Which drive is right for you?

Owners of large video archives

If you want to store lots of footage and leave room for more, start by working out the size of your library, then choose a capacity that suits it. COMPUTER BILD’s review also looks at the capacity options available with large desktop drives.

Keepers of irreplaceable footage

If you want to recover videos after a drive failure or accidental deletion, you’ll need a separate copy and should check that you can restore it. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security also recommends making sure that backed-up data can be restored.

Video editors on the move

If you take projects with you or regularly transfer large files, compare portable HDDs and SSDs for capacity, connection and how you actually work. The portable drives tested differ in factors such as access times and design; manufacturers’ speed claims don’t automatically reflect performance on your computer.

What should you look for when buying?

What matters to you What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Capacity and future growth Allow for the size of your existing videos and expected growth; check the capacity of the specific model. If your library already takes up a lot of space or is still growing, make sure there’s enough room for your footage. Around 36% of consumers put capacity first.
Recoverability Decide where to keep your originals and separate backup copy; try restoring a file. With irreplaceable videos, being able to recover them after a drive failure or accidental deletion is crucial. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Speed and portability Consider how often you transfer files and how large they are, as well as the drive, computer port and cable. If you regularly copy large projects or edit on the move, consider how the drive will fit into your transport and transfer routine. Around 21% of consumers put transfers and portability first.
Compatibility and set-up Check that your operating system, connection and file system work with your chosen backup software. If you want to set up the drive for Time Machine or Windows File History, check the format and which folders are included first. Around 14% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their devices.

Common mistakes when choosing and backing up

  • Moving your only copy of your videos to an external drive and calling it a backup

    If that drive fails, you won’t have an independent copy. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security also recommends checking that backed-up data can be restored.

    Keep your originals and an extra copy separately, and try restoring some files.

    You’ll need to allow for an additional backup destination, time for regular backups and recovery tests.

  • Choosing an SSD based only on its advertised speed

    Kingston quotes a maximum of 2,000 MB/s for the XS2000 over USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. This is a manufacturer’s maximum figure, not a guarantee of the speed you’ll get on every computer. For a large archive, capacity may matter more.

    Check your computer’s port and cable, and compare the capacity of the specific model with your library before making speed your top priority.

  • Reformatting a Windows-formatted HDD for a Mac without backing it up first

    The drive needs to use a compatible volume format for the stated Time Machine use. Apple notes that reformatting erases any existing data on the drive.

    Check the drive and its contents before reformatting, and save any important files elsewhere first.

Key brands at a glance

Seagate

The Expansion Desktop Drive is a useful reference point for large video archives that will mostly stay in one place.

  • COMPUTER BILD ranked the 16-TB version first in its test of desktop 3.5-inch drives and praised its high speed.
  • The test result applies to this model. A single hard drive won’t protect you if the drive itself fails.

Western Digital

In the cited tests, My Book represents desktop models, while My Passport is a portable option for taking with you.

  • COMPUTER BILD featured the 12 and 14 TB My Book models in a test of desktop drives, and the 6 TB My Passport in a separate test of portable HDDs.
  • The rankings come from separate comparison lists and shouldn’t be taken as an overall brand rating.

Toshiba

According to Toshiba Storage Solutions EMEA, Canvio Advance is a portable, USB-powered HDD available in capacities up to 4 TB.

  • Toshiba lists downloadable backup and security software.
  • The stated NTFS file system is designed for Windows; you’ll need to reformat the drive for the Mac use described here.

Intenso

According to the manufacturer, the portable Memory Case is designed for videos and other files, with documented versions available up to 5 TB.

  • The 5-TB version ranked second in a separate test of portable HDDs.
  • Slower read access was noted as a drawback in the same test.

Kingston

The XS2000 is a portable SSD option for frequent transfers or video work, provided the capacity of your chosen model is enough.

  • Kingston lists versions up to 4 TB and a maximum speed of 2,000 MB/s over USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.
  • The manufacturer’s maximum figure isn’t a measurement of performance on your computer. If you have a larger archive, check the capacity you need before focusing on speed.

Joybuy products for video storage and backup

The models below include portable HDDs, a desktop HDD and a portable SSD for storing videos, taking them with you and transferring files.

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

A portable HDD for videos you want to take between locations.

5 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

A portable HDD for videos you want to take between locations.

6 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

A portable HDD for videos you want to take between locations.

4 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 6 TB desktop external hard drive, USB 3.0, 3.5-inch, NTFS, black

WD Elements 6 TB Desktop External Hard Drive

A desktop HDD for videos that will mostly be stored in one place.

6 TB; USB 3.0; 3.5 inches; NTFS.

Requires an external power supply and a mains socket while in use. You’ll need to reformat it for the Mac use described here.

View at Joybuy
KEXIN external SSD, 256 GB, USB 3.1 Type-C

KEXIN external SSD 256 GB

A portable SSD for a limited video or project collection, if the stated capacity is enough.

256 GB; USB 3.1 Type-C; stated maximum transfer speed of up to 500 MB/s.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose a capacity if I’m already running short on internal storage?

Work out the size of your existing video files and leave room for more. If you also plan to store backup versions on the external drive, allow for their storage needs too. Keep an independent copy in a separate location.

Can I use a Windows-formatted hard drive as a Time Machine volume without changing it?

No, a Windows-formatted volume needs to be reformatted for Time Machine. Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted); reformatting erases any existing files on the volume. Save them elsewhere first.

How do I back up and check my videos on Windows?

Windows File History can back up to an external drive and restore previous file versions. Microsoft lists videos in the default libraries. If your files are in a different folder, check that it’s included, then try restoring a test file.

Who should I contact if a newly purchased drive is faulty, and will that replace my videos?

If a product is faulty, the seller is generally your point of contact for your statutory rights; these are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee. Your statutory rights don’t replace a separate, recoverable copy of your videos.

Can I put an old external hard drive in household rubbish in Germany?

No, electrical and electronic waste must be collected separately. Germany’s Federal Environment Agency lists local recycling centres and suitable retail take-back points as options. Before passing on or disposing of a drive, securely erase personal videos and other private data, or check that existing access protection is in place.