If you can get the mix right during the take, a USB stereo recording may be enough. But if you want to make changes to individual vocals and instruments later, you’ll need separate recording tracks. If you want to leave your laptop at home, make sure the device records individual tracks to a card, rather than just the stereo mix. Also count the microphone inputs you’ll need and test different microphone positions: a mixer can’t remove room sound that’s already been recorded.
The right recording setup for you
Band planning to edit the recording
If you’re recording vocals and several acoustic instruments at the same time and want to balance them individually later, the number of separate recording tracks matters more than the number of channels on the mixer. Yamaha Deutschland and PreSonus document different ways of recording over USB, so check how tracks are routed on the specific model you’re considering.
Recording without a laptop
If you want to record in the hall without running recording software, then edit the tracks later, look for a device that’s explicitly documented as supporting multitrack recording to a card. Zoom, Allen & Heath and Tascam offer different devices and recording options for this.
Small ensemble happy with a finished live mix
If you can get the balance right while you play and don’t need to change individual signals later, a single stereo recording may be enough. Yamaha Deutschland lists the MG12XU as having a USB interface with two inputs and two outputs. Microphone placement and the hall’s acoustics still matter to the final result.
What to look for when buying
First decide whether you want to edit individual signals later, record on site without a computer, or settle for a finished stereo mix. Then check the inputs, recording options and monitoring facilities against the needs of your line-up.
Stereo mix over USB
A good fit if: you can get the mix right during the take and don’t need to edit individual tracks afterwards.
The trade-off: Once everything has been recorded together, you can’t adjust the balance between vocals, instruments and room sound for each signal individually.
Multitrack recording over USB
A good fit if: you want to edit several simultaneously recorded signals separately later and can use a computer with recording software on site.
The trade-off: USB multitrack recording doesn’t make up for a lack of suitable microphone inputs or poor placement in a reverberant room. PreSonus says the StudioLive AR12c records the channels and main mix over USB.
Multitrack recording to a card
A good fit if: you want to record without a computer but still save the signals separately.
The trade-off: Check the storage media, track routing and monitoring options. Tascam lists the Model 12 as discontinued; this doesn’t tell you whether it’s currently available.
| What you need |
What to check |
Who it matters to |
| Individual tracks |
Compare the number and routing of separately recordable USB or card tracks with the microphone inputs you need to use at the same time. |
If you want to balance vocals and instruments separately after the take, the actual number of individual tracks is what counts. Around 33% of consumers would have this as their main priority. |
| Inputs, monitoring and room sound |
Note down the microphone inputs and monitoring options you need; record a test with several microphone positions before the take. |
If several people are playing, I need suitable inputs and a practical way to monitor the sound in the hall. Around 25% of consumers would put this setup first. |
| Recording without a computer |
Check the card type and the documented recording mode: individual tracks and the main mix are not the same thing. |
If I don’t want to bring my laptop but do want to save the signals separately, the card must actually support multitrack recording. Around 25% of consumers would prioritise this. |
| Set stereo mix |
Make sure two USB recording channels will work for your planned mix, then listen back to a test recording. |
If a single demo is enough for me and I don’t need to change individual instruments later, stereo recording may do the job. Around 17% of consumers would mainly be looking for this simpler setup. |
Common misconceptions
-
Lots of mixer channels mean just as many USB tracks
Yamaha Deutschland lists the MG12XU as having a USB interface with two inputs and two outputs. So the number of mixer inputs doesn’t tell you how many signals you can record separately over USB.
Check the number of separately recordable USB channels and how they’re routed for the exact model.
-
An SD card slot automatically means multitrack recording
According to PreSonus, the SD recorder on the StudioLive AR12c records the main mix; multitrack recording is documented for the USB connection.
Check the card and USB functions separately against the way you plan to record.
-
More mixer features will fix too much reverberation in the hall
The distance and position of the microphones affect how much room sound is already in the recording.
Start with a short test recording, listen back and try different microphone positions before assuming extra processing will solve the problem.
-
The LiveTrak L-12 and L12next are the same model version
Zoom publishes separate information for the older L-12 and the L12next. You can’t assume limitations of the older model also apply to the L12next.
Check the full model name and the relevant operating mode in the manufacturer’s specifications.
Key brands and product ranges
Zoom
According to Zoom, the LiveTrak L12next combines multitrack recording to a card, a USB interface and individual monitor mixes. It’s an option for ensembles that want to play and record without having to use a computer.
- Zoom lists up to twelve recordable tracks plus a stereo mix, and five monitor mixes, for the L12next.
- These specifications apply to the L12next; limitations of the older LiveTrak L-12 don’t automatically apply to this model.
Allen & Heath
The CQ-12T is a compact digital mixer with documented multitrack recording to SD and a USB recording option.
- Allen & Heath documents multitrack recording and playback on SD, and recommends SDHC Class 10 U1.
- Check that the digital controls and routing suit the way you work.
Tascam
According to Tascam, the Model 12 combines a mixer, USB interface and 12-track recorder for recording without a DAW running.
- The standalone recorder could suit a workflow that doesn’t involve a recording computer.
- Tascam lists the Model 12 as discontinued; this doesn’t confirm whether it’s currently available.
PreSonus
The StudioLive AR12c is an option for multitrack recording over USB to a computer.
- PreSonus documents a 14×4 USB interface and eight microphone inputs.
- According to PreSonus, the SD recorder records the main mix; it doesn’t replace recording individual tracks to SD without a computer.
Yamaha
The MG12XU is worth considering if a stereo mix set during the take and recorded over USB is all you need.
- Yamaha Deutschland lists six microphone inputs and a USB interface with two inputs and two outputs.
- So you can’t use the mixer channels as the same number of separate USB recording tracks.
Products to consider on Joybuy
Products to suit your needs are coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if my DAW receives individual instruments rather than just a stereo mix?
Check the number and routing of USB recording channels for the specific model, not just the total number of mixer channels. Yamaha Deutschland lists two USB inputs and outputs for the MG12XU; PreSonus says the AR12c records the channels plus the main mix over USB.
What should I test in the hall before the first take?
Make a short test recording and listen back. If there’s too much room sound, first try changing the distance or position of the microphones. If you’re using loudspeakers for amplification, also check where they’re positioned in relation to the microphones: sound from the loudspeakers can be picked up again by the microphones and cause feedback.
Which memory card do I need for multitrack recording without a computer?
It depends on the device and its recording mode. Allen & Heath recommends an SDHC Class 10 U1 card for multitrack recording on the CQ range. Before you buy, check that the card type is compatible with the specific model.
Can I record other people in a community hall and publish a cover demo?
There’s no straightforward answer without knowing who’s involved, what conversations are being recorded and how you plan to use the recording. Discuss the recording with everyone involved beforehand and check which rules on processing personal data apply to your situation. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information describes consent as a data protection principle, not as a blanket decision for every individual case. For music used in public, GEMA refers to the relevant licences; for covers released as recordings, it lists licence fees for commercial use.