Which recording setup is right for you?

Pianists in noisy flats

If you’re recording an acoustic piano, start by testing the microphone position and recording location. With a digital piano, a suitable audio output may be an alternative to a room microphone; check the connections on your specific instrument. Shure explains how microphone position affects piano sound and background noise, while Yamaha describes an audio output for the Silent Piano SH2.

Post-production with a pair of microphones

If you want to edit each microphone separately after playing, check which signals are actually sent over USB rather than simply counting the mixer’s inputs. Allen & Heath documents separate USB inputs for the ZEDi-10FX; the signals received depend on the routing settings.

Recording without a computer

If you want to record straight to a memory card, you’ll need a clearly documented recorder function. Zoom describes separate SD tracks for the LiveTrak L-8, while Tascam specifies an integrated SD recorder for the Model 12.

What should you look for?

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Room noise and signal path Type of piano and available audio outputs; if using microphones, test them at the actual recording location. If I want to keep unwanted background noise out of my piano recording as much as possible, I’ll first check the instrument, signal path and microphone position. Around 36% of consumers prioritise a recording with less background noise.
Separate microphone tracks Number of USB inputs and specific channel assignments; make a test recording and check that each track appears separately in the recording software. If I want to adjust levels or edit microphones separately after playing, I need genuinely separate recording signals, not just more mixer channels. Around 29% of consumers prioritise microphone tracks they can edit individually.
Finished stereo mix Suitable inputs, a stereo USB signal path and monitoring options; record a test level before playing. If I want to set the balance before playing and then record a finished mix, a straightforward stereo signal path is important. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a finished stereo recording.
Recording without a computer Standalone recorder, supported storage media and the number of tracks actually saved. If I want to record without a computer running, the device must be able to record to a memory card itself. Around 14% of consumers prioritise computer-free recording.

Common misconceptions

  • Assuming that inputs equal separately recordable USB tracks

    The number of sockets doesn’t automatically tell you how many separate signals reach your computer. The Yamaha MG10XU has four documented Mic/Line inputs, but its USB connection has 2 inputs and 2 outputs.

    Check the USB channel count and routing on the specific model. Make a test recording and check whether the software actually receives the tracks you want separately.

  • Expecting a mixer to get rid of noise in your flat

    When recording with microphones, their position affects how much piano, room sound and other noise is picked up. A USB mixer can’t remove noise that has already been recorded along with the piano on the same track.

    Test the microphone position and recording location with a short recording. If you have a digital piano, check whether a suitable audio output could work for the sound you want.

  • Confusing a USB connection with standalone memory-card recording

    A USB audio interface and a memory-card recorder are different features. To record without a computer, you need a documented recorder function.

    Check the exact model’s recorder function, supported storage media and number of tracks saved.

Brands worth considering

Yamaha

The MG10XU is an example of an analogue mixer with several Mic/Line inputs and a stereo USB signal path.

  • Yamaha documents inputs 1–4, 48 V phantom power and 2-in/2-out USB audio for the MG10XU.
  • On this model, four inputs don’t mean that four microphone signals can be recorded separately over USB.

Allen & Heath

The ZEDi-10FX combines hands-on analogue controls with configurable USB input signals.

  • According to its specifications, the ZEDi-10FX has four Mic/Line inputs and a 4-in/4-out USB interface.
  • Allen & Heath says which signals are sent separately depends on the USB routing settings.

Zoom

The LiveTrak L-8 combines a mixer and USB interface with an SD card recording function.

  • Zoom documents separate SD tracks, six microphone preamps and four headphone outputs for the L-8.
  • Recording to a card doesn’t change which room sounds the microphones pick up at the recording location.

Tascam

The Model 12 is designed for a more extensive workflow, with an integrated SD recorder and multichannel USB interface.

  • Tascam specifies a 12-track recorder, WAV recording to an SD card and USB with 12 inputs and 10 outputs for the Model 12.
  • The extra tracks and recorder are most useful if you actually plan to use these features.

Behringer

The XENYX X1204USB is an example of an analogue mixer that sends the main mix to a computer over USB.

  • Behringer describes the X1204USB as having four XLR microphone inputs and USB for the main mix.
  • The four XLR inputs on this model don’t guarantee four separate USB tracks.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How can I check whether the microphones are picking up too much noise from my flat before I play?

Make a short test recording at the planned location, including passages with playing and pauses, then listen back. Shure explains that microphone position affects both the piano sound and the surrounding noise picked up; changing the position can shift the balance. A mixer is no substitute for this test.

Do I actually need a USB mixer for a digital piano?

Not necessarily. Check the manual for your specific model to see whether it can record audio directly over USB or has a suitable audio output. An additional mixer can be useful if you want to combine that signal with other sources.

How can I tell whether a mixer really records separate USB tracks?

Check the USB input count and channel assignments for the specific model, set up the routing and test it with your recording software. On the Allen & Heath ZEDi-10FX, the manufacturer says the assignments depend on the selected USB routing settings; the number of mixer inputs alone isn’t enough to confirm this.

What should I check if I want to record without a computer running?

The device needs a standalone recorder function. Also check the supported storage media and which tracks are actually recorded, and make a short test recording before you play. Zoom describes separate SD tracks for the LiveTrak L-8; Tascam documents an integrated SD recorder for the Model 12.

Can I record conversations in the background or publish a piano performance?

This depends on what you record and how you use the recording. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers, among other things, the unauthorised recording of another person’s private speech. Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) permits individual copies for private use only under the conditions set out there; it doesn’t give blanket permission to make protected music publicly available. Check your permission to record conversations, as well as the rights to the specific work and intended use, in advance.