documents four microphone inputs and a 4-in/4-out USB interface with selectable sources.
  • You’ll need to set up the routing you want; there’s no evidence that this model has a built-in SD recorder.

Behringer

According to the manufacturer, the FLOW 8 sends multiple channels over USB to a computer.

  • Behringer lists ten USB send channels to a computer.
  • Inputs 1 and 2 are the XLR microphone inputs specifically described as having switchable phantom power. Check that the connections are right for your microphones.

Zoom

The LiveTrak L-8 is worth considering for rehearsals where you want to record tracks to an SD card without a computer running.

  • Zoom describes six separate preamps and individual tracks saved to an SD card.
  • Check that the storage media and power supply suit your planned recording setup.

Tascam

The Model 12 combines a mixer, USB interface and built-in SD multitrack recorder.

  • Tascam lists ten inputs, a 12-track recorder and a USB interface with 12 inputs and 10 outputs.
  • For a short stereo recording, this more comprehensive setup may offer more features than you need.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I automatically record four separate tracks on my computer with four microphone inputs?

No. The number of microphone inputs doesn’t guarantee the same number of separate USB recording tracks. Yamaha lists four mono microphone/line channels on the MG10XU, but USB audio with 2 IN / 2 OUT; the ZEDi-10 offers four USB recording channels with selectable sources. So check the specifications and routing for the particular model.

How should I set up microphones for a rehearsal in a classroom?

Start with as few choir microphones as possible, positioned appropriately, and listen to a short recording made in the actual space. Shure’s guidance on miking choirs is a useful starting point, not a fixed microphone count or spacing rule for every classroom.

What do I need to prepare for recording?

For an SD recording, you’ll need suitable storage media and a power supply as part of your setup. For a USB recording, you’ll need a computer and compatible software configured for the job. Allen & Heath also describes setting up a Windows driver for the ZEDi-10. Check in advance which recording option works with the equipment you already have.

Can I simply record a choir rehearsal in Germany and share it with others?

There’s no blanket yes-or-no answer. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers, among other things, the unauthorised recording of other people’s spoken words when they’re not intended for the public, and making a recording created in this way accessible to others. Whether it applies to a particular rehearsal depends on the circumstances. If voices can be identified and the recording will be shared, the relevant data protection questions also need to be addressed. If it is a school rehearsal, take into account the requirements that apply to that school: guidance from the Bavarian Data Protection Commissioner on school photography and video recording does not constitute blanket permission to make audio recordings throughout Germany.