Teams handling confidential interviews
If recordings contain identifiable people and are edited on a shared computer, you need to decide who can unlock the stick and access files once they are open.
For confidential interview recordings, controlled access and a suitable unlocking method matter more than a high read speed; the BfDI generally recommends storing data on encrypted USB sticks. For interviews that cannot be repeated, you should also keep a separate, verifiable backup, as the BSI emphasises when discussing data backups. Before you buy, check the connectors, file system and largest individual recording. An encrypted stick does not prevent access to files while it is unlocked and connected to a shared computer.
If recordings contain identifiable people and are edited on a shared computer, you need to decide who can unlock the stick and access files once they are open.
If you need to recover interviews after losing the stick or it becomes faulty, you’ll need a separate copy. Check that you can open the files from it.
If files move between devices with different connectors, check that you can actually transfer and open them on every device you plan to use.
A good fit if: you need to protect confidential recordings and can’t or don’t want to install unlocking software on the shared computer.
Bear in mind: Decide who manages the PINs and how authorised people can access a separate backup. Open files remain a separate access risk while the stick is unlocked.
A good fit if: the people responsible can use suitable encryption software on the computers they need and encrypt files before copying them.
Bear in mind: Protection depends on the encryption method being set up and used consistently. A compatible connector alone does not encrypt files.
A good fit if: the recordings are not confidential or are already protected in another suitable way.
Bear in mind: Don’t use the stick as your only copy. If you transfer files often, the write speed of the specific model matters.
| Priority | What to check when buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Confidentiality and access | Check the unlocking method and who is responsible for the PINs; decide who can access files while the stick is unlocked. | If I edit confidential interviews on a shared computer, I want to control who unlocks the stick and can see open files. Around 26% of consumers prioritise protecting confidential recordings. |
| Recoverability | Make a separate copy and try opening selected files from it. The BSI notes that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely. | For irreplaceable interviews, I want to be able to recover recordings if my work stick is lost or becomes faulty. Around 26% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Connectivity and compatibility | Check the connectors and file systems on all your devices. Microsoft gives FAT32 a maximum individual file size of 4 GiB. | If I transfer files between a recording device and a work computer, I want to be able to open them on both. Around 21% of consumers focus primarily on device compatibility. |
| Capacity | Add up file sizes and expected growth; also check that the largest individual file is within the FAT32 limit of 4 GiB. | I want to allow enough space for my recordings and the versions I need, without overlooking the size of individual files. Around 16% of consumers prioritise storage capacity. |
| Write speed | Compare figures for the exact model and capacity. Intenso quotes write speeds of up to 100 MB/s for the 128 and 256 GB High Speed Line models; COMPUTER BILD rated write speed as slow on the Intenso High Speed Line USB 3.0 128GB it tested. | If I often copy large interview files, I want to know how long transfers are likely to take. Around 11% of consumers prioritise the time needed for repeated transfers. |
USB sticks can be lost or fail. A backup only helps if it’s stored separately and you can open the files from it.
Keep a separate backup and regularly check that selected recordings can be read from it.
A password lock on the stick doesn’t control who can access files that are already open on a shared computer.
Also decide who is allowed to use the stick and when it should be locked again or removed.
Having two connectors doesn’t tell you how fast a stick can write files. COMPUTER BILD gave different write-speed ratings to the 128 GB models it tested.
Compare write-speed figures or test results for the exact model and capacity you’re considering.
For the Verbatim Keypad Secure #49429, the manufacturer says the stick needs to be reformatted after 20 incorrect code entries and points to a security update.
Check the manufacturer’s instructions, store the code securely and keep a separate copy of your files.
DataTraveler Duo is designed for switching between USB-A and USB-C devices; IronKey Keypad 200 is aimed at protected storage with keypad unlocking.
Keypad Secure #49429 is a 128 GB USB-A model with a keypad. Verbatim quotes AES-256 hardware encryption.
Extreme Pro USB 3.1 Gen1 128GB is a useful point of comparison for frequent file transfers, if test results for the exact model matter to you.
The High Speed Line is a USB-A range with 64, 128 and 256 GB variants.
JetFlash 890 is designed for switching between USB-A and USB-C devices.
The Joybuy products listed include a model with a keypad and hardware encryption, as well as options for different capacity and connector requirements. Check that the specifications match the devices at your shared workplace.
No product image available
For interview files if 64 GB suits your collection; check that the connector works with your workplace devices.
64 GB; USB 3.2 Gen 1; 220 MB/s according to the product name.
No product image available
For confidential recordings if a keypad-unlocked stick suits your access policy; also control access to files once they’re open.
32 GB; Keypad 200; AES-256 according to the product name.
No product image available
For switching between USB-A and USB-C devices; check that the connector and file system work with both.
32 GB; USB 2.0; USB-A and USB-C connectors; pack of 2.
No product image available
For storing and transferring interview files if a multipack suits your filing system.
USB 2.0; 16 GB according to the product name; pack of 5.
No product image available
For transferring files between devices, provided the connectors and, where necessary, OTG support are compatible.
32 GB according to the product name; 2-in-1 Type-C design; pack of 5.
Not on its own. Those responsible for personal data must ensure a level of protection appropriate to the risk; the BfDI generally recommends encrypted storage on USB sticks. Also check who can access files while the stick is unlocked, and keep a separate backup. There is no general legal requirement to use a particular brand or AES rating.
Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) makes it a criminal offence to record privately spoken words without authorisation, or to use or make such a recording available to others. Check that you have permission to record beforehand; buying a USB stick does not give you permission to record. For telephone recordings, the Data Protection Conference considers consent from the other person on the call generally necessary under data protection law; its statement refers specifically to telephone conversations.
Check the size of the individual file and the file system: Microsoft gives FAT32 a maximum individual file size of 4 GiB. Back up any existing files before reformatting, and check which formats your recording device and work computer can read.
Check the connector and unlocking method on the specific computer, and decide who unlocks the stick and when it should be locked again or removed. Also decide where authorised people can find a separate copy. Encryption doesn’t automatically make a shared computer trustworthy.
Check how access codes are managed and what happens after incorrect attempts or when updates are needed. For Keypad Secure #49429, Verbatim says the stick must be reformatted after 20 incorrect code entries and points to a security update. Check the manufacturer’s instructions and keep an independent copy of your files.