Start by choosing a stick based on its usable capacity and the ports on the devices involved. If you regularly copy large files, check the write speed of the specific variant rather than relying on the USB standard alone. For personal data belonging to your club, plan protection and recovery together: the Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority notes that clubs are also subject to data protection rules when processing this type of data, and the Federal Office for Information Security recommends planning for data restoration.
Who backs up club data?
People responsible for large club archives
You back up extensive project folders and need enough space for both the current files and planned backup versions. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends considering whether your backup can be restored, too.
Project teams that back up files frequently
You regularly copy large folders and want to compare write speeds for the specific capacity variant, rather than just looking at read speeds. COMPUTER BILD’s tests highlight differences in the write speeds of the models tested.
People managing confidential club data
You may be backing up members’ data, so you need to consider access protection, code management and recoverability together. The Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority notes that clubs are also subject to data protection rules when processing personal data.
What to consider when buying
For large club archives, consider capacity, write speed, data protection and recovery together.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who it matters most to |
| Space for backups |
Compare folder sizes, the number of backup versions you want to keep, and the usable capacity of the specific variant. |
If I need to store both the current files and additional backup versions, the usable space is what matters. Around 31% of consumers would make capacity their top buying consideration. |
| Write speed |
Compare write speed specifications or tests for the same capacity variant; don’t look at read speeds and USB specifications alone. |
If I regularly copy large files, I want to know how long writing them might take. Around 25% of consumers would consider write speed first. |
| Protecting confidential files |
Plan for the level of protection needed, the unlocking method and secure storage of codes or keys. |
If club files contain personal or other confidential information, I want to plan access protection and recovery together. Around 25% of consumers would prioritise file protection. |
| Device compatibility |
Check the ports and file system on the devices involved; Microsoft states that FAT32 has a maximum single-file size of 4 GiB. |
If I back up or restore files on different club devices, the stick and file system need to be readable on all of them. Around 19% of consumers would put device compatibility first. |
Common backup mistakes
-
Comparing only read speed or the USB standard
A fast connection doesn’t guarantee equally fast write speeds on the stick. COMPUTER BILD found differences in write speeds between the variants it tested.
Compare write speed specifications and, where available, tests for the exact capacity variant you’re considering.
Slow write speeds can mean extra waiting time every time you make a backup.
-
Keeping the portable stick as your only backup
The Federal Office for Information Security points out that the lifespan of a storage medium can’t be predicted precisely, and that it must be possible to restore a backup.
Keep another copy separately and test regularly that you can restore the data.
If the stick fails, your saved club files could be lost.
-
Assuming large folders mean large individual files
Microsoft states that FAT32 limits individual files to 4 GiB. A folder may therefore contain individual files that can’t be copied to a stick formatted for FAT32.
Before formatting, check the size of the largest individual file, the file system and whether it’s suitable for the devices you plan to use.
-
Using a code-protected stick without an access plan
For the Verbatim Keypad Secure USB-A with 128 GB, the manufacturer specifies reformatting after 20 incorrect code entries, as well as a security update.
Decide who will manage the code, how authorised people will access it, and how you’ll organise updates and a separate recoverable copy.
Code management and updates take additional time to organise.
Key brands to consider
SanDisk
The tested 128-GB Extreme Pro USB 3.1 Gen1 and Ultra Dual Drive Luxe USB Type-C models offer different options for connection types and write speeds.
- COMPUTER BILD rated the write speed of the Extreme Pro it tested as high.
- COMPUTER BILD described the write speed of the Dual Drive Luxe it tested as very slow, despite its USB-A and USB-C connectors. The test result applies to this variant.
Verbatim
The Keypad Secure USB-A with 128 GB is aimed at buyers considering a stick that can be unlocked directly on the device using a code.
- Verbatim states that this model has AES-256 hardware encryption and a keypad for entering the code on the stick.
- The manufacturer specifies reformatting after 20 incorrect code entries and a security update, so remember to plan for code management and updates.
Kingston
The DataTraveler range includes models with different capacities and connection types; IronKey is a separate range of encrypted USB sticks.
- Kingston lists the DataTraveler Duo in 128 and 256 GB capacities, with USB-A and USB-C connectors.
- This information doesn’t confirm a specific write speed for the Duo, and the protection offered by the IronKey range doesn’t apply to unencrypted DataTraveler models.
Samsung
The BAR Plus is available in a USB-A version with 256 GB, among other options.
- Samsung quotes sequential read speeds of up to 400 MB/s for the 256-GB variant.
- This read speed doesn’t tell you how fast the stick writes data. Samsung also notes that usable capacity may be lower than advertised.
Intenso
The High Speed Line is available in 128 and 256 GB capacities, and can be assessed using the manufacturer’s read and write speed specifications.
- For these variants, Intenso quotes read speeds of up to 250 MB/s and write speeds of up to 100 MB/s.
- COMPUTER BILD rated the write speed of the 128-GB variant it tested as slow. Manufacturer maximums and test results are based on different figures and shouldn’t be treated as identical real-world measurements.
USB sticks for large club archives
This selection includes sticks with different capacities and connector types, as well as options for frequent writing, confidential files or switching between USB-A and USB-C devices.
No image available
Kingston DataTraveler Kyson, 256 GB
The 256-GB variant is worth considering for large folders and frequent backups, provided its capacity and connector suit the devices you use.
For regular write operations, check the write speed specification for the specific variant and see how it fits your backup routine.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Kingston DataTraveler SE9 G3, 64 GB, 220 MB/s, USB 3.2 Gen 1
The 64-GB variant will only suit your club archives if there’s enough usable space for your current files and planned backup versions.
If you regularly write large files, check the write speed specification for this variant separately; the model name alone doesn’t tell you whether the 220 MB/s figure refers to reading or writing.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Kingston DataTraveler Exodia M, 128 GB, USB 3.2 Gen 1, black and red
The 128-GB variant is an option if there’s enough space for your project files and planned backup versions.
If you copy files frequently, compare the write speed specification for the specific variant and check that its connector suits the devices involved.
View at Joybuy
No image available
SanDisk Ultra, 256 GB, USB 3.0
The 256-GB variant is worth considering for large folders, provided its capacity and connector suit your backup needs.
If you’re storing confidential files, check before use whether the access protection and recovery features of the specific variant meet your club’s requirements.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Kexin 2-in-1, pack of 2, each with 32 GB, USB 2.0, USB-A and USB-C
The pack includes two sticks, each with 32 GB, and may suit you if your club devices use both USB-A and USB-C.
USB 2.0 is specified for this variant. Check beforehand that each stick has enough capacity for your folders and that you can restore the data on the devices you’ll be using.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose the right capacity for club archives?
Work out the size of the folders you need to back up and decide how many backup versions you want to keep. Compare the total with the usable space on the specific variant, then test that you can copy and restore the files.
What should I check about devices and file systems before my first backup?
Check the connectors and make sure all the devices you plan to use can read the stick. Microsoft states that FAT32 has a maximum single-file size of 4 GiB. For larger individual files, you’ll need to choose a suitable file system and check that it works with the devices you’ll be using. Back up any existing files before formatting, then test restoring your data.
Is one USB stick enough for a club backup?
Don’t rely on a single stick for important documents. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that the lifespan of a storage medium can’t be predicted precisely and that it must be possible to restore your data. Keep a separate copy and test that you can recover your files.
What should I consider when organising access to a code-protected USB stick?
Plan how the code will be managed and how authorised people will access it. For the Keypad Secure USB-A with 128 GB, Verbatim specifies a security update and reformatting after 20 incorrect code entries; these details apply to the model mentioned.