Which option is right for you?

Teams with a growing video archive

If completed projects are usually kept at a fixed workspace, you’ll need enough archive capacity, room for a desktop drive and a separate backup.

Teams with important original files

If you keep irreplaceable project files, plan for a separate copy and check regularly that you can restore it. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends testing your backups by restoring them.

Teams using several computers

If several workstations need access to the same projects, decide whether sharing files through one computer will be enough or whether you need centrally managed network storage. Synology describes shared access via SMB, with configurable access permissions.

What to look for when buying

First, decide whether the archive will mostly stay in one place, be moved around regularly or be used by several computers at the same time.

External desktop HDD

A good fit if: completed projects are mostly kept at a fixed workspace.

Keep in mind: A direct USB connection won’t automatically make the drive available to several computers. You’ll also need to plan for a separate backup.

Portable HDD

A good fit if: you need to take project files between workstations and frequent, fast transfers aren’t a priority.

Keep in mind: Toshiba lists the Canvio Flex with up to 4 TB of storage. Check whether that will be enough for your growing archive.

External SSD

A good fit if: you regularly transfer large video files or need a portable working drive.

Keep in mind: The Samsung T9 reviewed here has 4 TB of storage. Its advertised top speed requires a compatible host, a suitable cable and UASP enabled.

NAS or network share

A good fit if: several authorised computers need simultaneous access to a central project archive.

Keep in mind: A NAS needs to be set up and managed. RAID still doesn’t replace an additional backup.

What you need What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Archive capacity Work out how much you have and how much you expect it to grow in TB; plan capacity separately for the archive and its backup. If I keep completed projects at a fixed workspace, I need room for growth and a second copy; around 36% of consumers put archive capacity first.
Restoration and backup Choose a separate storage location and backup process, then test that you can restore your files. If I have irreplaceable original files, I want a separate copy that I can restore; around 29% of consumers prioritise recoverability and independent backups.
Shared access Check how many computers need access, how files will be shared and what user permissions are required. If several computers need the same projects, I need a suitable sharing solution rather than just a USB drive; around 21% of consumers prioritise shared access and permissions.
Speed and compatibility Check the host connection and cable; choose the operating system and file system before formatting. If I transfer files frequently, I want to know that the drive, host and cable work together and that the file system is supported; around 14% of consumers put speed and computer compatibility first.

Common pitfalls

  • Relying on a large archive drive as your only backup

    A fault or loss could then affect your only copy of a project, too. RAID doesn’t solve this underlying problem.

    Keep your archive and backup separate, and test that you can restore your files. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends regular restoration tests.

    You’ll need to set aside a separate backup drive and time to test restoring your files.

  • Assuming an advertised SSD speed is guaranteed in practice

    The Samsung T9’s advertised maximum depends on the host, cable and UASP mode being enabled.

    Check the connections at both ends and the cable you’re using. Don’t treat the manufacturer’s figures as a measured result for your workspace.

  • Confusing a directly connected drive with shared team storage

    Plugging a USB drive into one computer doesn’t automatically give other computers simultaneous network access or managed user permissions.

    Before buying, decide how you’ll share the files and who should be able to access the projects.

    A network share may need additional setup and ongoing management. A NAS solution also requires a suitable network device.

  • Leaving file system and backup requirements until after copying your files

    A drive set up for a particular computer or backup method won’t necessarily suit every other use.

    First, check which operating systems and backup methods are involved, and back up any existing files before reformatting.

    Changing the format may mean transferring your data again or buying extra storage for another copy.

Brands to consider

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a range of external hard drives designed to stay in one place.

  • Seagate’s EMEA data sheet lists Expansion Desktop models with 16 TB and 20 TB, USB 3.0 and a power adapter.
  • A desktop drive needs a suitable place to sit and a power socket. Make sure the capacity of the specific model suits your archive and backup plan.

Western Digital

My Book and WD_Black D10 are two different ranges of external hard drives.

  • The My Book models featured in the German desktop HDD comparison include 12 TB and 14 TB options.
  • Capacity and features vary between models, so check the exact version and plan for an independent backup.

Toshiba

Canvio Flex is a portable HDD for moving files between compatible computers.

  • Toshiba lists capacities of up to 4 TB and includes USB-A and USB-C cables.
  • Check that the capacity will be enough for your growing archive and that the connection is compatible with the computers you use.

Samsung

The portable T9 SSD is designed for mobile work and file transfers.

  • The model reviewed here has 4 TB of storage. Samsung advertises sequential transfer speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s.
  • According to Samsung, this maximum requires USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 on both the host and cable, as well as UASP enabled. It hasn’t been measured here.

Synology

NAS systems can provide the basis for centrally managed storage with network access.

  • Synology describes shared access via SMB, with configurable user permissions.
  • Synology points out that RAID isn’t a backup. Choose the NAS model, network and drives to suit your specific needs.

Joybuy products

This selection includes external desktop and portable hard drives, as well as portable SSDs for stationary archiving or more frequent transfers.

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 8 TB

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 8 TB

For a video archive kept in one place where a desktop drive is the right choice.

8 TB, 3.5 inches and USB 3.0. Requires a mains connection; the product description says it needs reformatting for macOS.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable, 5 TB, with USB-C

WD Elements Portable, 5 TB, USB-C

For an archive you need to carry between compatible workstations.

5 TB, 2.5 inches and 240 g; the product description says it works with Windows and Mac.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable, 2 TB, with USB-C and exFAT

WD Elements Portable, 2 TB, USB-C

For a portable archive that, according to the product description, can be used with Windows and macOS.

2 TB, 2.5 inches, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and pre-formatted exFAT.

Joybuy
Samsung T7 Portable SSD, 4 TB, in Titanium Grey

Samsung T7 Portable SSD, 4 TB, Titanium Grey

For a portable archive where frequent file transfers are important.

4 TB and USB 3.2 Gen 2. The product description lists read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,000 MB/s, plus USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A cables.

Joybuy
Samsung MU-PG2T0B portable SSD, 2 TB

Samsung MU-PG2T0B Portable SSD, 2 TB

For a portable archive where an SSD with a USB-C connection could be a good option.

2 TB and USB 3.2 Gen 2; the product description lists USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A cables.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can several people access a USB hard drive connected to a shared computer at the same time?

Not just by plugging it in via USB. If you want the computer to share the drive over a network, you’ll need to set up file sharing and keep the host computer available. For independent central storage, a suitably configured NAS is an option.

Which file system should I use when switching between Mac and Windows?

If you want to work directly with files on both systems, exFAT is an option worth considering. Apple describes exFAT as compatible with Windows and notes that macOS can read NTFS but can’t write to it. Back up any existing data before reformatting a drive.

Can the video archive also be your only backup?

No, not if you want to protect your projects from loss. Plan for a separate backup and test that you can restore it. Synology also states that RAID on a NAS isn’t a backup.

Are there data protection requirements for video recordings of people?

People who can be identified in video recordings may count as personal data. The European Data Protection Board describes technical and organisational safeguards that are appropriate to the level of risk. The measures required for a specific project depend on how the data is processed.